AI summary by TwinMind
How to Start an Airline
Wendover Productions
18m 21s
Industry Crisis as Business Opportunity
- Normal times: competitors head same direction, advancement through brute force
- Crisis times: fork in road, levels playing field between big/small players
- Coronavirus pandemic forced airline industry shutdown, now reinventing for new consumer needs
- Opportunity for airline entrepreneurship due to industry turmoil
Airline Startup Complexity
- Starting airline among most difficult business endeavors
- Unlike simple businesses (accounting, coffee shop, landscaping), airlines require massive complexity and capital
- Most people have "almost no shot" of successfully launching airline
Business Model Requirements
- New airlines must be unique to succeed
- Need competitive advantage: cheaper, faster, more convenient, or unique offering
- Major airlines' advantage: global network connectivity through connections
- Legacy carriers formed in early commercial aviation days, grew with industry
Market Analysis - Established Airlines
- US: None of 10 largest airlines founded in current century
- Europe: Only Wizz Air founded recently (not full-service network carrier)
- Globally: Virgin Australia only recent full-service carrier without government support
- Benefited from Ansett Australia collapse (2001)
- Entered administration 2020, exiting as smaller domestic airline
- Nearly impossible for new major full-service network carrier in 21st century
Promising Startup Airlines (2021)
FlyPop
- Long-haul low-cost flights UK to secondary Indian cities
- Routes: Amritsar, Ahmedabad (no existing non-stop service)
- Target: Indian diaspora in UK
Play Airlines
- Reviving defunct WOW Air business model
- Founded by former WOW executives
- Low-cost transatlantic travel via Iceland connections
Breeze Airways
- Founder previously launched WestJet, Azul Airways, JetBlue
- "Hub-busting" flights on under-served US routes
- Examples: Tulsa-New York, Louisville-Los Angeles
- Non-stop service on routes without existing direct flights
Competitive Strategy
- All three avoid direct competition with full-service network carriers
- Budget airlines expand market by stimulating demand from lower segments
- Breeze primarily competes with Southwest (hub-busting specialist)
- Avoiding price wars with major airlines (startups lack resources)
Funding Challenges
- Airline industry has little investor upside
- Massive profit/loss cycles based on oil prices, economic conditions
- Past 25 years: 4-5% operating margin (even pre-COVID)
- Railroad industry comparison: 25-30% operating margin
- Warren Buffett: avoided airlines, invested heavily in railroads
- Many startups fail before/after launch due to insufficient funding
Funding Sources for 2021 Startups
Play Airlines
- $42 million from Avianta Capital (Irish investment fund)
- Run by Aslan Whitley Ryan (Ryanair founder family member)
FlyPop
- UK government fund for COVID-affected innovative businesses
- Exact investor makeup unclear
Breeze Airways
- $83.3 million through venture capital
- Possible due to founder's consistent airline startup track record
Funding Ecosystem Issues
- No defined investor ecosystem for airline startups
- Unlike other industries with competing startup investors
- Tiny number of new entrants
- General lack of investor appetite
- Finding funding itself prevents most from reaching takeoff
Legal Certification Requirements
US Air Operator Certificates
Part 135 Certificate
- Simpler option for cargo/passenger charter operations
- Scheduled operations: 9 passenger seats or fewer
- Example: Cape Air (94 nine-seat aircraft, small subsidized destinations)
- Single pilot operations allowed (though most use two)
- Costs: $35,000-$95,000 legal fees + $50,000 expenses
Part 121 Certificate
- Required for major commercial airlines (United, American, Delta)
- 104 active Part 121 airlines in US
- Extremely complex process requiring third-party consultancy
- Only 6 FAA-endorsed Part 121 certification consultancies exist
- Non-endorsed competitor fee: $1.2 million
- Includes: operations manual, management training, electronic flight bags, drug/alcohol testing program
Certificate Acquisition Alternatives
- Purchase existing certificates rather than applying
- Breeze initially planned to buy defunct Compass Airlines certificate
- Dropped plan due to pushback from airlines and pilots union
- Part 135 certificate sales common (websites list airlines for sale)
- Each country has different certification processes
Aircraft Acquisition
Leasing (Most Common)
- 50% of global commercial aircraft under lease
- Popular with smaller airlines
- Advantages:
- Spreads cost without debt
- Reduces risk (shorter terms than aircraft life)
- Options to return aircraft early
- Faster acquisition than manufacturing
Manufacturing Backlogs
- Airbus: 7,000 aircraft order backlog (December 2020)
- New orders: multi-year delivery delays
- Lessors: aircraft available within months/weeks
COVID Impact on Aircraft Availability
- Airlines downsizing fleets, retiring older aircraft
- American Airlines: retired 20 E-190 aircraft
- Air Canada: retired 14 E-190 aircraft
- Breeze launching with E-190s (benefits from increased market supply)
Sale-Leaseback Arrangements
Breeze Example
- Ordered 60 A220-300 aircraft from Airbus ($90 million list price each)
- Sold 5 aircraft to Voyager Aviation Holdings before delivery
- Voyager leases aircraft back to Breeze
- Benefits: gets desired aircraft when needed with lease advantages
- Expected to enter more lease-back agreements as delivery dates approach
Four Critical Startup Hurdles
- Business model selection
- Funding acquisition
- Certification process
- Aircraft acquisition
- Improper completion of any one often causes failure
- Remaining tasks (hiring, office space, marketing, airport leasing) less critical to success
Industry Outlook
- Little successful airline entrepreneurship since low-cost airline era
- Business atmosphere primed for disruption post-COVID
- Next few years will determine if new airlines can succeed
- Question: Industry still locked down by world's largest airlines?
