AI summary by TwinMind

Huawei P30 Pro vs Samsung S10 Plus vs iPhone XS Max Camera Test Comparison

Mrwhosetheboss

11m 46s

Video Recording Capabilities

  • Huawei P30 Pro lacks 4K 60fps support, all phones tested at 30fps
  • All phones have optical image stabilization on telephoto lenses
  • P30 Pro's 5x optical zoom standout feature
    • 10x zoom clearly readable text on Eiffel Tower from distance
    • Other phones struggle at 10x zoom
  • Color accuracy ranking: iPhone XS Max closest to reality, S10 Plus similar with punchy aesthetic, P30 Pro established new color palette

HDR Performance

  • iPhone XS Max HDR still unbeaten
    • Best control of bright sun exposure
    • S10 Plus better than P30 Pro but behind iPhone
  • Ultra-wide video available on Huawei and Samsung only
    • Samsung captures much more in ultra-wide mode

Video Stabilization

  • All three phones have stellar 4K stabilization
  • Samsung lagging slightly behind in 4K walking footage
  • 1080p mode improvements:
    • Samsung's Super Steady mode elevates above iPhone
    • P30 Pro combines AI stabilization with OIS
    • P30 Pro "quite possibly best smartphone stabilization to date"

AI Video Features

  • P30 Pro AI video modes improved from previous flagships
  • AI color mode: colorize foreground, black/white background
  • Works better than ever before, wished for more modes

Low-Light Video Performance

  • P30 Pro becomes "beast" in low-light
    • Image slightly warm but detail "miles above" other phones
    • Lower grain than competitors
  • Ultra-wide nighttime video available on P30 Pro and S10 Plus
    • Quality "complete nosedive" compared to main camera
  • P30 Pro consistently produces less grain than Samsung, brighter than iPhone
  • "Best smartphone ever tested for low-light video"

Camera Hardware Setup

  • iPhone XS Max: 2 cameras (wide-angle, telephoto)
  • S10 Plus: 3 cameras (adds ultra-wide to iPhone setup)
  • P30 Pro: 4 cameras (5x optical zoom vs 2x, time-of-flight sensor)

Night Photography

  • P30 Pro "best night time shots of any smartphone ever used"
    • Requires night mode, hold steady 4-6 seconds
    • Results sharper, brighter, cleaner than competition
  • General trend: S10 Plus grainy, iPhone dark, P30 Pro leads despite looking processed/over-sharpened
  • Moving objects (cars) blur during long exposure on all phones
  • Night mode works while zooming
    • 5x zoom preserves texture better
    • 10x hybrid zoom with night mode "leagues ahead" of competitors

Extreme Low-Light Performance

  • Hotel room test with no lights: could barely see
  • iPhone image represents actual darkness level
  • Samsung bright night mode activated: brighter but less sharp than iPhone
  • P30 Pro "completely blew me away"
    • More sensitive to light than full-size DSLRs (as claimed)
    • "Real deal" performance

Flash Photography

  • Good flash quality on all three phones
  • Samsung color correction issues with flash-only lighting
    • Images have slight green tinge

Daytime Photography

  • All three "amazing" in standard daylight photos
    • Great detail, punchy colors, harsh lighting handling
  • Main difference: dynamic range handling
    • iPhone still slightly ahead
    • Android phones have darker shadows, high-contrast look
    • iPhone prevents overexposure better in many situations

Zoom Photography Performance

  • P30 Pro zoom "even more potent for photography than video"
  • Super clean images at 10x zoom where others "effectively crippled"
  • Can read text on distant buildings
  • Used as telescope to read far signs
  • Ultra-wide cameras (Huawei/Samsung) shine in daylight
    • No noise problems from low-light
    • S10 Plus captures more in shot than Huawei

Portrait Mode Comparison

  • Apple results "consistently cinematic"
    • Most natural background blur
    • Uses telephoto lens (requires stepping back)
  • Android phones tend to crush blacks in portrait mode
    • Lose detail in beard, hair, black jacket
    • iPhone preserves detail better
  • P30 Pro time-of-flight camera improves edge detection
    • "Leap above P20 Pro"
    • Fewer errors than S10 Plus
  • Night portrait mode holds up reasonably well
    • Vulnerable to overexposure in bright areas

Macro Photography

  • P30 Pro gets closest to subjects while retaining focus
  • S10 Plus also gets pretty close
  • iPhone struggles with close-up shots

Detail and Resolution

  • P30 Pro shoots 40MP images vs 12MP on S10 Plus and iPhone XS Max
  • 40MP mode "little underwhelming"
    • Needs perfect lighting conditions
    • Without perfect conditions, S10 Plus 12MP sensor captures more detail

Front Camera Video

  • S10 Plus records 4K resolution (4x pixels of others)
  • Not 4x better image quality
  • Samsung wins overall for front video
    • P30 Pro has better stabilization
    • Samsung shoots wider angle

Front Camera Photos (Selfies)

  • "Most subjective part of comparison"
  • iPhone XS Max: most consistent, balanced colors
  • P30 Pro: crispiest selfies (32MP sensor)
  • S10 Plus: best portrait selfies with specialized depth sensor
    • "Best job not just of these three but any smartphone ever tested"
    • Copes much better in low light vs others (become dark/soft)

Front Flash

  • All three offer front flash using display
  • P30 Pro benefits most from front flash light
  • "Kind of needs this light to perform well"

Slow-Motion Performance

  • P30 Pro disappointing for 2019 flagship
    • 1080p maximum 120fps vs 240fps on others
    • Others can record twice as slow footage
  • P30 Pro 240fps only at 720p resolution
    • "Doesn't hold candle to other two phones"
  • Nice burst super slow-mo feature like Samsung
  • S10 wins quality, P30 Pro uses software interpolation for 960fps
  • "You can kind of tell" about software interpolation

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome