AI summary by TwinMind

I'm Coming Around To Go...

Theo - t3․gg

21m 32s

Speaker's Evolution on Go

  • Initially not a Go fan, but coming around to its value
  • Doesn't enjoy writing Go, but recognizes its industry benefits
  • Uses Go-built tools daily: ES Build, Vest, Docker
  • Dislikes Go-built tools: Kubernetes, Terraform, GitHub CLI
  • Acknowledges Go enables fast development with relatively good runtime performance

Performance Comparison Diagram

  • Posted Twitter diagram showing language trade-offs
  • Runtime performance: Rust wins due to manual memory management
  • Developer velocity: TypeScript fastest for 0-to-1 or 1-to-10 development
  • Compilation times: Go "comically faster" than other options
  • Rust paradox: Used to build faster JS/TS compilers despite having slowest compiler
  • Both Go and Rust being used to rethink JS/TS tooling

Personal Go Experience at Twitch (2017)

  • Previously worked on Elixir team (2.5 engineers)
    • Built infrastructure for Twitch's marathon content
    • Loved functional programming and development speed
  • Moved to video infrastructure team using Go
  • Hated frontend/JavaScript at the time
  • Focused on native apps and backends
  • Spent 2 months with Go, was "miserable every second"
  • Go didn't make him "feel smart" or "spark joy"
  • Missed the craft enjoyment he had with Elixir

Go's Design Philosophy

  • Designed to be boring, minimal, repetitive, consistent
  • Goal: Code from senior dev (5+ years Go) should look identical to junior dev code
  • Strange mental shift: C++-like feel but with garbage collection
  • Garbage collectors typically associated with higher-level languages (Java)
  • Doesn't fit in any specific category box

Go's Technical Issues (via Faster Than Lime)

Type System Problems

  • Quote from OSCON conference: "Why did you choose to ignore any research about type systems since the 1970s?"
  • Go's types described as "utter chaos"
  • Speaker introduced bugs in production due to type system failures
  • Values were knowable but type system couldn't detect them
  • Handles errors well but handles empty values poorly
  • Failed to strike balance between error handling and type safety

Channel Axioms Issues

  • Channels pitched as reason to use Go for concurrency
  • Four problematic axioms:
    • Send to nil channel blocks forever
    • Receive from nil channel blocks forever
    • Send to closed channel panics
    • Receive from closed channel returns zero value immediately
  • Behaviors make no sense according to speaker
  • No way to detect if channel is closed when receiving
  • Inconsistent with Go's error-handling philosophy

Go Team's Acknowledgment

  • Recent presentation acknowledged generic container mistakes
  • Defined Maps, slices, arrays, channels without giving programmers access to genericity
  • Barrier between language-provided and user-controlled functionality
  • Caused issues for many developers

Performance vs Developer Velocity Spectrum

  • Spectrum diagram: Performance (left) vs Developer Velocity (right)
  • C++: Ultimate performance, poor developer velocity
  • JS/TypeScript: Good velocity, poor performance
  • Python: Similar velocity to JS/TS, potentially faster
  • Rust: High performance but slower development than C++
  • Gap exists in middle of spectrum ("Uncanny Valley")
  • Technologies at extremes get more attention/hype

Go's Position and Arenas Feature

  • Go designed to fill middle ground of spectrum
  • Garbage collection causes performance gap vs Rust
  • Arenas feature was planned to allow manual memory management for core packages
  • Would enable "perfect performance" for file readers, JSON parsers
  • Speaker was excited about Arenas pushing Go further toward performance
  • Arenas now on hold indefinitely - speaker "heartbroken"
  • Go seems content staying in middle position

JavaScript Tooling Evolution

  • ES Build created by Evan Wallace (Figma CTO)
  • Built in Go for faster TypeScript compilation
  • Core piece used by almost every modern JS solution
  • Vite uses ES Build in dev, Rollup in production
  • ES Build contribution chart shows it's essentially one-man project
  • Evan Wallace: 3,800 commits, next contributor: 16 commits

Rust-based JavaScript Compiler Issues

  • Ecosystem moving to Rust rewrites instead of building on ES Build
  • New tools: SWC, RSPack, Turbo Pack, Rolldown
  • Rust-based compilers have slow adoption lifecycles
  • SWC hasn't kept up with feature additions
  • Turbo Pack "notoriously been a mess," massively descoped
  • Projects stuck in "development hell"
  • ES Build still has best results despite being Go-based

Speaker's Conclusion and Reflection

  • Feels guilt for writing off Go's middle-ground position
  • JavaScript compilation doesn't need perfect memory safety
  • Doesn't need borrow checker complexity
  • Thinks ecosystem would be better centralizing around Go vs Rust
  • Admits could be wrong, as with previous Go skepticism
  • Has shipped ES Build in production many times
  • Never meaningfully shipped Rust alternatives
  • Recognizes Go's opportunity in middle ground
  • Go less interesting due to not being at extremes
  • Realizes didn't give Go proper credit for its position
  • Still thinks industry may have screwed up going all-in on Rust

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome