AI summary by TwinMind
How the USA Colonized the USA, Mapped
Johnny Harris
17m 40s
Continental Context and Louisiana Purchase (1803)
- North America contained dramatic landscapes from ocean shorelines to Alpine Mountains and sandy deserts
- Hundreds/thousands of different nations/tribes lived across continent as original inhabitants
- Spring 1803: Two American politicians in Paris closed Louisiana Purchase deal
- US doubled in size for $15 million
- US bought imperial rights from France, not actual land ownership
- France agreed to stay out of way, let US colonize without interference
- Land belonged to native tribes who had lived there thousands of years before Europeans
- US knew land wasn't theirs, planned to buy from original inhabitants
Early US Policy and George Washington's Ideals
- George Washington determined US Indian Affairs administration would follow "great principles of justice and Humanity"
- Plan: negotiate formal treaties instead of conquest
- Pay tribes "fair and square" for land
- US founding document emphasized justice, tranquility, welfare, liberty
- Initial peaceful transactional process
- US offered food, farming equipment, cash, blacksmith services
- In exchange for land ownership
Early Treaty Violations and Military Conflicts
- Many tribes refused to leave ancestral lands for farming equipment
- Washington's ideals of justice/humanity dissolved as US needed more land for booming population
- Westward Movement described as "great tidal wave"
Great Lakes Region Conflict
- Tribes near Great Lakes refused to sell land
- Established river as border, told US not to cross
- US went to war, lost twice
- Third battle: US won, forced tribes to sign treaty
- Result: tribes gave away all of present-day Ohio
Seminole Conflict
- Seminole tribes refused to leave land
- US military intervention, war killed thousands
- Forced tribes to sign treaty, pushed into swampy interior
- Lost access to farmland and ocean
Mogi Nation Deception
- Mogi refused relocation treaty but agreed to sell portion of land
- US guaranteed they could keep rest of ancestral lands
- Four years later: white settlers moved in, boxing out Mogi
- US military forced Mogi out without any treaty signed
Deceptive Treaty Practices
- Range of shenanigans to obtain land:
- Getting tribal leaders drunk to trick them into signing papers
- Appointing random people as tribal leaders to sign away land
- Breaking peace treaties when resources discovered
Sioux and Arapaho Case Study
- Nations defeated US military repeatedly
- US finally signed peace treaty acknowledging their land
- 8 years later: gold discovered
- US broke treaty, redrew boundaries, built roads on tribal land
- White prospectors with gold pans harvested the land
Systematic Treaty Process
- Other tribes realized refusing meant violence, so signed papers and left
- Over almost 100 years: US signed 368 treaties with tribal nations
- All tribes "driven out one way or another" for white settlers
- Created "facade of justice" - "thinly veiled campaign for Imperial Conquest"
Five Civilized Tribes and Cotton Economy
- Deep South had five large nations living alongside settlers
- Had signed treaties with US acknowledging their land rights
- Many spoke English, practiced farming, wore European clothes, some owned slaves
- Known as Five Civilized Tribes: Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, Mogi, Seminole
- Alternative world possible where they remained living side by side
Cotton Kingdom Expansion
- Southern farmers getting rich off cotton crop sold to textile mills worldwide
- Industry made profitable by free labor from stolen Africans
- Black Belt Prairie strip particularly desirable for cotton farming
- Land locked up in treaties acknowledging native nation ownership
- Southern slave owners wanted to expand cotton kingdom
- Georgia particularly aggressive, governor wanted to replace "all of the red with white population"
Cherokee Legal Victory and Andrew Jackson's Response
- Georgia targeted Cherokee Nation, passed law abolishing their governments
- Cherokee fought back using US legal system, took Georgia to court
- Case went to Supreme Court - Cherokee Nation won
- Supreme Court ruled states could not impose on tribal sovereignty
- Andrew Jackson (on $20 bill) refused to enforce ruling
- Jackson had written to wife in War of 1812 about successfully slaughtering 170 Native Americans "in elegant style"
- Jackson's snarky response: "Chief Justice John Marshall has made his decision, now let him enforce it"
Indian Removal Act of 1830
- Jackson pushed law through both houses of Congress
- Used taxpayer money to relocate tribes to uninhabitable Great Plains
- Promised "we will never mess with you again"
- Law claimed negotiations must be "fairly, voluntarily, peacefully"
- Government would "forever secure and guarantee" new land
- Promised not to break pre-existing treaty agreements
- All pretending - "paper trail of pretend Humanity"
- Jackson had no intention of following law he helped create
- Orchestrated "mass ethnic cleansing sanctioned by government, paid for by taxes"
Implementation of Removal
- US government, military, private companies ramped up removal efforts
- Focused on five tribes sitting on desired cotton empire land
- More bribes, pretended negotiations, threats of violence
Cherokee Fraudulent Treaty
- Cherokee eventually signed treaty agreeing to sell last portion of land
- Problem: leader who signed had no authority to make decision
- Not actual Cherokee leader
- Real Cherokee Chief furiously protested
- US didn't care - had signature, considered all justified
Trail of Tears (1831-1838)
- Nearly every member from five tribes expelled from land
- 100,000 people forced to walk over 1,000 miles on foot
- Brutal weather and terrain to "little box on map" they'd never seen
- Cherokee called it "trail where we cried" or Trail of Tears
- Some fought back, others stood ground until forcibly bound in chains by US government
- Herded west at gunpoint
- Land became vacant, cotton farmers with slaves moved in, economy grew
Death Toll and Documentation
- Unknown exact death toll: estimates range 3,000-15,000 lives lost
- Systematic, documented, enshrined in law
- Complete paper trail: receipts, payments, treaties, bureaucracy
- "Spreadsheets from 1800s"
- First state-sponsored ethnic cleansing by American settlers
- Hitler referenced this exact process 100 years later for his own ethnic cleansing
- Said Volga River would be "our Mississippi"
- "Europe not America would be land of unlimited possibilities"
Future Content Preview
- Story doesn't end here - beginning of longer process
- Part two will cover what happens when tribes arrive at Indian Territory
- How tribes tried to fight back using legal frameworks that pushed them out
- Led to establishment of one state that could have looked very different
