AI summary by TwinMind

How To Convert Customers With Cold Emails | Startup School

Y Combinator

32m 46s

Introduction & Best Email Outreach Hack

  • Aaron Epstein, YC Group Partner, presents comprehensive cold email strategy
  • #1 hack: Get warm intros - 2-3x higher conversion rates vs cold emails
  • Methods for warm intros:
    • Use LinkedIn network, contacts, friends of friends
    • Current/former co-workers
    • School alumni networks
    • Employer alumni networks from past companies
    • Turn over every rock to find connections

Mapping Your Email Funnel

  • Start with specific goal (e.g., get 1 new customer)
  • Work backwards to build conversion funnel
  • Sample B2B software funnel:
    • Demo to customer: 10% conversion rate
    • Need 10 demos for 1 customer
    • Email response to demo signup: 25% conversion rate
    • Need 40 responses for 10 demos
    • Email opens to responses: 10% conversion rate
    • Need 400 opens for 40 responses
    • Emails sent to opens: 50% conversion rate
    • Need 800 emails sent for 1 customer
  • Must send dozens of emails daily (possibly 50+)
  • Start manually, not with automation
  • Goal: get to next funnel step, not immediate sale
  • Track and measure conversion rates at each step
  • Conversion rates decrease as you scale
  • Fix low conversion rates before scaling

Increasing Open Rates

  • Most effective method: Better targeting
    • Find people who actually want your product
    • Better to send 100 targeted emails than 1000 untargeted
    • Get better at lead qualification over time
  • Email client display elements:
    • Sender name (use personal name, not company)
    • Subject line (short, relevant, interesting)
    • Preview text (first sentence)
  • Good subject line examples:
    • "Hey quick question"
    • "Can I get your advice"
    • "Help a fellow founder"
    • "Hello from [company name]"
  • Preferred contact channels:
    • Email usually better than LinkedIn
    • Text messaging only with explicit permission
    • Adapt based on industry norms

Finding Email Addresses

  • Ask mutual connections for email address (intro preferred)
  • Connect on LinkedIn
  • Check personal blogs/websites
  • Use LinkedIn Sales Navigator
  • Guess based on company email format
  • Tools: apollo.io, hunter.io, clearbit

Building Your Brand

  • Early stage: company brand won't help, you are the brand
  • Personal attention and effort stands out
  • Include personal cell phone number
  • Show you care and go above and beyond
  • People bet on you personally, not just company
  • Highest ROI still comes from better targeting

Seven Principles of Effective Email Copy

1. Have Focused Specific Goal

  • Single outcome focus (respond, click, intro)
  • Avoid paradox of choice with multiple asks
  • Every word should drive toward goal
  • Delete anything not moving toward goal

2. Be Human

  • Use emotional language: "I'd love to", "would mean a lot", "I'd really appreciate"
  • Be informal: "hey" vs "hello" or "hello Mr. [name]"
  • No capitalization, typos okay
  • Use GIFs, videos, custom content for personalization
  • Write how you talk to a friend
  • Compose in email editor with specific person in mind
  • Read out loud to check if it sounds natural

3. Personalize

  • Everyone can smell spam immediately
  • Use recipient's name vs "hi there"
  • Be specific in personalization
  • Example: "huge fan since you launched photos category" vs "love what you're doing"
  • Find uncommon commonalities:
    • Things uniquely in common (not obvious like gender)
    • Same college, same buildings, shared experiences
    • Requires research: company, LinkedIn, use their product
    • Build deeper connections this way

4. Keep It Short

  • Wall of text = instant delete
  • Easy to read and respond on mobile
  • Enable quick reply/action in the moment
  • Long emails get archived or deleted

5. Establish Credibility

  • YC membership opens doors
  • Schools attended, companies worked at
  • Impressive accomplishments
  • Share well-known customer names as social proof
  • Industry-specific data/trends to establish expertise
  • Mention shared connections for baseline trust

6. Make It About Reader, Not You

  • Reframe "I" statements as "you" and "yours"
  • Tell story as quest to solve their problems
  • Works best if you've felt the problem yourself
  • Use language your users use to describe you
  • Ask users: "how would you describe my company?"
  • Don't make demands or set deadlines
  • Remember: you're in their inbox, on their time

7. Clear Call to Action

  • Concrete next step: "reply to let me know", "click here", "intro me to [name]"
  • Make it own paragraph/standalone sentence
  • Place right before sign-off
  • People scan to end to see what you're asking
  • Make it quick and easy to respond

Follow-Up Strategy

  • One email often not enough
  • Plan to follow up 2-3-4 times manually
  • Give few days between emails
  • Get creative with follow-ups (example: "free donuts" subject line)
  • Don't get angry if no response - nobody owes you anything
  • Check back in couple months if timing wasn't right

Email Examples Analysis

Bad Examples:

  1. Poor targeting: Shipping service pitched to digital download company
  2. Generic spam: "Hey there", no personalization, unclear ask, unsigned
  3. Self-focused: All about sender ("I, I, I"), not recipient needs

Good Examples:

  1. LinkedIn success: "Go Terps" - uncommon commonality (same college building), credibility (ex-Googlers), clear ask (review YC app), shows prior work done
  2. Creative Market recruiting: Template email that felt personal through exclusivity language, informal tone, special treatment
  3. Smoothie company before/after:
    • Before: Focused on their demo day goal
    • After: "Smoothie party" - focused on free benefit for recipient's team

Final Advice

  • Do manually first to learn, scale later
  • Block off hours per day for email outreach
  • Track and measure funnel conversion rates
  • Founders should send emails personally (higher response rates)
  • Send dozens of emails per day
  • Your advantage: can give personalized attention
  • Key principles: Personalize, be human, be persistent, do the work

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome