AI summary by TwinMind
iPhone XS Face ID vs Samsung Note 9 Intelligent Scan.
Mrwhosetheboss
7m 3s
Setup and Technology Differences
- Both phones use different face scanning approaches
- Note 9 uses "intelligent scan" combining iris and face scanners
- Uses face scanning first (fastest option)
- Falls back to iris scanning in low-light conditions
- Only uses combination of both if individual methods fail
- iPhone XS uses dot projector system
- Fires 30,000 dots onto face via dot projector in notch
- Infrared camera picks up dots for 3D face mapping
- Upgraded chip from iPhone X provides faster processing
- Setup process simple on both devices
- iPhone shows front camera during setup only, then switches to infrared
- Note 9 scans both face and irises simultaneously in one process
Field of Vision Testing
- iPhone XS detects face from wider angle/further distance
- Note 9 requires more precise phone positioning to unlock
- iPhone XS won consistently across multiple tests
- Wider field of vision means less precision needed when pointing phone at face
Security Comparison
- iPhone XS uses 3D face mapping (more secure)
- Note 9 uses 2D face image 95% of the time
- Only uses more secure iris scanning when face scanning fails
- Face ID approved for payments, Note 9 face scanner is not
- Note 9 requires iris scanning or fingerprint for payments
- Photo spoofing test results:
- Neither phone fooled by laptop screen photo
- Note 9 not fooled even by selfie taken on same device
- Both phones detected photos vs real faces effectively
- iPhone has "require attention" feature for additional security
Low Light Performance
- Note 9 switches to iris scanning only in dark conditions
- Slight speed reduction in dark
- Screen brightness automatically increases to light face
- Success rate drops from ~100% to ~30% in pitch-black conditions
- iPhone XS unaffected by lighting conditions
- Works equally well in dark, low-light, and bright conditions
- No performance degradation in various lighting scenarios
Obstruction Testing
- Baseball cap: Both phones work fine, no speed impact
- Sunglasses testing:
- iPhone works with "require attention" disabled
- Note 9 fails when 20% of face covered by sunglasses
- Iris scanning also blocked by sunglasses on Note 9
- Consideration for glasses wearers important for Note 9
Speed Comparison
- iPhone XS recognizes face faster than Note 9 (95% of time)
- Two-step unlocking system on iPhone:
- Face recognition + swipe up to home screen
- Allows checking notifications on lock screen
- Note 9 faster to reach home screen due to single-step process
- Apple could add setting to bypass swipe requirement but hasn't
Additional iPhone Features
- Attention aware mode:
- Constantly checks if user looking at screen
- Automatically dims display when not looking
- Lowers alert volume when user looking at phone
- Alternative appearance feature for users who change looks frequently
Overall Assessment
- Note 9 advantage: Has fingerprint scanner as backup option
- iPhone XS advantages: Better low-light performance, wider field of vision, more secure
- Note 9 suitable security for most users and situations
