AI summary by TwinMind
How to Lead in the New Era of Employee Activism | Megan Reitz | TED
TED
16m 11s
Introduction and Context
- Speaker introduces era of employee activism where leaders ask employees to "bring whole selves to work" and "be the difference"
- Finance director example: asked for transparency/compliance feedback, received discussions on race, gender equity, climate change, modern slavery instead
- Problem: employee activism often ends badly - front page news, walkouts, firings, social media backlash, reputation damage, investor pressure
Research Foundation
- Speaker's research with John Higgins: interviewed hundreds of activists and leaders
- Goal: enable "voices of difference" to make workplace difference
- Presentation covers 4 key findings plus do's/don'ts for leaders
Key Finding 1: Activism is Subjective
- Word "activist" carries loaded meanings: progress/courage/passion/change vs protest/rebellion/violence
- Being labeled activist: cool in some contexts, life-threatening in others
- Healthcare organization board example: same climate-vocal employee seen as "troublemaker" by some executives, "trailblazer" by others
- Quote from Ruchika Toshian: "What looks like rebellion to you is another person's basic human rights"
- Leaders must recognize their assumptions/judgments about activism to respond mindfully
Key Finding 2: Leadership Optimism Bubble
- Senior leaders overestimate:
- Degree others speak up
- Their own approachability
- Their listening skills
- Result: underestimate employee strength of feeling
- Root cause: "Advantage blindness" - status/authority labels impact others' ability to speak up
- Leaders often last to realize impact of their position
- Retail organization head example: "Can't delegate listening responsibility to pulse surveys - show up with ears wide open"
- Leaders must assume they're detached, work harder to discover what matters to employees
Key Finding 3: Inaction is Political
- No such thing as "neutral" or "apolitical" stance
- Inaction on climate change equally political as action
- Construction industry HR director example: competitor made disparaging comments about women, director wanted to avoid conflict, but silence would communicate complicity
- Leaders must make "conscious, coherent, authentic choices" about what to stand for
- Collaborate with stakeholders (including employees) on these decisions
Key Finding 4: Leadership Response Taxonomy
Non-existent Response
- "Activism? What activism?"
- Manufacturing CEO example: utterly baffled by climate change questions, nowhere on agenda
Suppression
- "Expel those voices before it spreads"
- Explicit silencing or implicit (employees know speaking up costs promotion/career)
- Survey of 3,000+ employees: over 1 in 5 expect to be ignored if speaking up about social/environmental concerns
Facadism
- "Let's just say the right things"
- Leaders make proclamations but nothing happens
- Post-George Floyd example: many organizations supported Black Lives Matter, American Marketing Association found less than 1 in 10 took meaningful action
Defensive Engagement
- "Let's just do what lawyers tell us"
- Engage only when absolutely necessary, bare minimum
- Pharma industry example: diversity/inclusion handled in 5 minutes - "send everyone on course, count women"
Dialogic Engagement
- "Let's sit down, listen and learn"
- Step change: leaders acknowledge they don't know answers, want to learn
- Ex-UK car manufacturing plant example: entrepreneur shared information "until almost illegal," opened books to workers, shared decision-making about working conditions
Stimulating Activism
- "Let's be the activist"
- Ben & Jerry's, Patagonia examples
- Recruit, promote, retain activists in organization
Key Learnings from Taxonomy
- Leaders must know where employees think their response has been (not where they think it's been)
- Senior leaders more likely to think they're in dialogue; junior employees more likely to say it's facade or they're scared to speak up
- Dialogue is messy: vulnerability, ambiguity, disagreement
- Leaders avoid dialogue but can't anymore - not sustainable strategy
- Need to experiment, expect fallout, learn from mistakes
Conclusion and Call to Action
- Entering age of employee activism
- If can't/won't hear voices of difference = "canary in coal mine" danger signal
- Unable to discuss differing views on important matters = disaster for:
- Ethical conduct
- Innovation
- Inclusion
- Talent retention
- Performance
- Enormous social/environmental issues prompting reassessment of good leadership
- Maybe leadership IS activism
- Goal: enable voices of difference to "speak truth to power"
