AI summary by TwinMind
I Hated Smartwatches
Mrwhosetheboss
16m 18s
Initial Resistance to Smartwatches
- 10 years of persistent resistance to smartwatch adoption
- Key concerns: constant notifications, charging requirements, tiny keyboard interaction
- Self-identified as "not a smartwatch kind of guy"
Team Christmas Gift Decision
- Late last year: searched for perfect team Christmas gift with Dri
- Decided on Apple Watch Series 9 for entire team
- Created fitness challenge between team members for health goals
- Eventually "caved" and got watches for everyone
Fitness Gamification Impact
- Unexpectedly transformative effect on health behavior
- Apple's three ring system:
- Calories burned from movement
- Minutes of proper workout
- Hours with at least 1 minute standing
- Customizable daily goals for each ring
- Gamification aspects:
- Life feels like video game with health bars/stamina meters
- Wrist sensors measuring key stats
- Cool completion animations equivalent to beating high scores
- Objective completion and leveling up mechanics
Social Competition Features
- Apple fitness app: add friends with watches to see each other's rings
- Mutual visibility creates accountability layer
- Incentivizes exceeding personal goals
- Third-party "Challenges" app for group competitions
- Running leaderboard with constant updates
- Drama from surprise takeovers (outdoor holidays)
- Surprise downfalls (injuries)
Behavioral Changes
- Actively choosing healthier options:
- Walking home after big meals
- Discussing video ideas while walking vs sitting on sofa
- Describes impact as "priceless"
Workout Mode Limitations
- Specific workout mode required for accurate tracking
- Must manually activate before exercising
- Doesn't activate automatically initially
- Workaround: after 10 minutes of exercise, watch prompts to enable
- Retroactively adds back exercise time and calories when enabled
Aesthetic and Hardware Concerns
- Weak point: overall appearance as watch
- Watch face customization:
- Multiple templates available
- Color customization options
- Individual complications swapping
- Sufficient differentiation between team members
- Limited compared to expectations
- No third-party marketplace from Apple
- No granular animation customization
- Third-party solution: Facer app (costs money)
- "Mindblowing amount of watch faces"
- Video game-like options
- Pokémon faces available
Hardware Design Assessment
- "Just fine" - not ugly but not special
- Body and bands look fine, nothing remarkable
- No conversation-starting appeal
- Samsung and Huawei make more aesthetically pleasing options
- One massive screen scratch (highly upsetting)
- Screen protectors ruin seamless feel
- Watch cases make device bulkier
- Must accept it won't stay pristine
Daily Use Design Excellence
- Clearly designed as daily wear watch
- Not for special occasions or dress up
- Shape and curves don't dig into wrist regardless of position
- Bands: not prettiest but extremely comfortable
- Fabric band: easy slip on/off, softer than appearance
- Seamless user experience - no bugs or broken animations in 2 months
- Apps open instantly with consistent feel
- Low power stage that wakes when wrist lifted
- Cohesive, optimized system feel
Functional Design Benefits
- Square shape loses traditional watch points but gains functionality
- More usable space for apps
- Software specifically optimized for exact hardware
- Deep black display with black UI design
- Screen appears to "melt over the sides"
Addressing Initial Concerns
- Charging solution: single block charges phone, earphones, watch
- Reduces hassle and forgetting risk
- Notification management:
- Mirrors phone notification settings by default
- Further customizable for watch-specific preferences
- Disabled Amazon delivery notifications on watch
- Ensures important notifications seen immediately
Unexpected Screen Time Reduction
- Contrary to assumption of doubled screen time
- Reduces phone-checking anxiety
- Quick notification handling on watch
- No TikTok or feeds to scroll
- Action notifications and return to daily activities
- Overall reduced tech time despite additional device
Usage Behavior Issues
- Instinctive glance at wrist notifications mid-conversation
- Acknowledges rudeness of behavior
- Trying to break the habit
- Consequence of tech being on body
Functional Limitations
- Not iPhone replacement despite being standalone computer
- Permanent Bluetooth connection to phone required
- Limited functionality without phone:
- Text sending requires Bluetooth range or previously connected Wi-Fi
- Can't watch videos despite being good remote
- WhatsApp images appear as blurs
- Native apps like Headspace are "neutered" compared to phone versions
- Photo storage limited to favorited shots (max 500 vs 28,000 on phone)
- Wouldn't feel comfortable leaving home without phone even with cellular watch
Convenience Features
- Contactless payments: simplified from phone to wrist tap
- Built-in flashlight with brightness adjustment
- Navigation tracking without repeated phone checking
- Two-factor authentication codes visible on wrist
- Music control and volume adjustment while running
- Quick timer and weather checking
- Faster than phone for small tasks
- Similar to phone vs laptop preference for touchscreen apps
Double Tap Gesture
- New feature in latest Apple watches
- Universal button for primary app actions
- Not particularly comfortable or reliable in practice
Additional Useful Features
- Find My app: make lost phone ring
- Walkie-talkie function:
- Hold button and speak for real-time communication
- Requires internet connection
- Effortless long-distance communication
- Convenience of voice notes without phone call pressure
- Perfect for quick catch-ups and updates
- Speaker 30% quieter than needed for full effectiveness
- Compass functionality:
- Shows altitude, incline, latitude, longitude
- Super responsive app
- Backtrack feature: automatically tracks steps for return navigation
- Useful for unfamiliar locations
Overall Assessment Reversal
- Complete perspective flip from detesting to being sold on smartwatches
- Specifically recommends Apple Watch Series 9
- Describes experience as "very good"
Major Limitation: Ecosystem Lock-in
- Apple Watch primarily iPhone accessory
- Limited functionality with non-iPhone devices:
- Can track rings but can't message, take calls, or get directions
- Not functional product without iPhone
- Recently switched from iPhone to Samsung phone
- Creates unfortunate choice: preferred phone vs preferred watch
- Android watches similarly dysfunctional with iPhones
- Smartwatch purchase = strongest ecosystem lock-in commitment
- Current solution: carrying old iPhone in backpack for watch functionality
- Can't switch to Galaxy watch due to team fitness challenge commitment
