AI summary by TwinMind
I'm Happy Hermeus Let Me Upload This
Real Engineering
35m 53s
Documentary Performance & Content Access
- 45-minute Hermes documentary was best performing video uploaded in recent time
- Uncut interview with Joe Shonan, Hermes principal flight dynamics engineer
- Hermes surprisingly approved extensive technical content sharing
- Joe demonstrates flight optimization physics on whiteboard
- Nebula exclusive interview with Hermes CEO AJ Pica available
- $2.50/month or $300 lifetime access
- Funding supports months-long documentary production not profitable on YouTube alone
Joe Shonan Background & Role
- Flight dynamics engineer at Hermes since June (previous year)
- Primary responsibility: handling qualities and flight performance of Quarterhorse aircraft series
- Educational background: grad school focus on structural dynamics
- Previous work: high-speed systems, flight dynamics, wind tunnel testing of novel control systems for high-speed missiles
- Started at Hermes as loads engineer, recently pivoted fully to flight dynamics
- Ensures aircraft behaves as designed and meets touch point speed targets
Transition from Missiles to Aircraft
- Similarities between missiles and rockets: both use aerodynamic maneuvering for bulk of trajectory
- Key differences:
- Aircraft much more complicated than symmetric missiles
- Quarterhorse/Darkhorse must take off under own power through entire speed regime
- Wide speed range: subsonic → transonic → supersonic → Mach 4-5 targets
- Aircraft asymmetries create effects ignorable in missiles
- Must consider significantly more dynamic coefficients than missiles
Technical Responsibilities & Data Analysis
- Supports flight controls group with proper data for controller design across flight envelope
- System-level aircraft analysis using CFD aerodynamic data
- Baselines data against known correlations and approximate methods
- Assembles databases for guidance and navigation (GN&C) teams
- Scrutinizes aerodynamic coefficients to ensure everything explainable
- Coordinates with CFD analysts to rectify discrepancies
Testing & Validation Methods
- Wind tunnel test conducted January/February showing good CFD correlation for static aerodynamic coefficients
- Static vs dynamic aerodynamic coefficients distinction:
- Static: fixed angle of attack conditions
- Dynamic: rate of change effects (critical for aircraft, less so for missiles)
- Dynamic derivatives challenging to obtain from wind tunnel and CFD
- Often relies on classical 1950s-1960s methods for dynamic derivatives
- Wind tunnel limitations: can't always match Reynolds number, turbulent transition
- Historical example: SR-71 "transonic surprise" - boat tail drag on engine nozzles unaccounted for by both airframe and engine manufacturers
Aircraft Configuration Trade Studies
Horizontal Stabilizer vs Pure Delta Wing
- Mirage III (delta wing) vs F-104/F-16 (horizontal stabilizer) comparison
- Delta wing advantages: less drag (no extra lifting surface), larger wing area
- Horizontal stabilizer advantages: better maneuverability, higher angle of attack capability
- French study found maneuverability largely cancels out between configurations
- Delta wing wins on drag reduction but depends on available engine power
- Quarterhorse uses J85 engine, may drive toward pure delta configuration if feasible
- Considerations: takeoff rotation capability, minimal maneuvering requirements, fuel placement, landing gear integration
Wide Speed Range Flight Dynamics Challenges
- Subsonic regime: relatively well understood, high angle of attack challenges with crosswinds
- Transonic regime: extremely difficult flow physics, control effectiveness degradation
- Aerodynamic center shifts backward to ~50% chord at supersonic speeds
- Center of gravity (CG) position creates competing challenges:
- Forward CG: increased stability but trim drag penalty
- Optimal: minimize trim drag through CG management
- Historical examples: XF-103 rotating wing design, high-speed aircraft fuel pumping for CG management
- Variable geometry wings considered too complex due to thermal and mechanical challenges
Inlet Design Considerations
- Current configuration: inward turning inlet ("ice cream scoop")
- Historical inlet types: aerospike cone inlets, 2D ramp inlets
- Inward turning inlet enabled by CFD (impossible with hand calculations)
- Trade studies include full cone, half cone configurations
- Simplicity and execution ease favored over pure performance for Quarterhorse
- Multi-ramp systems (F-15, F-14) more complex with multiple actuators and high loads
- Aerospike appealing for simplicity
Reusability & Thermal Management
- Biggest reusability challenge: no rocket motor boost, must design for wide Mach range
- Material approaches comparison:
- SR-71: titanium airframe, beaded exterior surface, sliding joints
- XB-70: stainless steel sandwich panels, smooth outer mold line
- X-15: heat sink inconel skin, ablative coating at highest speeds
- Inconel vs titanium trade-off:
- Inconel: handles Mach 5+ better, heavier, higher thermal expansion coefficient
- Titanium: struggles above Mach 4, lighter, lower thermal expansion
- Quarterhorse advantage: no cruise requirement, always transient temperature conditions
- High emissivity paint considerations: black (0.95 emissivity) vs white high-emissivity alternatives
Mission Range & Capabilities
- Thermal systems sized for extended cruise at target Mach numbers
- Climb/acceleration phase significant portion of downrange capability and flight time
- New York to London mission: feasible without aerial refueling
- Transpacific: extremely challenging, would require smaller legs
- No aerial refueling planned for commercial flights
Trajectory Optimization Breakthrough
- Favorite moment: developing fuel specific energy optimization plots
- Key metrics:
- Excess thrust = thrust - drag
- Specific excess power = (excess thrust × airspeed) / weight
- Fuel specific energy = specific excess power / fuel consumption rate
- Energy altitude = actual altitude + kinetic energy contribution
- Contour plots show optimal flight paths through Mach-altitude envelope
- Technique: dive along constant energy altitude contours through bad performance regions
- SR-71 used this technique twice during ascent
- Critical for Quarterhorse mission: efficient climb to touch point rather than cruise optimization
