AI summary by TwinMind
Investment Analyst Reacts to Investing TikToks PART 2
The Plain Bagel
13m 36s
Host Introduction and Credentials
- Richard Coffin, host of Plain Bagel, investment manager in Ottawa
- Credentials: CFA (Chartered Financial Analyst), CFP (Certified Financial Planner), registered portfolio manager
- Qualified to provide discretionary investment advice to clients
- Second video in series reviewing TikTok investment content due to popularity of first video
Video Purpose and Context
- Goal: review popular TikToks in investing/money space to clear up misconceptions
- Acknowledges some good TikTok content exists (short educational tidbits, account types)
- Focus on problematic content: flexing, fast cars, wealth imagery used to sell products/courses
- Aims to inform viewers for better self-directed investing
TikTok Review #1: Electric Vehicle Stock Recommendations
- Video claims Biden committed to changing entire US fleet to electric vehicles
- Recommends adding specific stocks:
- Tesla (police departments buying Tesla police cars)
- Workhorse (mail carrier vehicles)
- GM (big push for electric vehicles in lineup)
- IDEX/Ideonomics (division for fleet conversion from gas to electric, sales financing)
Richard's Analysis:
- Insufficient information to justify these stock purchases
- Chasing news headlines not sound strategy for retail investors
- By time retail investors act, institutional traders already reflected information in stock price
- Competitions exist to buy stocks nanoseconds faster than competitors based on news
- Retail investors lack capacity for news-based trading strategy
- Stock price already reflects information by time of retail purchase, lowering returns
- News can be part of justification but need much more research beyond headlines
- Strategy likely unreliable, comparable to throwing darts at board
TikTok Review #2: Cryptocurrency Liquidity Issues
- Video exposes fake cryptocurrency gains showing "Super Sonic Finance" coin
- Shows account with 97 billion of worthless coins with no liquidity
- Demonstrates rug pull coin scenario
Richard's Analysis:
- Excellent point about liquidity problems in altcoins
- Stories of accounts reaching billions from small altcoin investments often unrealizable
- People never see advertised dollar amounts, especially with obscure cryptocurrencies
- Not issue with Bitcoin/Ethereum but big problem with smaller projects
- Analogy: investor buying stock at $10, rises to $12, $30, then $100
- When trying to sell everything, broker asks "to who? you are the only person in this market"
- Same issue with cryptocurrencies - price can go high based on buy demand with low liquidity
- Need billionaire on other end of trade to buy, most altcoins lack that capital
- When trades happen infrequently, very hard to sell at market value
- Usually need heavy discount to exit position
TikTok Review #3: Young Millionaire Pressure
- Video asks why people stress about being millionaire by age 21
- Encourages enjoying life instead
Richard's Analysis:
- Common TikTok theme: young people discussing early wealth
- Not normal behavior, dislikes "hustle culture" for 19-year-olds
- Reassures viewers: don't stress if not millionaire by 21, you're doing fine
TikTok Review #4: Individual Stock Performance Highlighting
- Video shows person highlighting past successful stock pick (BNGO)
- Using performance to likely sell course
Richard's Analysis:
- Misrepresentation at its finest
- Never judge analyst/researcher/investor merit based on individual positions
- Only way to judge merit: look at whole portfolio picture
- If investing in risky/volatile picks like BNGO, probably has many poorly performing positions
- Might have overall negative performance despite cherry-picked winners
- Can choose which positions to show people
- Rule of thumb: ignore anyone highlighting single/small handful of positions as justification
- Not giving full picture, misrepresenting skill
- Industry has standards for performance reporting - must give whole picture
- Professional misrepresentation exists too (showing 3-year vs 5-year track records)
- Shouldn't rely on individual year/position highlights without supporting research
- Could be equivalent to throwing dart at board
- Sales gimmick, don't let influence investing decisions
TikTok Review #5: Cryptocurrency Past Performance
- Video shows hypothetical $1000 investments in various cryptos from beginning of year
- Results: Litecoin $1,188, Bitcoin similar, Chainlink $1,600, Tellcoin $144,000
Richard's Analysis:
- Not making recommendations but highlighting past returns
- For each successful crypto, hundreds have failed miserably and lost money
- Thousands of cryptocurrencies exist
- Doesn't provide forward-looking information
- Analogy: like looking at roulette table past numbers and wishing you'd bet on specific numbers
- Not helpful for future decisions
- Creates FOMO (fear of missing out)
- Often used to manipulate people into buying highlighted assets after the fact
TikTok Review #6: Insider Trading Information
- Claims Americans can look up and copy stock purchases by rich people/CEOs/CFOs
- Shows 17% gain in one day using this strategy
- Demonstrates OpenInsider website with charts showing insider buying (blue) vs selling (red)
- Notes insiders bought during COVID, stocks went up, now they're selling
Richard's Analysis:
- Real thing that many analysts actually watch
- Insiders = executives/high-level people in public firms
- Regulators require disclosure of personal trades to prevent insider trading
- Insider trading = using non-public information for profit (e.g., knowing bad quarter coming)
- Following trades based on assumption insiders know more than public
- Some academic papers suggest validity of strategy
- Problem: alone not enough to justify buy/sell decisions
- Good indicator when combined with other factors
- Can be part of investment thesis
- Examples exist where executives bought in but stock still crashed
- Executives aware their trades are public, might manipulate market sentiment
- When simple strategy leads to positive returns, everyone flocks to it, negating effectiveness
- Buying drives up recommended positions, reducing returns for other investors
- Can use as part of thesis but insufficient alone to justify stock purchases
Closing Remarks
- TikTok great social media app but insufficient time for proper stock research/tips
- Not safe for investment advice due to time constraints
- People can discuss investing but take everything with grain of salt
- Everything edited to look perfect, show person in best light
- Don't take skill level at face value
- Many selling courses/products, unlikely to benefit subscribers
- Advice: be safe out there
