AI summary by TwinMind

I'm Happy Hermeus Let Me Upload This

Real Engineering

35m 53s

Documentary Performance & Content Access

  • 45-minute Hermes documentary was best performing video uploaded in recent time
  • Uncut interview with Joe Shonan, Hermes principal flight dynamics engineer
  • Hermes surprisingly approved extensive technical content sharing
  • Joe demonstrates flight optimization physics on whiteboard
  • Nebula exclusive interview with Hermes CEO AJ Pica available
    • $2.50/month or $300 lifetime access
    • Funding supports months-long documentary production not profitable on YouTube alone

Joe Shonan Background & Role

  • Flight dynamics engineer at Hermes since June (previous year)
  • Primary responsibility: handling qualities and flight performance of Quarterhorse aircraft series
  • Educational background: grad school focus on structural dynamics
  • Previous work: high-speed systems, flight dynamics, wind tunnel testing of novel control systems for high-speed missiles
  • Started at Hermes as loads engineer, recently pivoted fully to flight dynamics
  • Ensures aircraft behaves as designed and meets touch point speed targets

Transition from Missiles to Aircraft

  • Similarities between missiles and rockets: both use aerodynamic maneuvering for bulk of trajectory
  • Key differences:
    • Aircraft much more complicated than symmetric missiles
    • Quarterhorse/Darkhorse must take off under own power through entire speed regime
    • Wide speed range: subsonic → transonic → supersonic → Mach 4-5 targets
    • Aircraft asymmetries create effects ignorable in missiles
    • Must consider significantly more dynamic coefficients than missiles

Technical Responsibilities & Data Analysis

  • Supports flight controls group with proper data for controller design across flight envelope
  • System-level aircraft analysis using CFD aerodynamic data
  • Baselines data against known correlations and approximate methods
  • Assembles databases for guidance and navigation (GN&C) teams
  • Scrutinizes aerodynamic coefficients to ensure everything explainable
  • Coordinates with CFD analysts to rectify discrepancies

Testing & Validation Methods

  • Wind tunnel test conducted January/February showing good CFD correlation for static aerodynamic coefficients
  • Static vs dynamic aerodynamic coefficients distinction:
    • Static: fixed angle of attack conditions
    • Dynamic: rate of change effects (critical for aircraft, less so for missiles)
  • Dynamic derivatives challenging to obtain from wind tunnel and CFD
  • Often relies on classical 1950s-1960s methods for dynamic derivatives
  • Wind tunnel limitations: can't always match Reynolds number, turbulent transition
  • Historical example: SR-71 "transonic surprise" - boat tail drag on engine nozzles unaccounted for by both airframe and engine manufacturers

Aircraft Configuration Trade Studies

Horizontal Stabilizer vs Pure Delta Wing

  • Mirage III (delta wing) vs F-104/F-16 (horizontal stabilizer) comparison
  • Delta wing advantages: less drag (no extra lifting surface), larger wing area
  • Horizontal stabilizer advantages: better maneuverability, higher angle of attack capability
  • French study found maneuverability largely cancels out between configurations
  • Delta wing wins on drag reduction but depends on available engine power
  • Quarterhorse uses J85 engine, may drive toward pure delta configuration if feasible
  • Considerations: takeoff rotation capability, minimal maneuvering requirements, fuel placement, landing gear integration

Wide Speed Range Flight Dynamics Challenges

  • Subsonic regime: relatively well understood, high angle of attack challenges with crosswinds
  • Transonic regime: extremely difficult flow physics, control effectiveness degradation
  • Aerodynamic center shifts backward to ~50% chord at supersonic speeds
  • Center of gravity (CG) position creates competing challenges:
    • Forward CG: increased stability but trim drag penalty
    • Optimal: minimize trim drag through CG management
  • Historical examples: XF-103 rotating wing design, high-speed aircraft fuel pumping for CG management
  • Variable geometry wings considered too complex due to thermal and mechanical challenges

Inlet Design Considerations

  • Current configuration: inward turning inlet ("ice cream scoop")
  • Historical inlet types: aerospike cone inlets, 2D ramp inlets
  • Inward turning inlet enabled by CFD (impossible with hand calculations)
  • Trade studies include full cone, half cone configurations
  • Simplicity and execution ease favored over pure performance for Quarterhorse
  • Multi-ramp systems (F-15, F-14) more complex with multiple actuators and high loads
  • Aerospike appealing for simplicity

Reusability & Thermal Management

  • Biggest reusability challenge: no rocket motor boost, must design for wide Mach range
  • Material approaches comparison:
    • SR-71: titanium airframe, beaded exterior surface, sliding joints
    • XB-70: stainless steel sandwich panels, smooth outer mold line
    • X-15: heat sink inconel skin, ablative coating at highest speeds
  • Inconel vs titanium trade-off:
    • Inconel: handles Mach 5+ better, heavier, higher thermal expansion coefficient
    • Titanium: struggles above Mach 4, lighter, lower thermal expansion
  • Quarterhorse advantage: no cruise requirement, always transient temperature conditions
  • High emissivity paint considerations: black (0.95 emissivity) vs white high-emissivity alternatives

Mission Range & Capabilities

  • Thermal systems sized for extended cruise at target Mach numbers
  • Climb/acceleration phase significant portion of downrange capability and flight time
  • New York to London mission: feasible without aerial refueling
  • Transpacific: extremely challenging, would require smaller legs
  • No aerial refueling planned for commercial flights

Trajectory Optimization Breakthrough

  • Favorite moment: developing fuel specific energy optimization plots
  • Key metrics:
    • Excess thrust = thrust - drag
    • Specific excess power = (excess thrust × airspeed) / weight
    • Fuel specific energy = specific excess power / fuel consumption rate
  • Energy altitude = actual altitude + kinetic energy contribution
  • Contour plots show optimal flight paths through Mach-altitude envelope
  • Technique: dive along constant energy altitude contours through bad performance regions
  • SR-71 used this technique twice during ascent
  • Critical for Quarterhorse mission: efficient climb to touch point rather than cruise optimization

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome