AI summary by TwinMind
I Tried the Weirdest “Open” Headphones
Marques Brownlee
14m 39s
Introduction to Open-Back Audio
- Traditional headphones block outside sound completely
- Open-back headphones allow air/sound through, enabling environmental awareness
- Sennheiser HD650 used as daily driver reference for editing work
- Recent influx of unusual open-back designs prompted comprehensive testing
Sony LinkBuds Open Review
- Ring-shaped earbuds with hole in middle, wing tip for ear fit
- Available since 2022, newest generation tested
- Features:
- Circle sits deep in ear, not obviously visible when worn
- App with blind EQ testing feature
- Double-tap controls on bulb
- USB-C charging case
- Performance:
- Decent out-of-box sound quality
- Naturally selected more bass-heavy EQ to compensate for open design
- Long listening comfort issues after couple hours
- Ratings: 3/5 sound quality, 4/5 transparency
Bose Ultra Open Review
- Unconventional design resembling lapel mic
- Flexible section allows back part behind ear, front part in ear canal
- Cannot wear with upper ear piercings/earrings
- Features:
- Dedicated app with EQ controls
- Immersive audio/spatial audio support
- Head tracking for fixed instrument positioning
- Missing multipoint Bluetooth (significant omission for price)
- Performance:
- Most comfortable for extended wear
- Very secure fit, requires significant movement to dislodge
- Sound quality matches LinkBuds with EQ adjustment
- Most recognizable to others as allowing conversation
- Battery lasts longer with immersive sound disabled
- Ratings: 3/5 sound quality, 5/5 transparency
Nothing Ear Open Review
- Larger case than competitors
- Transparent design aesthetic with red dot on right side
- Hook-behind-ear design with floating driver
- Features:
- Stem squeeze controls with click sound
- Most advanced equalizer app with detailed frequency response control
- Bigger driver covers more ear opening
- Performance:
- Air gap between ear and driver creates floating sensation
- Most likely to fall out, feels least secure
- Better bass response due to larger driver coverage
- Significant audio bleed compared to others
- White color makes them highly visible/contrasting
- Ratings: 4/5 sound quality, 4/5 transparency
NWM Open-Back Headphones Review
- Traditional headphone form factor, most open design possible
- Lightweight construction with floating drivers
- Features:
- Pivoting driver mechanism for conversation mode
- Controls on left side with volume rocker
- Multipoint Bluetooth support
- 20-hour battery life
- Compatible with behind-the-ear hearing aids
- Performance:
- Lightest headphones ever worn
- Adjustable positioning via pivot and height adjustment
- Sounds like speaker floating next to head
- Cheaply built feeling for price point
- No carrying case (just packaging)
- Ratings: 4/5 sound quality, 5/5 transparency
MoveEngine M600 Review
- Pre-release prototype from founder
- Ring design with hole through middle of traditional headphone form
- Features:
- No app or EQ adjustment available
- Lightweight but heavier than NWM
- 3D printed prototype build quality
- Performance:
- Ring design actually inferior to driver-in-middle approach
- Sound doesn't properly direct into ear canal
- Creates cavity around ear, muffling outside world
- Poor sound quality overall
- Ratings: 2/5 sound quality, 2/5 transparency
Comparison with Modern Transparency Mode
- Modern earbuds/headphones offer transparency mode via external microphones
- Advantages of traditional headphones with transparency:
- More versatile (noise cancelling + transparency in one device)
- Additional features like automatic loud noise attenuation
- Hearing aid functionality (AirPods Pro 2)
- Open-back advantages:
- No computational processing required
- Some transparency modes have delays/muffling
- Perfect accuracy to real-world sound
- Analogy: Transparency mode = VR, Open-back headphones = AR glasses
