AI summary by TwinMind
I visited the Yellowstone Zone of Death
Tom Scott
6m 2s
Legal Loophole Discovery
- Brian Colt, law professor, discovered loophole in 2005
- Wrote law journal article about it
- Nicknamed it "zone of death"
- His goal: encourage lawmakers to fix the loophole, not promote crime
Geographic and Legal Framework
- 50 square mile area in Yellowstone National Park wilderness
- Located in Idaho state but under Wyoming federal district jurisdiction
- Only one road leads in and out of the zone
- Within Yellowstone borders: only federal government can prosecute (not state)
Federal District System
- Congress divided US into 94 districts
- Districts don't cross state lines normally
- Exception: All of Yellowstone assigned to Wyoming federal district
- Problem: Small parts of park actually in Idaho and Montana states
Constitutional Issue - Sixth Amendment
- Sixth Amendment requires jury trial with jurors from "state AND district" where crime committed
- For zone of death crimes: jury must be from Idaho state AND Wyoming district
- Population in this overlap zone: zero people
- No jury = no trial = no conviction (in theory)
Legal Precedent - Montana Case
- Elk poaching case in Montana portion of park
- Public defender raised constitutional jury issue
- Judge acknowledged Sixth Amendment requirements but refused to dismiss
- Prosecutors offered plea deal with condition: no appeal of zone of death issue
- Defendant accepted deal, preventing legal precedent
Practical Limitations
- Crime still illegal, arrest still occurs
- Must commit only one crime, only in this specific zone
- Risk of prosecution elsewhere for:
- Conspiracy
- Fraud
- Firearms violations
- Civil liability still applies
Simple Fix Available
- Congress could pass statute defining Wyoming district as Wyoming state only
- Could be fixed in 5 minutes if desired
- Congress has been on notice for 18 years (since 2005)
Professor Colt's Caution
- Refused to visit Idaho portion during media interviews
- Stayed in Wyoming portions (the "pretty bits")
- Declined photo op in zone: "not going to tempt the forces of irony"
Expected Outcome
- US Attorney's office in Wyoming wouldn't "roll over"
- People do get released on constitutional technicalities
- This loophole is "in black and white" in Constitution
