AI summary by TwinMind
How To Convert Customers With Cold Emails | Startup School
Y Combinator
32m 46s
Introduction & Best Email Outreach Hack
- Aaron Epstein, YC Group Partner, presents comprehensive cold email strategy
- #1 hack: Get warm intros - 2-3x higher conversion rates vs cold emails
- Methods for warm intros:
- Use LinkedIn network, contacts, friends of friends
- Current/former co-workers
- School alumni networks
- Employer alumni networks from past companies
- Turn over every rock to find connections
Mapping Your Email Funnel
- Start with specific goal (e.g., get 1 new customer)
- Work backwards to build conversion funnel
- Sample B2B software funnel:
- Demo to customer: 10% conversion rate
- Need 10 demos for 1 customer
- Email response to demo signup: 25% conversion rate
- Need 40 responses for 10 demos
- Email opens to responses: 10% conversion rate
- Need 400 opens for 40 responses
- Emails sent to opens: 50% conversion rate
- Need 800 emails sent for 1 customer
- Must send dozens of emails daily (possibly 50+)
- Start manually, not with automation
- Goal: get to next funnel step, not immediate sale
- Track and measure conversion rates at each step
- Conversion rates decrease as you scale
- Fix low conversion rates before scaling
Increasing Open Rates
- Most effective method: Better targeting
- Find people who actually want your product
- Better to send 100 targeted emails than 1000 untargeted
- Get better at lead qualification over time
- Email client display elements:
- Sender name (use personal name, not company)
- Subject line (short, relevant, interesting)
- Preview text (first sentence)
- Good subject line examples:
- "Hey quick question"
- "Can I get your advice"
- "Help a fellow founder"
- "Hello from [company name]"
- Preferred contact channels:
- Email usually better than LinkedIn
- Text messaging only with explicit permission
- Adapt based on industry norms
Finding Email Addresses
- Ask mutual connections for email address (intro preferred)
- Connect on LinkedIn
- Check personal blogs/websites
- Use LinkedIn Sales Navigator
- Guess based on company email format
- Tools: apollo.io, hunter.io, clearbit
Building Your Brand
- Early stage: company brand won't help, you are the brand
- Personal attention and effort stands out
- Include personal cell phone number
- Show you care and go above and beyond
- People bet on you personally, not just company
- Highest ROI still comes from better targeting
Seven Principles of Effective Email Copy
1. Have Focused Specific Goal
- Single outcome focus (respond, click, intro)
- Avoid paradox of choice with multiple asks
- Every word should drive toward goal
- Delete anything not moving toward goal
2. Be Human
- Use emotional language: "I'd love to", "would mean a lot", "I'd really appreciate"
- Be informal: "hey" vs "hello" or "hello Mr. [name]"
- No capitalization, typos okay
- Use GIFs, videos, custom content for personalization
- Write how you talk to a friend
- Compose in email editor with specific person in mind
- Read out loud to check if it sounds natural
3. Personalize
- Everyone can smell spam immediately
- Use recipient's name vs "hi there"
- Be specific in personalization
- Example: "huge fan since you launched photos category" vs "love what you're doing"
- Find uncommon commonalities:
- Things uniquely in common (not obvious like gender)
- Same college, same buildings, shared experiences
- Requires research: company, LinkedIn, use their product
- Build deeper connections this way
4. Keep It Short
- Wall of text = instant delete
- Easy to read and respond on mobile
- Enable quick reply/action in the moment
- Long emails get archived or deleted
5. Establish Credibility
- YC membership opens doors
- Schools attended, companies worked at
- Impressive accomplishments
- Share well-known customer names as social proof
- Industry-specific data/trends to establish expertise
- Mention shared connections for baseline trust
6. Make It About Reader, Not You
- Reframe "I" statements as "you" and "yours"
- Tell story as quest to solve their problems
- Works best if you've felt the problem yourself
- Use language your users use to describe you
- Ask users: "how would you describe my company?"
- Don't make demands or set deadlines
- Remember: you're in their inbox, on their time
7. Clear Call to Action
- Concrete next step: "reply to let me know", "click here", "intro me to [name]"
- Make it own paragraph/standalone sentence
- Place right before sign-off
- People scan to end to see what you're asking
- Make it quick and easy to respond
Follow-Up Strategy
- One email often not enough
- Plan to follow up 2-3-4 times manually
- Give few days between emails
- Get creative with follow-ups (example: "free donuts" subject line)
- Don't get angry if no response - nobody owes you anything
- Check back in couple months if timing wasn't right
Email Examples Analysis
Bad Examples:
- Poor targeting: Shipping service pitched to digital download company
- Generic spam: "Hey there", no personalization, unclear ask, unsigned
- Self-focused: All about sender ("I, I, I"), not recipient needs
Good Examples:
- LinkedIn success: "Go Terps" - uncommon commonality (same college building), credibility (ex-Googlers), clear ask (review YC app), shows prior work done
- Creative Market recruiting: Template email that felt personal through exclusivity language, informal tone, special treatment
- Smoothie company before/after:
- Before: Focused on their demo day goal
- After: "Smoothie party" - focused on free benefit for recipient's team
Final Advice
- Do manually first to learn, scale later
- Block off hours per day for email outreach
- Track and measure funnel conversion rates
- Founders should send emails personally (higher response rates)
- Send dozens of emails per day
- Your advantage: can give personalized attention
- Key principles: Personalize, be human, be persistent, do the work
