AI summary by TwinMind

How to Control a Crowd

Wendover Productions

21m 55s

Black Friday Disaster Scenario

  • Electronic store selling 9th gen game consoles at massive discount
  • Three per person limit creates arbitrage opportunity (hundreds of dollars profit)
  • Mass of people fills pedestrian mall width, growing before 9 AM opening
  • Security arrives 8 AM, announces only 500 consoles available
  • Crowd refuses to form orderly line
  • Security lets small groups in from front
  • 30 minutes later: predictable crowd crush occurs
    • Back of crowd pushes forward (concerned about dwindling supply)
    • Core gets compacted, individuals lose movement ability
    • People get asphyxiated from compression
    • Three groups with different incentives: back wants consoles, security keeps crowd out, core wants to survive

Debunking Traditional Crowd Psychology

  • Antiquated view: mass gatherings devolve into mindless state, dehumanize individuals
  • Recent research dispels this notion
  • In emergencies, people do exact opposite of selfish behavior
  • Of 21 major crowd crushes this decade, only 2 involved people running from deadly threat
    • Yemen: electrical explosion
    • Egypt: church fire worshipers fleeing
  • Counter-intuitive: running from fire stronger incentive than buying console, yet lower crush frequency

Identity and Cooperation in Crowds

  • Flight example: normal flight = no interaction, delayed flight = cooperation emerges
  • Canceled flight = even more cooperation (sharing rental cars)
  • Explanation: shared identity concentrates during distress
    • Normal: weak "traveler" identity
    • Delayed: strong "distressed traveler" identity
  • Greater shared identity = greater cooperation
  • Study: London Underground simulation - participants more likely to help person wearing their team's jersey
  • Most events involve shared identity (fans, religious followers, protesters)

Evacuation-Based Crushes Rarity

  • London Underground bombings 2005: victims showed perceived unity, selfless cooperative behavior
  • High degree of crowd cooperation in disasters, leading to orderly crush-free evacuations
  • Civil unrest crushes also rare
  • Only major riot crush this decade: 2022 Kanjuruhan Stadium, Indonesia (caused by police tear gas, not riot itself)
  • Last major riot crush: 2016 Ethiopia protests (also police intervention)
  • Riots feature low competitiveness, strong shared identity = low crush potential

Hajj Pilgrimage Analysis

  • 2+ million Muslims descend on Mecca annually
  • Strong shared identities: Muslim + Pilgrim + state of Ihram (ritualistic purity)
  • Yet home to 20th and 21st century's deadliest crowd crushes (1000+ dead each)
  • Study of Kaaba prayer areas:
    • Plaza: best unobstructed view, equal experience
    • Balconies: pillars obstruct view, variable experience based on pushing/shoving
  • Balconies showed lower crowd cooperativeness
  • Key finding: competitiveness up = cooperativeness down

Concert Venue Crush Scenarios

  • Predictable scenario: people spend money on tickets, arrive at stadium, event starting but still outside
  • Examples of this dynamic:
    • 2023 San Salvador, El Salvador
    • 2022 Yaoundé, Cameroon
    • 2019 Antananarivo, Madagascar
    • 2017 Luanda, Angola
  • Unassigned seating creates competition for best view
  • Bands and fans prefer unassigned floor seating (high energy, dynamic) over assigned seats (boring, clinical)

The Who Concert Disaster 1979

  • December 3, 1979, Cincinnati Riverfront Stadium
  • 18,348 unassigned seats sold out
  • Competition for best position led to afternoon lineup outside venue
  • Evening arrival, crowd grew cold waiting
  • Only 2 doors opened for nearly 20,000 people
  • Late sound check mistaken for concert start
  • Push began from back, pressure felt at front
  • 11 dead, dozens injured
  • Aftermath blamed character, substances, rock culture
  • Real cause: bad design - understaffed security, only 2 doors for 20,000 people
  • At 5+ people per square meter: individuals lose movement control, fluid dynamics principles apply

Post-Who Disaster Changes

  • Cincinnati banned general admission concerts 1979-2004 (24.5 years)
  • US cities adopted stricter event regulations
  • National Fire Protection Association rethought life safety codes
  • Today: most seats assigned, unassigned heavily monitored
  • Entry/exit strategies heavily planned, redundant, practiced

Recent Near-Misses and Incidents

  • 2020 European Football Championship, Wembley Stadium
    • 2,000 ticketless England fans forced entry
    • 6,000 additional fans ready to charge if England won
    • Event on "razor's edge" of deadly disaster
  • January 2023 Sheffield Wednesday playoff game
    • Fans packed into narrow concourses
    • Turnstiles opened 30 minutes early
    • People hoisting crying kids to relieve pressure

AstroWorld Festival 2021

  • Houston Energy Park, designed for 200,000 people
  • Capacity lowered to 50,000 by fire chief
  • Two-stage layout expected crowd dispersion
  • Secondary stage music ended, Travis Scott delayed primary stage start
  • Crowd shifted from west to north stage
  • Barricades created effective corral
  • All 10 deaths occurred in this quadrant
  • Bad timing + bad barricade configuration

Saudi Arabia's Hajj Infrastructure Investment

  • Bridge complex existing since 1960s
  • Sole conduit for millions of pilgrims from Mina tent city to Jamarat pillars
  • 2004: 251 pilgrims died, Saudi government altered pillar walls
  • 2006: 345 died on bridge entry ramp
  • $1 billion reconfiguration:
    • Bridge widened by 260 feet (80 meters)
    • 4 additional floors added
    • Massive sun awning
    • Capacity: 500,000+ pilgrims per hour
  • Nearly 2 decades later: bridge handles growing crowds successfully

2015 Mina Stampede

  • Worst Saudi crowd crush ever: estimated 2,400 deaths
  • Location: intersection of pedestrian streets 206, 223, 204
  • Simple T-intersection choke point
  • Hours away from impressive crowd control infrastructure
  • Problem relocated to infrastructure's nearest weak point
  • Became geopolitical issue, deteriorated Saudi-Iranian relations

Modern Hajj System Success

  • After 2015 disaster, Saudi Arabia invested heavily in safer, efficient system
  • Combines infrastructure, technology, psychology
  • Modern Hajj perhaps most organized event in world
  • Accident-free since 2015 crush

Risk Mitigation Principles

  • Prediction easier in retrospect
  • For every deadly crush: countless successful rowdy events
  • People love risky situations
  • Key difference: proper planning to mitigate crush potential
  • Three critical steps:
    1. Knowledge of risk factors
    2. Ability to identify when things get out of control
    3. Ability to respond appropriately
  • Almost every incident involves failure of one of these steps
  • Culpability for why crushes occur is almost inevitably predictable

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome