AI summary by TwinMind
Investing Internationally – ADRs, VIEs, and Everything Else You Should Know About Foreign Stocks
The Plain Bagel
17m 55s
Introduction and Sponsorship
- Video sponsored by Skillshare
- First 10,000 people get free trial of Premium membership
- Focus on geographic diversification in investing
Home Country Bias Problem
- Investors hold disproportionately large share of domestic stocks
- US investors: 70%+ in domestic stocks
- Canadian investors: 60% in domestic stocks despite US allocation
- Many avoid international investing due to complexity and added risks
Why Invest Internationally
- Sector Diversification
- Some industries unavailable in home country
- Canada: large finance sector, small healthcare sector
- Need international exposure for proper sector diversification
- Country Risk Mitigation
- Reduces risk of country-level problems affecting portfolio
- Higher Return Potential
- Developing markets offer higher risk/reward
- Catch-up effect: less developed countries see higher growth rates
- Rapid increase in consumer markets in developing economies
Risks of International Investing
- Regulatory and Transparency Issues
- Developing markets lack safety/transparency
- Weaker accounting rules, disclosure requirements, investor protections
- US has highest stock standards globally (audits, regular statements, disclosure requirements)
- Country-Specific Risks
- Economic, political, regulatory baggage
- China example: rapid regulatory changes affecting tech companies
- Currency stability risks
- Tax regime differences
- Unique investor rules per country
Step-by-Step Process for International Investing
- Step 1: Identify Company and Exchange
- Find company ticker and trading exchange
- UK companies: London Stock Exchange
- Chinese companies: Shanghai/Hong Kong exchanges
- Australian companies: Australian Securities Exchange
- Ticker conventions vary by market (Hong Kong: numeric, US: alphabetic)
- Same ticker can represent different companies on different exchanges
- Example: Ticker "T" = Telus (Canada) vs AT&T (US)
- Use ISIN identifier (12-digit alphanumeric) for unique identification
- Step 2: Verify Broker Access
- Not all brokers access all exchanges
- Robin Hood: US exchanges only
- Some countries (China) restrict foreign ownership of certain stocks
- Step 3: Handle Foreign Exchange
- Different exchanges operate in different currencies
- London Stock Exchange: pounds
- Japanese Stock Exchange: yen
- Two options:
- Handle FX yourself (better rates, more work)
- Let broker handle exchange (convenient, higher cost)
- Step 4: Submit Order
- Consider time zone differences
- Different exchange operating hours
- Can leave orders with broker for execution during market hours
Additional Considerations
- Higher Costs
- Additional broker fees for international trading
- FX costs
- Administrative/market-related costs unique to international markets
- Currency Impact on Returns
- Must exchange money when buying AND selling
- Exchange rate fluctuations directly impact portfolio returns
- Example: Canadian investor in Swedish company
- $1,000 CAD at 6.8 exchange rate = 6,800 Swedish kronor
- 10% stock increase + currency fluctuation = modified actual return
- Tax Considerations
- Withholding taxes on foreign dividends
- Tax rules vary by country and treaties
- Some countries charge tax on dividends to foreign investors
- Canadian example: RRSP avoids US withholding taxes, TFSA does not
Alternatives to Direct International Investing
- Cross-Listed Stocks
- Foreign companies listed on domestic exchanges
- Example: Enbridge (Canadian) listed on NYSE as ENB
- Companies meet rules/regulations for both exchanges
- Flexibility to buy in either currency
- American Depositary Receipts (ADRs)
- Receipts for foreign stock held in trust
- Example: BABA = certificate for 8 shares of Hong Kong ticker 9988
- Technically different from cross-listing but similar in practice
- International Funds
- Mutual funds and ETFs holding foreign positions
- Fund managers handle complications behind scenes
- Some funds hedge currency risk
- Avoids impact of fluctuating exchange rates
- Domestic Companies with International Revenue
- Companies operating internationally
- Example: Canada Goose earns 81.5% revenue from other countries
- Asia is biggest market despite Canadian brand
- Check regulatory filings for revenue geographic breakdown
Variable Interest Entities (VIEs)
- Legal business structure with interest but not shareholder control
- Common with Chinese stocks due to foreign ownership restrictions
- BABA example: Americans own profit-sharing agreement, not actual Chinese company
- VIEs legal in most countries but China has specific restrictions
- Risk: Chinese government might crack down on this workaround structure
- Highlights additional complexity layer of international investing
