AI summary by TwinMind

How to Share Public Money Fairly | Maja Bosnic | TED

TED

12m 8s

Personal Background and Bosnia Agriculture Case Study

  • Speaker from Bosnia, now living in Sweden
  • 50% of Bosnia's land dedicated to agriculture/farming
  • Government created budget to support farmers
    • Set requirements for fund distribution
    • Analyzed fund recipients at end of process
    • Ministry of Agriculture shocked: only one group received 90% of funds
    • Recipients were men working in agriculture
    • Women excluded despite working in agriculture

Root Causes of Gender Exclusion

  • Three main problems identified:
    • No gender analysis of farmers (knew sex segregation of cows but not people)
    • Distribution method couldn't reach women
      • Required land ownership certificate as condition
      • Women traditionally don't own land
    • Information sharing through forums women don't participate in
  • Ministry changed provisions with help of Bosnian gender experts
  • More women now receiving funds annually

Core Concept: Gender Responsive Budgeting

  • Heart of gender responsive budgeting = common sense budgeting
  • Speaker is economist specializing in public finance
  • Helps governments inject gender perspective into financial decisions/budgets
  • Need to know faces of people served with public funds
  • Can't run numbers blindly

Budget Process Overview

  • Four logical steps for all budgets (personal, public, company):
    1. Calculate revenues (taxes/fees for state)
    2. Budget approval (parliament approval)
    3. Spending/budget execution according to priorities
    4. Control/oversight (whether money spent as planned, objectives achieved)

Universal Human Assumption Problem

  • Traditional budgeting assumes targeting one universal homogeneous human
  • Assumes same access to funds, same needs
  • Results in surprise when funds don't reach everybody

Ukraine Case Study - 300 Budget Programs

  • Government analyzed close to 300 budget programs
  • Programs covered: health, education, sports, infrastructure, defense
  • Found gender gaps in every single program
  • Gaps usually disadvantaged women (lack of access)
  • Finance officers doing job well but not accounting for people's needs
  • Focused on: economic effectiveness, efficiency, value for money, performance budgeting, medium-term objectives

Tuberculosis Treatment Example

  • 70% of tuberculosis patients were men
  • Men living in remote/rural areas, working in mines
  • Preventive measures targeted education/health sectors (where women dominate)
  • Didn't account for needs of men in risk groups
  • Shows need for gender equality in budget decisions for effectiveness

Gender Analysis Framework

  • Core of work is gender analysis
  • When planning fiscal decisions (e.g., new tax), analyze impact on different groups
  • Determine if gender gaps will be: increased, reduced, or status quo maintained
  • Goal: reduce gender gaps
  • Many countries have solid legislative framework for gender equality but story evaporates when it comes to budget/finance

Three-Step Implementation Process

  1. Situation analysis
    • Know gender gaps in sector beforehand
    • Wouldn't be surprised by outcomes
    • Know barriers (e.g., land ownership requirements)
  2. Know beneficiaries being served
    • Sex disaggregated data
    • Sounds obvious but not commonly done
  3. Know procedures
    • How budget will be distributed
    • Who has access
    • What groups will be excluded

Global Implementation Status

  • Around 80 countries working with gender budgeting
  • Not all have whole budget gender responsive

Country Examples

  • Austria: Gender budgeting entrenched in constitution
    • Cannot have investment project without considering gender equality
  • Canada: Feminist government, gender balanced cabinet
    • Doing gender budgeting considering indigenous groups
  • Morocco: Working with gender budgeting for 20 years
  • Indonesia: With World Bank help, analyzed whole budget system for gender responsiveness
  • Balkan countries: Doing fantastic work with UN Women help

Personal Relevance and Call to Action

  • Public budgets are "our money" - citizens fund these budgets
  • Right to demand equitable and fair budgets
  • Important for countries, companies, families
  • Questions to ask: Who makes decisions? Whose needs are satisfied? Who has voice?
  • Wealth of materials available from: UN Women, IMF, World Bank, Swedish government, various scholars
  • One click away from accessing resources

Vision for Future

  • Gender responsive budgeting will lead to:
    • Gender equality (amazing objective in itself)
    • Better, more effective, efficient, fair budgets
  • Hope that next meeting, gender responsive budgeting will simply be called "budgeting"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome