AI summary by TwinMind

Investment Analyst Reacts to Investing TikToks PART 2

The Plain Bagel

13m 36s

Host Introduction and Credentials

  • Richard Coffin, host of Plain Bagel, investment manager in Ottawa
  • Credentials: CFA (Chartered Financial Analyst), CFP (Certified Financial Planner), registered portfolio manager
  • Qualified to provide discretionary investment advice to clients
  • Second video in series reviewing TikTok investment content due to popularity of first video

Video Purpose and Context

  • Goal: review popular TikToks in investing/money space to clear up misconceptions
  • Acknowledges some good TikTok content exists (short educational tidbits, account types)
  • Focus on problematic content: flexing, fast cars, wealth imagery used to sell products/courses
  • Aims to inform viewers for better self-directed investing

TikTok Review #1: Electric Vehicle Stock Recommendations

  • Video claims Biden committed to changing entire US fleet to electric vehicles
  • Recommends adding specific stocks:
    • Tesla (police departments buying Tesla police cars)
    • Workhorse (mail carrier vehicles)
    • GM (big push for electric vehicles in lineup)
    • IDEX/Ideonomics (division for fleet conversion from gas to electric, sales financing)

Richard's Analysis:

  • Insufficient information to justify these stock purchases
  • Chasing news headlines not sound strategy for retail investors
  • By time retail investors act, institutional traders already reflected information in stock price
  • Competitions exist to buy stocks nanoseconds faster than competitors based on news
  • Retail investors lack capacity for news-based trading strategy
  • Stock price already reflects information by time of retail purchase, lowering returns
  • News can be part of justification but need much more research beyond headlines
  • Strategy likely unreliable, comparable to throwing darts at board

TikTok Review #2: Cryptocurrency Liquidity Issues

  • Video exposes fake cryptocurrency gains showing "Super Sonic Finance" coin
  • Shows account with 97 billion of worthless coins with no liquidity
  • Demonstrates rug pull coin scenario

Richard's Analysis:

  • Excellent point about liquidity problems in altcoins
  • Stories of accounts reaching billions from small altcoin investments often unrealizable
  • People never see advertised dollar amounts, especially with obscure cryptocurrencies
  • Not issue with Bitcoin/Ethereum but big problem with smaller projects
  • Analogy: investor buying stock at $10, rises to $12, $30, then $100
  • When trying to sell everything, broker asks "to who? you are the only person in this market"
  • Same issue with cryptocurrencies - price can go high based on buy demand with low liquidity
  • Need billionaire on other end of trade to buy, most altcoins lack that capital
  • When trades happen infrequently, very hard to sell at market value
  • Usually need heavy discount to exit position

TikTok Review #3: Young Millionaire Pressure

  • Video asks why people stress about being millionaire by age 21
  • Encourages enjoying life instead

Richard's Analysis:

  • Common TikTok theme: young people discussing early wealth
  • Not normal behavior, dislikes "hustle culture" for 19-year-olds
  • Reassures viewers: don't stress if not millionaire by 21, you're doing fine

TikTok Review #4: Individual Stock Performance Highlighting

  • Video shows person highlighting past successful stock pick (BNGO)
  • Using performance to likely sell course

Richard's Analysis:

  • Misrepresentation at its finest
  • Never judge analyst/researcher/investor merit based on individual positions
  • Only way to judge merit: look at whole portfolio picture
  • If investing in risky/volatile picks like BNGO, probably has many poorly performing positions
  • Might have overall negative performance despite cherry-picked winners
  • Can choose which positions to show people
  • Rule of thumb: ignore anyone highlighting single/small handful of positions as justification
  • Not giving full picture, misrepresenting skill
  • Industry has standards for performance reporting - must give whole picture
  • Professional misrepresentation exists too (showing 3-year vs 5-year track records)
  • Shouldn't rely on individual year/position highlights without supporting research
  • Could be equivalent to throwing dart at board
  • Sales gimmick, don't let influence investing decisions

TikTok Review #5: Cryptocurrency Past Performance

  • Video shows hypothetical $1000 investments in various cryptos from beginning of year
  • Results: Litecoin $1,188, Bitcoin similar, Chainlink $1,600, Tellcoin $144,000

Richard's Analysis:

  • Not making recommendations but highlighting past returns
  • For each successful crypto, hundreds have failed miserably and lost money
  • Thousands of cryptocurrencies exist
  • Doesn't provide forward-looking information
  • Analogy: like looking at roulette table past numbers and wishing you'd bet on specific numbers
  • Not helpful for future decisions
  • Creates FOMO (fear of missing out)
  • Often used to manipulate people into buying highlighted assets after the fact

TikTok Review #6: Insider Trading Information

  • Claims Americans can look up and copy stock purchases by rich people/CEOs/CFOs
  • Shows 17% gain in one day using this strategy
  • Demonstrates OpenInsider website with charts showing insider buying (blue) vs selling (red)
  • Notes insiders bought during COVID, stocks went up, now they're selling

Richard's Analysis:

  • Real thing that many analysts actually watch
  • Insiders = executives/high-level people in public firms
  • Regulators require disclosure of personal trades to prevent insider trading
  • Insider trading = using non-public information for profit (e.g., knowing bad quarter coming)
  • Following trades based on assumption insiders know more than public
  • Some academic papers suggest validity of strategy
  • Problem: alone not enough to justify buy/sell decisions
  • Good indicator when combined with other factors
  • Can be part of investment thesis
  • Examples exist where executives bought in but stock still crashed
  • Executives aware their trades are public, might manipulate market sentiment
  • When simple strategy leads to positive returns, everyone flocks to it, negating effectiveness
  • Buying drives up recommended positions, reducing returns for other investors
  • Can use as part of thesis but insufficient alone to justify stock purchases

Closing Remarks

  • TikTok great social media app but insufficient time for proper stock research/tips
  • Not safe for investment advice due to time constraints
  • People can discuss investing but take everything with grain of salt
  • Everything edited to look perfect, show person in best light
  • Don't take skill level at face value
  • Many selling courses/products, unlikely to benefit subscribers
  • Advice: be safe out there

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome