AI summary by TwinMind
Hydrogen Will Not Save Us. Here's Why.
Sabine Hossenfelder
20m 1s
Introduction & Market Overview
- UK hydrogen passenger car sales in 2021: only 12 vehicles
- British Science and Technology Committee report warns hydrogen not a panacea for climate problems
- Global hydrogen car sales 2021: ~16,000 units (3,500 in US)
- Total new car sales 2021: ~67 million (hydrogen = 1 in 4,000 cars)
- Small but existing market with ambitious future plans
Basic Hydrogen Technology
- First element on periodic table, burns with oxygen to produce water + energy
- Only exhaust: pure water (no CO2, nitrogen oxides, particulates, radioactive waste)
- Storage challenges: gas takes large volume at normal pressure/temperature
- Compression: typically 700 bar (700x atmospheric pressure)
- Energy density: 1/6 of gasoline per liter at 700 bar pressure
- Energy per mass: 2x higher than gasoline
- Hydrogen tanks heavier than gasoline tanks due to pressure requirements
Fuel Cell History & Development
- Technology >200 years old
- First hydrogen fuel cell: William Grove, 1839
- 1960s: General Electric engineers developed proton exchange membrane
- NASA development for spacecraft (Gemini mid-1960s, Apollo, Space Shuttle)
- International Space Station uses hydrogen fuel cells for electricity + drinking water
Current Industry Investment
- EU RepowerEU strategy (May 2022): replace 50 billion cubic meters Russian gas with hydrogen
- Represents ~10% of EU total gas consumption
- Major investing countries: Japan, Canada, Egypt, China, US
- Green Hydrogen International Texas plant:
- 60 GW solar/wind electricity
- 2.5 billion kg hydrogen/year production
- Called "Hydrogen City"
- Microsoft: hydrogen fuel cells as backup generators for data centers
Hydrogen Production Methods & Color Classification
- Hydrogen = energy storage system, not energy source
- Requires energy input to break chemical bonds in water/methane
Current Production (2019 World Energy Council data)
- >95% from fossil fuels (black/brown/gray hydrogen)
- Releases 830 million tons CO2/year (2% global emissions, equivalent to air traffic)
Color Scale:
- White: Naturally occurring (rare geological deposits)
- Black/Brown: From coal/lignite + water (high CO2 emissions)
- Gray: From methane + water (CO2 + methane emissions)
- Blue: From methane with CO2 capture/storage (currently 1% of production)
- Green: From water using renewable energy
- Pink/Purple: From water using nuclear power
Environmental Impact Analysis
Gray vs Blue Hydrogen (2021 American research)
- Gray hydrogen: 550g CO2 equivalent/kWh
- Blue hydrogen: 486g CO2 equivalent/kWh (only slightly better)
- Blue hydrogen performance issues:
- Not all CO2 captured/stored
- CO2 storage process requires energy
- Under best conditions: ~200g CO2/kWh possible
Green Hydrogen Challenges
- Australian research: ideally 1/4 emissions of gray hydrogen
- Realistic conditions: comparable emissions to gray hydrogen
- Solar fluctuations make production inefficient
- Wind expected to be worse due to less reliability
- Most expensive production method (2019 review)
- Economic competitiveness doubtful due to energy input fluctuations
Resource & Infrastructure Challenges
Water Requirements
- University of Delaware estimates: 18% fossil fuel replacement = 2% of current irrigation water
- Global average manageable, but regional variations (Australia: 4% of irrigation water)
- Fossil fuels currently use more fresh water than projected hydrogen needs
Cold Weather Problems
- Water freezes in fuel cells below 0°C
- Freezing degrades membranes and tubes rapidly
- "Cold start problem" - current solution: preheating systems
Rare Metal Dependencies
- Proton exchange membranes require platinum and iridium
- Both expensive noble metals with limited supply
- Supply concentrated in 3 countries: South Africa, Russia, Zimbabwe
- Wood McKenzie projections: iridium demand will exceed supply several times by 2030
- China already experiencing supply consequences
Storage & Handling Issues
- Hydrogen embrittlement: molecules penetrate tank walls, making materials brittle
- Requires thick, specially coated tanks (heavy + expensive)
- High pressure storage (700 bar) creates handling difficulties
- Real-world example: Regensburg, Germany retired 6 new hydrogen buses due to filling station breakdowns
Economic & Practical Considerations
- High infrastructure costs for transport system
- Rare metal supply constraints increase costs
- Pressure storage adds weight and expense
- Limited cold weather functionality
- Current production methods maintain high carbon footprint
