AI summary by TwinMind
Investors Are Trying to Make Money By Doing The Opposite Of Jim Cramer - How Money Works
How Money Works
14m 9s
Jim Cramer Background and Mad Money Show
- Mad Money: finance TV program running 17 years on CNBC, hosted by Jim Cramer
- Cramer's background: former Goldman Sachs trader, hedge fund manager turned TV personality
- Hedge fund performance: 24% annualized returns over 14 years managing fund
- Earnings: ~$10 million/year take-home pay during hedge fund management
- Show disclaimer: stocks discussed shouldn't be major part of viewer's portfolio
- Recommends low-risk diverse selection of stocks, bonds, real estate
- Similar to "not financial advice" disclaimers
- Current performance: no longer achieving 24% returns like hedge fund days
- Problem: buying/selling every Cramer recommendation would lose considerable portfolio value
Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) Fundamentals
- ETF definition: investment product listing units on public securities exchange
- Most known: Vanguard/BlackRock market indexes
- Buy and hold broad company selection for easy diversification
- Passive funds have trading floors: constantly rebalancing
- Buy shares in companies with grown market cap
- Sell companies with shrunk market cap
- Maintain market-weighted makeup of broad market
- Actively managed ETFs: financial professionals/algorithms make buy/sell decisions
- Charge higher fees due to extra management work
- Example: Kathy Wood's Innovation fund (actively picks based on investing themes)
Tuttle Capital's Anti-Arc ETF Strategy
- Total Capital Management created ETFs doing opposite of overhyped funds
- Response to Arc Invest's Innovation ETF: 588% returns over 5 years (2016-2021)
- Anti-Arc ETF creation: ticker SARK (Short Arc)
- Went short on every Arc Invest long position
- Rebalanced daily using swaps instead of regular shorts
- If Arc ETF up 1%, SARK down 1% same day
- Short position risks:
- Maximum upside: 100% (if stock goes to zero)
- Maximum risk: practically infinite (stock could rapidly increase)
- Stock doubling makes short position go to zero
- Daily adjusted swaps benefit: only mattered day-to-day basis
- Target audience: sophisticated day traders wanting short exposure to high growth innovation companies
- Not intended for "diamond hands" investment
- Wall Street Bets types jumped on it anyway
- Performance: Arc lost 66% value, SARK up 85%, over $200 million assets under management
Jim Cramer ETF Strategy Details
- Tuttle Capital created long/short Cramer ETFs: tickers LGM and SGM
- SEC prospectus filing details:
- Actively managed ETF seeking opposite return of Cramer's recommendations
- 80% of fund invested in inverse of Cramer-mentioned securities
- Advisor monitors Cramer's stock selection via Twitter and CNBC broadcasts
- Sells recommendations short or enters derivative transactions (futures, options, swaps)
- Goes long on stocks/ETFs Cramer is negative on
- Uses index ETFs and inverse index ETFs for opposite market view
- Portfolio composition: 20-25 equally weighted equity securities
- Any market capitalization, domestic and foreign issuers
- Normally holds positions no longer than 1 week
- Could hold longer if Cramer continues contrary opinion
- Advisor discretion to ignore Cramer if:
- Securities not well suited for ETFs
- Excessive risk level
- Illiquid securities
- Negatively impact diversification requirements
Market Performance and Strategy Analysis
- Cramer's audience influence: market tends to move following day after mentions
- Especially smaller companies with easily influenced prices
- Optimal strategy (illegal): find out Cramer's picks beforehand, follow recommendation, sell next day
- Would have generated 555% returns in 2021
- Would result in federal prison for stock manipulation/insider trading
- Short Cramer ETF timing: enters position day after recommendation during buying/selling rush
- Rush typically cools off rapidly as audience forgets suggestions
- 1-week position closure designed to profit off average Cramer viewer behavior
- Estimated performance: potentially 100% returns in 2021 based on Cramer's picks
- Extremely unlikely to repeat long-term
- Risk: Cramer could improve pick quality
- ETF creation purpose: capitalize on meme stock bubble
- 0.75% management fee for Tuttle Capital
- $200 million assets under management = $1.5 million/year
- Payment for making 20 trades/week and watching Mad Money nightly
