AI summary by TwinMind
iPhone 12 Pro Max vs Samsung Note 20 Ultra / Huawei Mate 40 Pro Camera Test Comparison.
Mrwhosetheboss
15m 48s
Introduction & Phone Overview
- Three best camera phones of 2020 comparison
- iPhone 12 Pro Max: biggest image sensor Apple ever used, extras over iPhone 12 Pro
- Galaxy Note 20 Ultra: Samsung's pinnacle, massive sensor, 5x optical zoom, laser autofocus
- Huawei Mate 40 Pro: biggest sensor of any modern smartphone, company pushed smartphone photography forward most
Daytime Photography Performance
- All three phones consistently brilliant but produce different results
- Color profiles differ significantly:
- iPhone: warmer, redder colors
- Samsung: cooler, blue tones
- Huawei: inconsistent color profile, treats each photo separately
- Detail comparison:
- Samsung wins detail consistently (108MP sensor vs iPhone 12MP vs Huawei 50MP)
- Auto mode: all produce ~12MP shots
- Full res mode: Samsung shows big jump in detail
- Surprising: 12MP iPhone keeps up with 50MP Huawei
Camera Philosophy & Dynamic Range
- Apple philosophy: keep scene looking natural to human eyes
- Samsung/Huawei: not afraid to adjust/enhance images
- Dynamic range handling:
- iPhone: can overexpose like DSLR in challenging scenes
- Huawei: detects outdoor portions, massively lowers exposure, preserves sky detail
- Samsung: sits halfway between, good compromise
- Huawei's aggressive dynamic range makes shots more aesthetically pleasing but sometimes fake-looking
- Ultra-wide cameras rely more on software processing due to light limitations
Sensor Size & Background Blur
- iPhone 12 Pro Max has biggest sensor Apple ever used but smallest among these three
- Bigger sensors (Samsung/Huawei) produce more natural background blur/separation
- iPhone gets nice background blur but less than competitors
Video Performance
- Post-processing vs real-time capture difference crucial for video
- iPhone advantages:
- Chipset built for recording two video streams simultaneously (high/low exposure)
- Blends exposures in real-time for better dynamic range
- Dynamic range in video almost matches photo quality
- Shoots 10-bit Dolby Vision HDR with extra color information
- Samsung/Huawei rely more on post-processing, worse video dynamic range
- Samsung compensates with increased contrast but less information in dark areas
- Huawei inconsistent - sometimes awesome, sometimes poor
- Stabilization: Apple/Samsung superior, especially when running
- Samsung adds extra sharpness layer via software
- Focus performance: all fast but Huawei jolty during video vs smooth Apple/Samsung transitions
- Samsung offers 8K video but janky with excessive storage requirements
Portrait Mode
- iPhone 12 Pro Max dominance in portrait photography
- 2.5x zoom camera primarily for portraits prevents facial distortion
- Samsung uses 2x digital zoom (quality loss), Huawei no zoom at all
- iPhone better at subtle foreground/background blending
- LiDAR scanner enables unbelievable edge detection in complex scenes
- Samsung/Huawei tendency to over-beautify faces (can't completely disable)
Zoom Capabilities
- Samsung/Huawei: 5x optical zoom cameras
- Beyond 5x zoom: Samsung/Huawei in league of their own
- iPhone's 2.5x zoom better for portraits, others better for distance
Selfie Performance
- Huawei wins selfie category
- Very detailed without being excessive
- Some face beautification but not excessive
- Key differentiator: second ultra-wide front camera for vlogging
- Audio quality: iPhone best, Huawei improved and "pretty good"
Slow Motion
- Companies seemed to forget about slow-mo in 2020
- Better sensors mean better slow-mo than ever
- Huawei: slowest (sometimes boring, interesting use cases)
- Samsung: pretty slow with decent quality
- iPhone: least slow ability but nicer output
Fun Features & Flexibility
- iPhone approach: less flexibility but ensures everything looks good
- Samsung/Huawei more experimental features:
- Huawei: light painting mode, AI color, dual view, macro mode with AI switching
- Samsung: live focused portrait video, single take mode (captures everything - photos, videos, ultra-wide, filters, music)
- iPhone 12 Pro Max: zenith of refinement but missed opportunity due to focus on standard features only
Night Photography
- Historical context: Huawei dominated, Samsung poor night mode, Apple no night mode
- Current state: narrative changing
- iPhone improvements: 10s Max → 11 Pro Max → 12 Pro Max massive progression
- iPhone now beats Huawei, contests with Samsung
- iPhone strengths: restores daylight colors, smooths surfaces, very detailed
- Huawei regression: ditched optical image stabilization, prone to micro movements, too bright exposing noise
- Astrophotography: iPhone now produces cleaner output than Huawei
- iPhone night advantages:
- Only phone with simultaneous night mode + portrait mode
- Widest f/1.6 aperture for video
- Better color correction in low light video
Final Verdict
- Galaxy Note 20 Ultra: best photo camera overall
- Extreme detail
- Aggressive but not over-aggressive dynamic range
- Many interesting options
- iPhone 12 Pro Max: best video camera
- Really good quality dynamic range
- Unrivaled consistency between lenses
- Superior low light video
- Almost as good as Samsung for photos
- Wins points back in low light
- Huawei Mate 40 Pro: consider if wanting flexibility/camera modes or primarily selfie use
- Weaker camera system overall of the three
