AI summary by TwinMind
How to Close the Authority Gap | Mary Ann Sieghart | TED
TED
12m 50s
Personal Experience and Definition of Authority Gap
- Speaker (MAS) recounts conference interaction where man called her "busy little girl" despite extensive professional portfolio
- Portfolio included: political column for The Independent, BBC radio programs, think tank chair, commercial boards, Tate Modern council, Ofcom content board
- Speaker was ~50 years old, older than Prime Minister at time
- Defines "authority gap" as tendency to take women less seriously than men
- Reluctance to accord authority to women
- Men assumed competent until proven otherwise; women assumed incompetent until proven otherwise
Research Evidence on Gender Authority Disparities
- Men have 6x more influence in group discussions than women
- Women 2x more likely to say they must provide evidence of competence
- Women 2x more likely to report people surprised at their abilities
- Women of color experience this more than white women
- Working-class/disabled women face even larger gaps
- Authority gap widens further from "white, male, middle class default"
Professional Examples Across Hierarchies
- Female US Supreme Court justices interrupted 3x more than male justices
- 96% of interruptions by men
- Pattern exists regardless of position: presidents, CEOs, Supreme Court justices all affected
Transgender Experience as Scientific Evidence
- Transgender individuals provide controlled experiment (same person, abilities, intelligence, personality, experience)
- Ben Barres (neuroscientist, transitioned to male):
- "I'm taken more seriously" - thought this "million times"
- Academic overheard saying "Ben Barris gave great seminar, work much better than his sister's" (not knowing history)
- Joan Roughgarden (evolutionary biologist, transitioned to female):
- As male: "conveyor belt to success" - pay increased, promotions, people listened
- As female: interrupted, challenged, personally attacked, points ignored until men repeated them
- Initially amused by discrimination, then "thrill wore off"
Benefits of Gender Equality for Men
- Narrowing authority gap not zero-sum ("not like seesaw")
- Research shows in gender-equal countries/US states and equal relationships:
- Men 2x more likely to say satisfied with lives
- Men 50% less likely to be depressed
- Men smoke less, drink less, sleep better, take fewer drugs
- Men get more frequent and better sex
- Children happier, healthier, better school performance, better relationships with fathers, fewer behavioral difficulties
- Women less resentful, exhausted, feel more part of team
Solutions Overview
- Speaker developed 140 solutions total
- Focus: not fixing women, but changing perceptions and interactions with women
- Need changes to: ourselves, workplaces, world around us
- Even women biased against other women
Individual Actions
- Notice when brain tries to trick us with gender bias
- "Flip test": ask "would I think/say/do this if person were man instead of woman?"
- Examples: wouldn't mistake male CEO for assistant, wouldn't call 50-year-old man "busy little boy"
- Actively affirm women's contributions at work (when interesting)
- Address interruptions: "Hang on, I was interested in what Rosa was saying"
- Credit original speaker: "I'm glad you agree with what Evie said earlier"
Workplace Statistics and Hiring Practices
- Women make up 40% of group but 50% less likely to gain approval, more likely interrupted
- 70% of men rate men more highly than women for same achievements
- Women with same qualifications 30% less likely called for job interviews
- One woman on shortlist = vanishingly small hiring chances (signals men are natural job holders)
- Adding one more woman to shortlist makes hiring woman 79x more likely
Employer Recommendations
- Ensure genuine merit-based hiring and promotion
- Actively encourage talented women to apply for promotion
- Women socialized to be less confident, less self-promoting
- Confident women often disliked, called "strident" or "pushy"
- Speaker caricatured as "Mary Ann Bighead" in Private Eye magazine for acting confident like male colleagues
- Don't mistake confidence for competence - they're not the same
Confidence vs. Competence Research
- Academic paper: "Bullshitters. Who Are They and What Do We Know about Their Lives"
- Teenage boys significantly more likely than girls to pretend understanding non-existent mathematical concepts
- Male overconfidence persists into adulthood
- Taking overconfident men at word leads to hiring/promoting them over more competent female rivals
Media Representation Impact
- Media signals men more authoritative, expert, important than women
- Current statistics:
- Men 3x more likely quoted in news stories
- Men 2x more likely protagonists in movies
- BBC push for 50% female experts on air could impact next generation
- Seeing women as public authorities makes easier to accord equal authority in daily life
Conclusion and Call to Action
- Quote from Mary McAleese (former Irish president): "If men don't take women equally seriously, we end up with world that flies on one wing"
- World "flapping about sadly" due to refusal to use elevation, direction, confidence from flying on two wings
- When women flourish, world flourishes, men flourish, all flourish
