AI summary by TwinMind
How to Share Public Money Fairly | Maja Bosnic | TED
TED
12m 8s
Personal Background and Bosnia Agriculture Case Study
- Speaker from Bosnia, now living in Sweden
- 50% of Bosnia's land dedicated to agriculture/farming
- Government created budget to support farmers
- Set requirements for fund distribution
- Analyzed fund recipients at end of process
- Ministry of Agriculture shocked: only one group received 90% of funds
- Recipients were men working in agriculture
- Women excluded despite working in agriculture
Root Causes of Gender Exclusion
- Three main problems identified:
- No gender analysis of farmers (knew sex segregation of cows but not people)
- Distribution method couldn't reach women
- Required land ownership certificate as condition
- Women traditionally don't own land
- Information sharing through forums women don't participate in
- Ministry changed provisions with help of Bosnian gender experts
- More women now receiving funds annually
Core Concept: Gender Responsive Budgeting
- Heart of gender responsive budgeting = common sense budgeting
- Speaker is economist specializing in public finance
- Helps governments inject gender perspective into financial decisions/budgets
- Need to know faces of people served with public funds
- Can't run numbers blindly
Budget Process Overview
- Four logical steps for all budgets (personal, public, company):
- Calculate revenues (taxes/fees for state)
- Budget approval (parliament approval)
- Spending/budget execution according to priorities
- Control/oversight (whether money spent as planned, objectives achieved)
Universal Human Assumption Problem
- Traditional budgeting assumes targeting one universal homogeneous human
- Assumes same access to funds, same needs
- Results in surprise when funds don't reach everybody
Ukraine Case Study - 300 Budget Programs
- Government analyzed close to 300 budget programs
- Programs covered: health, education, sports, infrastructure, defense
- Found gender gaps in every single program
- Gaps usually disadvantaged women (lack of access)
- Finance officers doing job well but not accounting for people's needs
- Focused on: economic effectiveness, efficiency, value for money, performance budgeting, medium-term objectives
Tuberculosis Treatment Example
- 70% of tuberculosis patients were men
- Men living in remote/rural areas, working in mines
- Preventive measures targeted education/health sectors (where women dominate)
- Didn't account for needs of men in risk groups
- Shows need for gender equality in budget decisions for effectiveness
Gender Analysis Framework
- Core of work is gender analysis
- When planning fiscal decisions (e.g., new tax), analyze impact on different groups
- Determine if gender gaps will be: increased, reduced, or status quo maintained
- Goal: reduce gender gaps
- Many countries have solid legislative framework for gender equality but story evaporates when it comes to budget/finance
Three-Step Implementation Process
- Situation analysis
- Know gender gaps in sector beforehand
- Wouldn't be surprised by outcomes
- Know barriers (e.g., land ownership requirements)
- Know beneficiaries being served
- Sex disaggregated data
- Sounds obvious but not commonly done
- Know procedures
- How budget will be distributed
- Who has access
- What groups will be excluded
Global Implementation Status
- Around 80 countries working with gender budgeting
- Not all have whole budget gender responsive
Country Examples
- Austria: Gender budgeting entrenched in constitution
- Cannot have investment project without considering gender equality
- Canada: Feminist government, gender balanced cabinet
- Doing gender budgeting considering indigenous groups
- Morocco: Working with gender budgeting for 20 years
- Indonesia: With World Bank help, analyzed whole budget system for gender responsiveness
- Balkan countries: Doing fantastic work with UN Women help
Personal Relevance and Call to Action
- Public budgets are "our money" - citizens fund these budgets
- Right to demand equitable and fair budgets
- Important for countries, companies, families
- Questions to ask: Who makes decisions? Whose needs are satisfied? Who has voice?
- Wealth of materials available from: UN Women, IMF, World Bank, Swedish government, various scholars
- One click away from accessing resources
Vision for Future
- Gender responsive budgeting will lead to:
- Gender equality (amazing objective in itself)
- Better, more effective, efficient, fair budgets
- Hope that next meeting, gender responsive budgeting will simply be called "budgeting"
