AI summary by TwinMind

How to Close the Authority Gap | Mary Ann Sieghart | TED

TED

12m 50s

Personal Experience and Definition of Authority Gap

  • Speaker (MAS) recounts conference interaction where man called her "busy little girl" despite extensive professional portfolio
    • Portfolio included: political column for The Independent, BBC radio programs, think tank chair, commercial boards, Tate Modern council, Ofcom content board
    • Speaker was ~50 years old, older than Prime Minister at time
  • Defines "authority gap" as tendency to take women less seriously than men
    • Reluctance to accord authority to women
    • Men assumed competent until proven otherwise; women assumed incompetent until proven otherwise

Research Evidence on Gender Authority Disparities

  • Men have 6x more influence in group discussions than women
  • Women 2x more likely to say they must provide evidence of competence
  • Women 2x more likely to report people surprised at their abilities
  • Women of color experience this more than white women
  • Working-class/disabled women face even larger gaps
  • Authority gap widens further from "white, male, middle class default"

Professional Examples Across Hierarchies

  • Female US Supreme Court justices interrupted 3x more than male justices
    • 96% of interruptions by men
  • Pattern exists regardless of position: presidents, CEOs, Supreme Court justices all affected

Transgender Experience as Scientific Evidence

  • Transgender individuals provide controlled experiment (same person, abilities, intelligence, personality, experience)
  • Ben Barres (neuroscientist, transitioned to male):
    • "I'm taken more seriously" - thought this "million times"
    • Academic overheard saying "Ben Barris gave great seminar, work much better than his sister's" (not knowing history)
  • Joan Roughgarden (evolutionary biologist, transitioned to female):
    • As male: "conveyor belt to success" - pay increased, promotions, people listened
    • As female: interrupted, challenged, personally attacked, points ignored until men repeated them
    • Initially amused by discrimination, then "thrill wore off"

Benefits of Gender Equality for Men

  • Narrowing authority gap not zero-sum ("not like seesaw")
  • Research shows in gender-equal countries/US states and equal relationships:
    • Men 2x more likely to say satisfied with lives
    • Men 50% less likely to be depressed
    • Men smoke less, drink less, sleep better, take fewer drugs
    • Men get more frequent and better sex
  • Children happier, healthier, better school performance, better relationships with fathers, fewer behavioral difficulties
  • Women less resentful, exhausted, feel more part of team

Solutions Overview

  • Speaker developed 140 solutions total
  • Focus: not fixing women, but changing perceptions and interactions with women
  • Need changes to: ourselves, workplaces, world around us
  • Even women biased against other women

Individual Actions

  • Notice when brain tries to trick us with gender bias
  • "Flip test": ask "would I think/say/do this if person were man instead of woman?"
  • Examples: wouldn't mistake male CEO for assistant, wouldn't call 50-year-old man "busy little boy"
  • Actively affirm women's contributions at work (when interesting)
  • Address interruptions: "Hang on, I was interested in what Rosa was saying"
  • Credit original speaker: "I'm glad you agree with what Evie said earlier"

Workplace Statistics and Hiring Practices

  • Women make up 40% of group but 50% less likely to gain approval, more likely interrupted
  • 70% of men rate men more highly than women for same achievements
  • Women with same qualifications 30% less likely called for job interviews
  • One woman on shortlist = vanishingly small hiring chances (signals men are natural job holders)
  • Adding one more woman to shortlist makes hiring woman 79x more likely

Employer Recommendations

  • Ensure genuine merit-based hiring and promotion
  • Actively encourage talented women to apply for promotion
  • Women socialized to be less confident, less self-promoting
  • Confident women often disliked, called "strident" or "pushy"
  • Speaker caricatured as "Mary Ann Bighead" in Private Eye magazine for acting confident like male colleagues
  • Don't mistake confidence for competence - they're not the same

Confidence vs. Competence Research

  • Academic paper: "Bullshitters. Who Are They and What Do We Know about Their Lives"
  • Teenage boys significantly more likely than girls to pretend understanding non-existent mathematical concepts
  • Male overconfidence persists into adulthood
  • Taking overconfident men at word leads to hiring/promoting them over more competent female rivals

Media Representation Impact

  • Media signals men more authoritative, expert, important than women
  • Current statistics:
    • Men 3x more likely quoted in news stories
    • Men 2x more likely protagonists in movies
  • BBC push for 50% female experts on air could impact next generation
  • Seeing women as public authorities makes easier to accord equal authority in daily life

Conclusion and Call to Action

  • Quote from Mary McAleese (former Irish president): "If men don't take women equally seriously, we end up with world that flies on one wing"
  • World "flapping about sadly" due to refusal to use elevation, direction, confidence from flying on two wings
  • When women flourish, world flourishes, men flourish, all flourish

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome