AI summary by TwinMind
If You Could Live Forever Would You? (Ben Goertzel) | AI Podcast Clips with Lex Fridman
Lex Fridman
15m 41s
Immortality and Choice of Death
- Goal: abolish plague of involuntary death
- People should die only by choice, not by force
- Preference: immortality with suicide option over forced immortality
- Prediction: 50 years from now, death-as-meaningful will seem absurd
- Comparison to Anabaptists in year 1000 awaiting Jesus's ascension
- Age 53 perspective: limited decades left creates reflection and deeper understanding
- Acknowledges wisdom from mortality awareness
- Argues deep understanding achievable through other means
Pain Elimination and Suffering
- Goal: abolish pain through neuroscience advances
- Brain adjustment to eliminate pain sensation
- Comparison: beauty in overcoming pain vs torture - few choose self-harm
- Romanticization of suffering debate
- Russian cultural perspective on suffering
- Non-obvious choice between world with/without suffering, pain, death
- Dial concept: adjustable pain control (0-11 scale, Spinal Tap reference)
- Question: would you choose to have the dial available?
- Prediction: dark moments would drive choice for dial implantation
Physical Challenge and Pain Experience
- Current challenge: 680 push-ups and pull-ups daily
- Shoulder pain during conversation
- Would immediately turn pain dial to zero if available
- Question: twisted human narrative vs genuine happiness source
- Research question for humanity to determine
Human Biology and Motivation Systems
- Human biological makeup implies probability distribution over motivational systems
- Flexibility question: how can this morph with society/technology changes?
- Future context considerations:
- No work requirement for living
- Ambient decentralized benevolent AI network
- Warnings for potential self-harm
- Possibility: pain dial at zero while maintaining rewarding, fulfilling lives
- Confidence level: uncertain but possible for humans
AGI and Non-Human Intelligence
- Higher confidence: non-human AGI system without pain analog
- AGI system would be fundamentally healthier and more benevolent than humans
- Human suffering requirement may disqualify humans as super AGI
- Human motivational system gravitates toward situations where:
- Large-scale best ≠ small-scale best according to subjective values
- Large gratification requires small ungratification
Musical Aesthetics and Expectation Theory
- Key principle: surprising fulfillment of expectations
- Examples: Zappa, Buckethead, Christopher Penderecki, Mozart
- Elevator music lacks this element (boring)
- Desire for slight hurt/confusion followed by satisfying resolution
- Want to "feel pain go away" and confusion resolved
Meaning of Life: Three Core Values
- Joy: basis of everything, number one value
- Growth: unsatisfied with static joy, needs progression
- Choice: individuality and agency as distinct system
- Nexus of causality within system vs evenly distributed causality
- These three values can continue indefinitely
Transhumanism and Super Longevity
- Path to maximum joy, growth, choice: go beyond human form
- Human body potential not maximized by current humans
- Other matter configurations could manifest greater joy, growth, choice
- Possibly transcending current matter realm understanding
- Practical meaning: create something better than humans
Personal Life Balance
- Four kids, one granddaughter, friends, parents, family
- Enjoys everyday human social existence
- Spends time in nature, forest, water daily
- Pleasant moments important but growth/choice limited by human biology
- Death severely inhibits personal growth potential
Current Longevity Research Progress
- Aging and death not yet cured
- CRISPR and gene editing: incredible tool potential
- Stem cells: could significantly prolong life
- Stem cell injections for every body tissue
- Replacement of old cells with new stem cell-produced cells
- Need better technology for proper growth
- Machine learning guidance for stem cell differentiation/transdifferentiation
Extracellular Matrix Research
- Problem: proteins between cells stiffen with age
- Function: transmits information electrically, mechanically, biophotonically
- Consequence: stiffer matrix = less transmission = worse organ coordination
- Solution: Christian Schaffmeister (Temple University) developing:
- Novel molecules called spiral ligaments
- Non-organic, specially designed polymers
- Algorithmically predictable folding
- Molecular scissors with spiroligamers
- Edible, cuts through glucose and cross-linked proteins
- Several years of work needed, currently unfunded
Systemic Solutions for Longevity
- Need: integrated database of all biological knowledge
- Human beings and model organisms
- Massively distributed open cog bio atom space
- Privacy-protecting data opening
- Funding requirement: massive investment in machine learning/AGI/proto-AGI
- Research focus: statistical research for molecular and human biology
- Regulatory changes: allow radical self-experimentation by choice
- Infrastructure: cloud-based automated experimentation platforms
- Microorganisms, flies, mice
Economic Perspective on Longevity Investment
- Historical context:
- Obama gave $4 trillion to large banks/insurance companies post-financial crisis
- COVID crisis: trillions for people/small businesses, more trillions likely for large institutions
- Proposal: $10 trillion investment in massive holistic bio AI
- Bio simulation and experimental biology infrastructure
- World economy could handle this scale (similar to crisis spending)
- Current problem: research siloed in big companies and government agencies
- Data issue: personal biological data sitting unused in databases instead of feeding longevity AI research
