AI summary by TwinMind
Huawei P30 Pro vs Samsung S10 Plus vs iPhone XS Max Camera Test Comparison
Mrwhosetheboss
11m 46s
Video Recording Capabilities
- Huawei P30 Pro lacks 4K 60fps support, all phones tested at 30fps
- All phones have optical image stabilization on telephoto lenses
- P30 Pro's 5x optical zoom standout feature
- 10x zoom clearly readable text on Eiffel Tower from distance
- Other phones struggle at 10x zoom
- Color accuracy ranking: iPhone XS Max closest to reality, S10 Plus similar with punchy aesthetic, P30 Pro established new color palette
HDR Performance
- iPhone XS Max HDR still unbeaten
- Best control of bright sun exposure
- S10 Plus better than P30 Pro but behind iPhone
- Ultra-wide video available on Huawei and Samsung only
- Samsung captures much more in ultra-wide mode
Video Stabilization
- All three phones have stellar 4K stabilization
- Samsung lagging slightly behind in 4K walking footage
- 1080p mode improvements:
- Samsung's Super Steady mode elevates above iPhone
- P30 Pro combines AI stabilization with OIS
- P30 Pro "quite possibly best smartphone stabilization to date"
AI Video Features
- P30 Pro AI video modes improved from previous flagships
- AI color mode: colorize foreground, black/white background
- Works better than ever before, wished for more modes
Low-Light Video Performance
- P30 Pro becomes "beast" in low-light
- Image slightly warm but detail "miles above" other phones
- Lower grain than competitors
- Ultra-wide nighttime video available on P30 Pro and S10 Plus
- Quality "complete nosedive" compared to main camera
- P30 Pro consistently produces less grain than Samsung, brighter than iPhone
- "Best smartphone ever tested for low-light video"
Camera Hardware Setup
- iPhone XS Max: 2 cameras (wide-angle, telephoto)
- S10 Plus: 3 cameras (adds ultra-wide to iPhone setup)
- P30 Pro: 4 cameras (5x optical zoom vs 2x, time-of-flight sensor)
Night Photography
- P30 Pro "best night time shots of any smartphone ever used"
- Requires night mode, hold steady 4-6 seconds
- Results sharper, brighter, cleaner than competition
- General trend: S10 Plus grainy, iPhone dark, P30 Pro leads despite looking processed/over-sharpened
- Moving objects (cars) blur during long exposure on all phones
- Night mode works while zooming
- 5x zoom preserves texture better
- 10x hybrid zoom with night mode "leagues ahead" of competitors
Extreme Low-Light Performance
- Hotel room test with no lights: could barely see
- iPhone image represents actual darkness level
- Samsung bright night mode activated: brighter but less sharp than iPhone
- P30 Pro "completely blew me away"
- More sensitive to light than full-size DSLRs (as claimed)
- "Real deal" performance
Flash Photography
- Good flash quality on all three phones
- Samsung color correction issues with flash-only lighting
- Images have slight green tinge
Daytime Photography
- All three "amazing" in standard daylight photos
- Great detail, punchy colors, harsh lighting handling
- Main difference: dynamic range handling
- iPhone still slightly ahead
- Android phones have darker shadows, high-contrast look
- iPhone prevents overexposure better in many situations
Zoom Photography Performance
- P30 Pro zoom "even more potent for photography than video"
- Super clean images at 10x zoom where others "effectively crippled"
- Can read text on distant buildings
- Used as telescope to read far signs
- Ultra-wide cameras (Huawei/Samsung) shine in daylight
- No noise problems from low-light
- S10 Plus captures more in shot than Huawei
Portrait Mode Comparison
- Apple results "consistently cinematic"
- Most natural background blur
- Uses telephoto lens (requires stepping back)
- Android phones tend to crush blacks in portrait mode
- Lose detail in beard, hair, black jacket
- iPhone preserves detail better
- P30 Pro time-of-flight camera improves edge detection
- "Leap above P20 Pro"
- Fewer errors than S10 Plus
- Night portrait mode holds up reasonably well
- Vulnerable to overexposure in bright areas
Macro Photography
- P30 Pro gets closest to subjects while retaining focus
- S10 Plus also gets pretty close
- iPhone struggles with close-up shots
Detail and Resolution
- P30 Pro shoots 40MP images vs 12MP on S10 Plus and iPhone XS Max
- 40MP mode "little underwhelming"
- Needs perfect lighting conditions
- Without perfect conditions, S10 Plus 12MP sensor captures more detail
Front Camera Video
- S10 Plus records 4K resolution (4x pixels of others)
- Not 4x better image quality
- Samsung wins overall for front video
- P30 Pro has better stabilization
- Samsung shoots wider angle
Front Camera Photos (Selfies)
- "Most subjective part of comparison"
- iPhone XS Max: most consistent, balanced colors
- P30 Pro: crispiest selfies (32MP sensor)
- S10 Plus: best portrait selfies with specialized depth sensor
- "Best job not just of these three but any smartphone ever tested"
- Copes much better in low light vs others (become dark/soft)
Front Flash
- All three offer front flash using display
- P30 Pro benefits most from front flash light
- "Kind of needs this light to perform well"
Slow-Motion Performance
- P30 Pro disappointing for 2019 flagship
- 1080p maximum 120fps vs 240fps on others
- Others can record twice as slow footage
- P30 Pro 240fps only at 720p resolution
- "Doesn't hold candle to other two phones"
- Nice burst super slow-mo feature like Samsung
- S10 wins quality, P30 Pro uses software interpolation for 960fps
- "You can kind of tell" about software interpolation
