AI summary by TwinMind
If Companies Are Desperate For Workers... Why Can Nobody Find A Job?
How Money Works
11m 37s
Job Market Statistics Overview
- 9.6 million job openings in America currently
- Only 6.5 million unemployed people officially counted
- Additional 5.4 million people want jobs but don't meet technical unemployment requirements
- Gap between openings and unemployed is shrinking
Job Opening Calculation Methodology
- Survey of 20,000 business establishments on last day of month
- Three criteria for counting job opening:
- Specific position exists with available work
- Job could start within 30 days
- Establishment actively recruiting outside workers
- Numbers can be misleading due to methodology
Amazon Case Study - High Turnover Operations
- Staff turnover rate: 150% annually
- 1.6 million employees, hiring 2.4 million yearly to maintain workforce
- Only 1/3 of new hires stayed longer than 90 days
- Continuous onboarding/offboarding process
- Hundreds of thousands of positions stay perpetually open
- Company doesn't remove job listings once filled due to constant turnover
Amazon's Strategic Job Posting Practices
- Web services utility computing team: 25,000 job openings posted in 2022
- Only 7,800 positions actually approved to be filled
- Occurred during year Amazon laid off more staff than hired
- Strategy: constantly post positions to attract top talent
- Reject non-overqualified applicants
- Common practice among top tech, finance, consulting companies
Remote Work Impact on Job Postings
- Companies post same job in multiple major cities
- Increases visibility across country
- Allows more selective hiring since location irrelevant
- Creates appearance of more opportunities than actually exist
- Contributes to "ghost jobs" phenomenon
Ghost Jobs Definition and Prevalence
- Jobs advertised with no intention of filling
- Harvard Business Review study confirms increased prevalence
- Survey of 10,000 hiring managers by Clarify Capital:
- 60%+ job postings active for 2+ months
- 96% of employers claim actively trying to fill roles quickly
Three Reasons Companies Post Ghost Jobs
1. Talent Database Building
- Collect data on thousands of workers worth millions
- Access pool of previous applicants for future needs
- Cheaper than starting search from scratch
- Business intelligence on competitors:
- Staff numbers
- Salary levels
- Turnover rates
- Skills assessment
2. Employee Management Strategy
- Keep overworked employees happy with promise of new hires
- Avoid paying more while maintaining morale
- Appearance of growth to investors/customers
3. Regulatory/Visa Justification
- Justify outsourcing decisions
- Support H-1B visa worker hiring
- H-1B workers have 60 days to find new job or face deportation
- Creates more dependent workforce
Historical Job Market Changes
- Past: Pharmacists knew compounding formulas, bank managers made discretionary lending decisions
- Present: Pharmacists handle compliance/pre-made scripts, bank managers use credit scores/algorithms
- Technology made jobs easier but workers more replaceable
- Companies stopped valuing/rewarding loyalty
- Job switchers earn 50% more than loyal employees on average
Training Investment Decline
- Companies unwilling to invest in training due to expected turnover
- Employees forced to self-train: Excel courses, coding bootcamps, sales training, AI seminars
- Growing requirement for advanced degrees (MBA for entry-level analyst)
- High standards maintained to avoid training costs
Entrepreneurship Surge
- 5 million businesses created in America last year
- Up from 3.5 million pre-pandemic
- Platforms enabling self-employment: Etsy, Amazon, eBay, Uber, Fiverr, YouTube
- People choosing entrepreneurship over lengthy interview processes for non-existent jobs
Corporate Disclosure Incentives
- Companies avoid admitting staffing challenges to protect stock price
- CEOs have fiduciary duty to keep personnel challenges discreet
- Only disclose when beneficial to company
