AI summary by TwinMind
I'm Finally Moving On (I have a new browser)
Theo - t3․gg
27m 51s
Arc Browser Performance Problems
- Arc causing massive battery drain on M2 MacBook Pro Max
- Normal 8-10 hours battery life reduced to less than 2 hours
- 6x more battery usage compared to Chrome
- Performance issues widespread among users
- Browser Company lack of updates or communication
- No posts except icons in ~1 year
- Last icon posts from November
- Clear indication browser development has stalled
- Lost credibility recommending VC-funded browser that "hates its users"
Browser Alternatives Evaluation
Chrome
- Gold standard: stable, well-supported, good ecosystem
- Lacks customization features
- Missing sidebar, takes up vertical space with top bar
- Most people should probably stick with Chrome
Brave
- Described as "web3 skinned worse Chrome with sidebar"
- No customization options
- Can't set hotkeys for basic functions like sidebar toggle
- Runs poorly, looks outdated
Edge
- Better than Brave but limited customization
- Has vertical tabs but can't hide top bar
- Janky hover animations, especially on high refresh screens
- No hotkey customization for sidebar pin/unpin
- Team downplays user needs in forums
Zen Browser (Initial Assessment)
- Firefox-based, very customizable
- Early stage with some problems
- Battery life and performance concerns initially
Core Requirements List
- Vertical tab bar
- Ability to hide everything for simple UI
- Command+Shift+C to copy current URL (used 20+ times daily)
- Hotkey to toggle sidebar
- Chrome-based preferred
- Good performance
- Team that cares about users
Vivaldi Deep Dive
Positive Features
- Hit most requirements despite ugly icon
- Extensive customization through quick commands
- Created custom "copy current URL" command with delays and focus management
- Could put sidebar on right (advantage over Arc)
- Impressive level of customization options
Deal-Breaking Issues
- Cannot hide top bar
- Page hotkeys take precedence over browser hotkeys always
- Command+Shift+E conflicts with ExcaliDraw export function
- Cannot close sidebar when ExcaliDraw is open
- Team doesn't care about user requests based on forum analysis
Trackpad Gesture Problems
- Swipe gestures don't work natively
- Team prefers mouse gestures (right-click + mouse movement)
- Required third-party extension to fix trackpad functionality
- Many forum posts confirming this ongoing issue
- Philosophy: if not offered in settings, it doesn't matter
Custom Browser Experiment
- Built experimental browser in 1 hour using Electron
- Features: search, tabs, navigation, streaming capability
- 4 files + index.html total
- Major limitation: can't sandbox different tabs properly
- Electron assumes you own all pages opened
- Would need to DIY encapsulation layer or fork Chromium
- Abandoned due to security and complexity concerns
Zen Browser Final Decision
Why Zen Won
- Open-source alternative to Arc
- Team focused on user needs, not showing off technical prowess
- No VC funding, genuine community-driven development
- Continuous improvement every 2 months
- Firefox-based but overcoming personal Firefox disdain
Team and Community
- Awesome Discord community
- Half the team watches live streams
- None own MacBooks yet (shipping one to maintainer)
- Contributing to Patreon at highest tier since announcement
- Fast bug fixes (sidebar animation bug fixed same day)
Technical Improvements
- Command+Shift+C for copy URL now default (matching Arc)
- Experimental window controls option
- Tab bar positioning on right side (advantage over Arc)
- Hover behavior for window controls configurable
- Much better defaults requiring minimal configuration
Zen Mods System
- Beyond traditional extensions
- Customize browser itself, not just page JavaScript
- Examples: compact mode, rounding characteristics, hide status bar
- Can disable split view highlighting
- CSS customization through profile Chrome file
- Community tests ideas as mods, best ones integrated into browser
- Allows rapid iteration and user-driven development
Final Recommendation
- Still recommends Chrome for most users
- Zen for users wanting Arc-like features with active development
- Warning against following complex browser customization journey
- Apology for previous Arc recommendation
- Zen represents caring and listening vs. money and history
- Supporting underdog browser team through Patreon
