AI summary by TwinMind
How to support witnesses of harassment and build healthier workplaces | Julia Shaw
TED
11m 7s
Speaker Introduction and Research Background
- Dr. Julia Shaw: research associate at University College London, co-founder of Spot
- Spot: tool helping organizations tackle harassment/discrimination through better reporting options and training
- 2019 study: conducted with Dr. Camilla Elphick, Dr. Rashid Minus, international NGOs/charities
- One of largest studies ever on witnesses of workplace harassment/discrimination
- Over 1,000 participants
Personal Experience and Reporting Paralysis
- Shaw's victimization experience: targeted by senior academics while still at university
- Repeated, relentless inappropriate behavior
- Experienced "reporting paralysis" - didn't speak up, neither did others
- Barriers to reporting:
- Career consequences concerns
- Fear of not being believed/taken seriously
- Worry about no change resulting from report
- Current improvement: reporting paralysis affecting fewer people, some previously voiceless now have voices
Research Findings on Witnesses
- Initial Spot data: 93% of victims reported at least one witness present
- Key insight: harassment/discrimination not happening behind closed doors
- Most harassment/discrimination is witnessed according to further research
Psychology of Bystander Effect
- 2018 Starbucks incident example:
- Two women witnessed barista denying washroom access to African-American men
- Barista called police instead
- Active bystanders filmed men in handcuffs, posted online
- Result: Starbucks closed doors, implemented bias training
- Research contradiction:
- Hypothetical scenarios: most people say they would intervene
- Actual physical situations: most people do nothing (bystander effect)
Witness Reporting Barriers
- 75% of study participants never reported incidents to HR or someone who could act
- Primary barrier: fear of consequences/retaliation (same as victims' main barrier)
- Other barriers:
- Not wanting to interfere/be a "snitch"
- Not knowing they could report
- Not knowing how to report
- All barriers addressable through better education and workplace systems
Impact on Witnesses
- Witnesses largely invisible, support lacking
- Research findings discrepancy:
- Direct question: most said "no negative repercussions, I'm fine"
- Qualitative entries revealed profound negative impacts:
- Increased stress, anxiety, depression
- Increased desire to leave organization
- Loss of faith
- Comparative evaluation problem: witnesses compare themselves to victims rather than assessing actual impact
Social Contagion Effect
- Reporting patterns from study:
- 23% told HR
- 46% told colleagues (usually team members)
- 67% told someone outside work
- Negative consequences spread beyond immediate incident
- Discontent grows as story spreads to more people
- Threatens organization's ability to retain/attract diverse, excellent candidates
Five Organizational Solutions
1. Showcase Leadership Commitment
- Leadership must repeatedly emphasize diversity/inclusion importance
- Must lead by example
- HR-driven campaigns insufficient
- Organization mirrors leadership team directly
2. Train Managers
- Managers most likely to harass in organizations
- Possible reasons:
- Power corrupts
- Promoted for job excellence, not people skills
- Assume management skills develop naturally
- Poor management creates fertile ground for harassment:
- Unrealistic expectations
- Poor time management
- Poor conflict management skills
3. Provide Anonymous Reporting Options
- Fear of consequences overwhelms most people without anonymity
- Same finding applies to witnesses as victims
- Participant suggestions for improvement:
- Anonymous witness reporting (top priority)
- Choices about who to report to
- Avoid manager as first contact (problematic since managers often perpetrators)
4. Encourage Witness Reporting
- Set organizational tone supporting witness reporting
- Communicate that people can and should report
- Encourage standing up for each other
5. Conduct Proactive Surveys
- Don't wait for employees to come forward
- Ask everyone about diversity/inclusion health
- Be specific about incidents/behaviors witnessed
- Direct harassment/discrimination questions get "no" responses
- Specific behavior questions reveal "oh yeah, I saw that" responses
Building Shared Social Identity
- Research shows best way to mitigate bystander effect
- Not about policing or calling out each other
- About cohesive unit mentality: "attack one, attack all"
- Collective building of stronger, healthier, diverse, inclusive organization
Personal Reflection and Current Reality
- Shaw's depression and near-departure from academia after targeting
- Allies crucial to her continued presence/success
- No happy ending: perpetrators still active
- Organizational structures enabling harassment:
- Dispersed colleague work arrangements
- Unclear reporting structures
- Unknown consequences
- Positive changes observed:
- Legislative changes
- Attitude shifts
- Organizations taking issues seriously
- Prediction: "time of harassers, bullies, discriminators coming to an end"
