AI summary by TwinMind

How to disrupt philanthropy in response to crisis | Darren Walker

TED

51m 35s

Historical Context of American Philanthropy

  • Ford Foundation exists 80 years, founded on Andrew Carnegie's 1889 "Gospel of Wealth"
  • Carnegie's model used by titans: John D. Rockefeller, JP Morgan, Henry Ford, Andrew Mellon, Bill Gates, Michael Bloomberg
  • Traditional philanthropy: wealthy give back to improve lot of "common men, poor, dispossessed, disadvantaged"
  • Martin Luther King challenged this model: "philanthropy is commendable but should not allow philanthropist to overlook economic injustice which makes philanthropy necessary"
  • King questioned inequality that made wealth possible, challenged wealthy to examine complicity in economic injustice

Current Crisis and Need for Change

  • Living in "age of inequality" - must reconsider philanthropy and capitalism
  • Key question shifted from "what do I do to give back?" to "what am I willing to give up?"
  • System based on racism and capitalism generated "far too little shared prosperity"
  • Hopelessness identified as "great threat of our time" along with climate
  • "Hope is the oxygen of democracy"
  • George Floyd murder as metaphor: breath taken from body by protector, parallels marginalized communities "being asphyxiated by system that does not recognize their humanity"

Challenges in Communication and Language

  • Many tired of constraining language to make privileged people comfortable
  • Privileged people must become uncomfortable to make progress
  • Privilege "buys insulation from being uncomfortable"
  • George Floyd murder: moment many white Americans could "no longer be comfortable with racism"
  • African-American hearts "broken for centuries" due to racism
  • Language about racism necessarily makes privileged people uncomfortable

Specific Changes Needed

  • Tax policies that bolster wealth of privileged
  • Legacy admissions systems in colleges
  • Expectation that wealth entitles "place at front of line"
  • Fast track/lane for wealthy and privileged in all aspects of society
  • Examples: sporting events, Disneyland fast passes
  • Meritocracy belief among successful: rules generally fair because they're winners
  • Many have "started with nothing" stories but ignore advantages (e.g., "white man with Harvard Business School degree in 1978")

Walker's Personal Journey

  • Born bottom 1%, charity hospital in poor rural Louisiana community
  • First class of Head Start program, summer 1965, Ames Texas (population 1,200)
  • Never attended private education - "great pride"
  • Financed by public-private partnership: Pell grants, private philanthropy
  • Felt country "cheering me on" despite facing racism and homophobia
  • Now in top 1% - "been on both sides of inequality equation"
  • Concerned today's poor children don't feel America cheering them on

Historical Progress and Reversal (1965-1978)

  • Tremendous progress 1965-1978: high school/college graduation rates, wages, employment levels for blacks at all-time highs
  • Progress reversed when whites saw black progress as threat
  • Affirmative action attacked as "reverse discrimination"
  • Supreme Court case outlawed racial quotas
  • Walker: "product of affirmative action" - country acknowledged historical legacy
  • Convergence of harmful policies:
    • Reversal of progressive policies
    • Economy marginalizing black workers
    • Criminal justice system proactively incarcerating blacks/browns at higher rates

Criminal Justice Reform and Nuance

  • "Defense of nuance" piece: seeking common ground replaced by "retreat to corners"
  • Oppositional, nuanced-averse posture rewards ideological purity, public shame
  • Rikers Island example: supported smaller, modern prisons as compromise
  • Activists opposed any jail building
  • Believes in nuance for complex societal challenges
  • "Defund police" movement gained currency post-George Floyd
  • Previously marginal idea now mainstream due to exhaustion with incremental change

Corporate Accountability

  • Need "reckoning in corporate America" aligned with national reckoning
  • Built-in barriers: race-based, gender-based promotion/recognition mechanisms
  • Accountability through: media follow-up, nonprofits, ESG organizations, civil rights groups
  • Change corporate composition beyond tokenism
  • Private equity oversight needed - "millions of Americans employed" behind curtain
  • Move from "tokenism to transformation" on boards

Ford Foundation Operational Changes

  • Shifted from 21% to 76% general operating support (vs project support)
  • BUILD initiative: 5-year general operating grants
  • General operating support endorses leadership, board, mission, vision, execution
  • Institutions sustain social change - examples: MLK had SCLC, Gloria Steinem had MS Foundation
  • Beyond 5% payout: deploying other 95% of capital more innovatively

Social Bond Innovation

  • $1 billion social bond, 50-year instrument, 2.8% interest rate
  • Doubles payout for 2 years ($550M normally to over $1B for 2 years)
  • Oversubscribed: $5.8B orders for $1B offering
  • Proceeds for general operating support: racial justice, reproductive rights, human rights, arts
  • Historic low rates, first foundation bond of its kind
  • Demonstrates investor hunger for social impact investing

Arts and Cultural Support

  • $175M of $1B social bond for arts
  • Government must do more in next federal funding round
  • Creative funding needed: UK billionaire family considering arts trust/bond
  • Higher education inequality: HBCUs "living hand-to-mouth" vs well-endowed Ivies
  • Proposed: Ivy League social bond worth billions to strengthen 100+ HBCUs
  • Privileged arts organizations (Lincoln Center, Kennedy Center) will survive
  • Concern for arts organizations led by people of color without endowments/emergency funding

Wealth and Taxation

  • Cannot have progress reducing inequality without taxing wealth
  • Generational wealth holders often generous, empathetic (understand "lottery" nature)
  • Newly wealthy more challenging: "I made money, mine to decide what to do with"
  • Combination of "arrogance and ignorance" among some newly wealthy
  • Some entrepreneurs show bold philanthropic vision
  • Preference for "shiny silver object" vs long-term institutional investment
  • Systemic racism requires sustained institutional approach

Signs of Hope and Change

  • More privileged/powerful people share diagnosis of inequality problem
  • Billionaire who previously called inequality talk "downer" now comfortable discussing racism
  • Fortune 500 CEO shared Walker's op-ed on stock buybacks with board
  • Executive compensation distorted by share buyback policies
  • Seeing reckoning with American history previously unacknowledged
  • References Langston Hughes' "Let America Be America Again" (1938)
  • Hughes: "America never was America to me" but "someday America will be"
  • Walker: "time for America to be America is today"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome