AI summary by TwinMind
How to Tame Your Advice Monster | Michael Bungay Stanier | TED
TED
14m 8s
Personal Anecdote - Coffee with Shannon
- Speaker met with friend Shannon who asked for help
- Speaker's "advice monster" immediately activated, eager to provide solutions
- Engaged in fake active listening (head tilting, nodding, "mhm, yeah, sure")
- Advice monster impatient: "Could we just hurry this up, please? Time is short"
- When speaker finally gave "brilliant" advice, Shannon responded with same fake listening behavior
- Advice failed to help - advice monster sabotaged conversation again
Universal Nature of Advice Monster
- Not just speaker's problem or mansplaining - everyone has advice monster
- Activates after ~10 seconds of listening to someone's problem
- Medical doctors interrupt patients after ~11 seconds on average
- Human tendency, not profession-specific
- People think others' advice monsters annoying but their own advice is "fantastic"
Three Problems with Advice Giving as Default Response
Problem 1: Solving Wrong Problem
- First challenge presented almost never the real challenge
- People's best guess, first hypothesis, stab in dark
- Get seduced into thinking first challenge = real challenge
- Rare for initial problem statement to be actual issue
Problem 2: Your Advice Isn't As Good As You Think
- Cognitive biases make advice worse than perceived
- Particularly true if you think you give good advice
- Referenced TED videos on cognitive biases for evidence
Problem 3: Disempowerment (Cuts Both Ways)
- Receiving end: Constant message "you can't figure this out yourself"
- Cuts away sense of competence, confidence, autonomy
- Giving end: Added responsibility of having all answers, saving everyone
- Exhausting, frustrating, overwhelming
- Creates bottleneck, disempowers others
The Advice Monster's Three Personas
Tell It (Loudest)
- Convinced you only add value by having all answers
- Must have answers to all things or you fail
- Most resonant for many people
Save It (More Subtle)
- Job is to rescue everybody
- Don't let anyone stumble, struggle, fail
- If anyone struggles, you fail
- Particularly relevant for parents
Control It (Speaker's Favorite)
- Must maintain control at all times
- Can't let go grip on anything
- If others take control, everyone fails
Core Issue with All Three Personas
- In moment advice monster controls, you're saying you're better than other person
- Implying they're not: smart enough, wise enough, fast enough, moral enough, experienced enough
- Saying they're "not good enough"
- You're also diminished: lose connection to humanity, empathy, compassion, vulnerability
- Start using answers as armor
Solution: Replace Advice-Giving Habit
- New habit: Stay curious a little bit longer
- Tool: Questions are kindling of curiosity
- Light that holds back darkness of advice monster
Three Key Questions
Question 1: "What's the real challenge here for you?"
- Purpose: Focus question
- Recognizes neither party knows what's really going on at start
- Keeps advice monster at bay
- Repositions to help find really important issue
- Prevents "fast, wrong answer"
Question 2: "And what else?" (AWE)
- Insight: First answer never only answer, rarely best answer
- Helps go deeper and further on any question
- Tames advice monster while exploring more options
Question 3: "What do you want?"
- Difficult but powerful question
- Getting clear on wants becomes foundation for action
- Enables autonomy, competence, confidence
- Renders advice monster ineffective
Live Demonstration with Audience
- Asked audience to think of real current challenge
- Walked through question sequence:
- "What's the real challenge here for you?"
- "And what else?" (repeated multiple times)
- Final: "What's the real challenge here for you?"
- Key insight: First and final answers different
- If solving first challenge, would be "offering slightly crappy advice to solve wrong problem"
- This pattern "happening all the time"
Final Message: Empowerment Through Curiosity
- Replace advice-giving habit with staying curious longer
- Empowerment comes from:
- Helping people find their own answers (not giving answers)
- Helping them find their own path (not rescuing)
- Giving up some control, inviting others to step in/up (not holding control)
- All becomes possible when you tame your advice monster
