AI summary by TwinMind
I thought the Schmid Peoplemover was impossible
Tom Scott
5m 29s
Previous Elevator Research
- Made two videos on strange elevators with horizontal/vertical movement
- Genoa, Italy: cabin travels tunnel, loads into regular vertical elevator
- Rottweil, Germany test tower: uses locking mechanisms, linear induction motors
- Both designs stop completely when changing direction
- Believed smooth horizontal-to-vertical transition impossible
Schmid People Mover Discovery
- System performs smooth horizontal-to-vertical transitions for ~20 years
- Only 3 ever installed, 2 still exist
- Examined larger installation at train station in outback Germany
- Required engineering consultant to analyze original patents
- Tracked down inventor with German producer assistance
Technical Operation
- Motor located in cabin itself (not cable-pulled)
- Self-propulsion via pair of cogs on top
- Cogs engage rack rails on each side of cabin
- Essentially suspended cog railway with anti-sway devices
- Smooth transition: cogs follow rails as they curve to vertical
Safety Systems
- Locks onto carrier device during vertical travel
- Counterweight system with safety equivalent to regular elevator
- Carrier visible through window during vertical transition
- Counterweight sits on calibrated springs at bottom
- Springs gently lift counterweight as cabin transitions to vertical
- System maintains balance throughout transition
- Complex docking/undocking mechanism in roof
- Analogy: similar to garage door mechanism sliding into place
Practical Limitations
- Complicated system vs. simpler alternatives
- Alternative: underpass or two mass-produced elevators + footbridge
- Standard elevators: any qualified technician can repair with off-shelf parts
- Schmid system: requires specially trained technicians, rare equipment
- Footbridge provides backup if elevator breaks
- Physically able users can run across footbridge when late for train
System Advantages
- Requires much less land than regular footbridge
- No tunneling needed (unlike underpass)
- Convenient for heavy/bulky bags
- Single continuous journey without multiple transfers
- No hauling bags in/out of multiple elevators
Market Assessment
- Possible world where design became popular, parts standardized
- Not bad invention - very clever, solves specific problem
- More common/reliable alternatives exist with slightly more installation hassle
- Economics favor conventional solutions despite technical elegance
