AI summary by TwinMind

How to support witnesses of harassment and build healthier workplaces | Julia Shaw

TED

11m 7s

Speaker Introduction and Research Background

  • Dr. Julia Shaw: research associate at University College London, co-founder of Spot
  • Spot: tool helping organizations tackle harassment/discrimination through better reporting options and training
  • 2019 study: conducted with Dr. Camilla Elphick, Dr. Rashid Minus, international NGOs/charities
    • One of largest studies ever on witnesses of workplace harassment/discrimination
    • Over 1,000 participants

Personal Experience and Reporting Paralysis

  • Shaw's victimization experience: targeted by senior academics while still at university
    • Repeated, relentless inappropriate behavior
    • Experienced "reporting paralysis" - didn't speak up, neither did others
  • Barriers to reporting:
    • Career consequences concerns
    • Fear of not being believed/taken seriously
    • Worry about no change resulting from report
  • Current improvement: reporting paralysis affecting fewer people, some previously voiceless now have voices

Research Findings on Witnesses

  • Initial Spot data: 93% of victims reported at least one witness present
  • Key insight: harassment/discrimination not happening behind closed doors
  • Most harassment/discrimination is witnessed according to further research

Psychology of Bystander Effect

  • 2018 Starbucks incident example:
    • Two women witnessed barista denying washroom access to African-American men
    • Barista called police instead
    • Active bystanders filmed men in handcuffs, posted online
    • Result: Starbucks closed doors, implemented bias training
  • Research contradiction:
    • Hypothetical scenarios: most people say they would intervene
    • Actual physical situations: most people do nothing (bystander effect)

Witness Reporting Barriers

  • 75% of study participants never reported incidents to HR or someone who could act
  • Primary barrier: fear of consequences/retaliation (same as victims' main barrier)
  • Other barriers:
    • Not wanting to interfere/be a "snitch"
    • Not knowing they could report
    • Not knowing how to report
  • All barriers addressable through better education and workplace systems

Impact on Witnesses

  • Witnesses largely invisible, support lacking
  • Research findings discrepancy:
    • Direct question: most said "no negative repercussions, I'm fine"
    • Qualitative entries revealed profound negative impacts:
      • Increased stress, anxiety, depression
      • Increased desire to leave organization
      • Loss of faith
  • Comparative evaluation problem: witnesses compare themselves to victims rather than assessing actual impact

Social Contagion Effect

  • Reporting patterns from study:
    • 23% told HR
    • 46% told colleagues (usually team members)
    • 67% told someone outside work
  • Negative consequences spread beyond immediate incident
  • Discontent grows as story spreads to more people
  • Threatens organization's ability to retain/attract diverse, excellent candidates

Five Organizational Solutions

1. Showcase Leadership Commitment

  • Leadership must repeatedly emphasize diversity/inclusion importance
  • Must lead by example
  • HR-driven campaigns insufficient
  • Organization mirrors leadership team directly

2. Train Managers

  • Managers most likely to harass in organizations
  • Possible reasons:
    • Power corrupts
    • Promoted for job excellence, not people skills
    • Assume management skills develop naturally
  • Poor management creates fertile ground for harassment:
    • Unrealistic expectations
    • Poor time management
    • Poor conflict management skills

3. Provide Anonymous Reporting Options

  • Fear of consequences overwhelms most people without anonymity
  • Same finding applies to witnesses as victims
  • Participant suggestions for improvement:
    • Anonymous witness reporting (top priority)
    • Choices about who to report to
    • Avoid manager as first contact (problematic since managers often perpetrators)

4. Encourage Witness Reporting

  • Set organizational tone supporting witness reporting
  • Communicate that people can and should report
  • Encourage standing up for each other

5. Conduct Proactive Surveys

  • Don't wait for employees to come forward
  • Ask everyone about diversity/inclusion health
  • Be specific about incidents/behaviors witnessed
  • Direct harassment/discrimination questions get "no" responses
  • Specific behavior questions reveal "oh yeah, I saw that" responses

Building Shared Social Identity

  • Research shows best way to mitigate bystander effect
  • Not about policing or calling out each other
  • About cohesive unit mentality: "attack one, attack all"
  • Collective building of stronger, healthier, diverse, inclusive organization

Personal Reflection and Current Reality

  • Shaw's depression and near-departure from academia after targeting
  • Allies crucial to her continued presence/success
  • No happy ending: perpetrators still active
  • Organizational structures enabling harassment:
    • Dispersed colleague work arrangements
    • Unclear reporting structures
    • Unknown consequences
  • Positive changes observed:
    • Legislative changes
    • Attitude shifts
    • Organizations taking issues seriously
  • Prediction: "time of harassers, bullies, discriminators coming to an end"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome