AI summary by TwinMind
Huge Physics Anomaly Finally Put to Test, But That Just Makes it More Confusing
Sabine Hossenfelder
7m 19s
Original Discovery (2015)
- Hungarian Atomki Institute reported groundbreaking discovery
- Found atomic nuclei decays disagreed with current physics theories
- Discovery made headlines as potential new force of nature
- Called "atomic anomaly"
Experimental Setup & Findings
- Slammed charged particles (protons, alpha particles) into targets
- Targets contained elements with small atomic numbers (beryllium, helium)
- Nuclei absorbed particles, then decayed after some time
- Focus on decay resulting in electron-positron pair from beryllium nucleus
- Used standard nuclear physics to predict angle differences between particles
- Observations didn't fit predictions at all
- Result incompatible with predictions at 6.8 sigma
- Less than 1 in trillion chance of random noise
- Assigned observation to new particle called X17
- Calculated mass: ~17 MeV (mega electron volt)
- Published in Physical Review Letters (PRL)
Initial Scientific Reception
- Mostly ignored by other physicists initially
- 17 MeV energy range previously tested experimentally many times
- Hard to understand why particle wasn't seen in other experiments
- Year later: well-known particle physicists published paper in PRL
- Found way new particle might only show up in nuclear decays
- Not in any other experiments done to date
Media Coverage & Follow-up
- Popular science media declared evidence for "fifth force"
- Excitement built when Atomki reported similar observations in 2019
- Saw similar things in decays of more atomic nuclei
- Other research labs began reproduction experiments
Reliability Concerns
- Atomki lab had reported similar anomalies previously (almost decade)
- Some previous anomalies vanished with better equipment
- Some vanished for no reason
- Lab reliability questioned
- 2019 followup paper was preprint (not peer-reviewed)
2021 Calculation Challenge
- Another group came forward with calculation
- Claimed Atomki observation was never incompatible with known physics
- Standard physics, just more complicated math
- Presented exact calculation that fit data perfectly
- Actually fit "suspiciously well"
- Didn't explain exactly how calculation was done
- Partly numerical, couldn't be checked
- Paper didn't get published
- Created confusion about whether anomaly exists
Recent Experimental Results (Mac2 Collaboration)
- Experiment at Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland
- Did not confirm anomaly, ruled it out
- Low statistical significance (~2 sigma)
- Reject X17 particle hypothesis but not with much confidence
- Reason: don't have lot of data yet
- Experiment continuing to collect data
- Better results expected in near future
Current Status & Implications
- If Atomki result was standard physics: new anomaly at low statistical significance
- If Atomki result was actual anomaly: chances of new physics decreased (but not much)
- Various other experiments also investigating
- Current status: physicists extremely confused with more expensive equipment
- Conclusion: might have discovered new particle or not
