AI summary by TwinMind

iPhone XS / XS Max vs iPhone X vs Samsung Note 9 Camera TEST

Mrwhosetheboss

7m 59s

Video Recording Comparison

  • Front Camera Video
    • iPhone XS: softer, more even feel; software brings down highlights, brings up shadows for flatter image; advanced but subtle skin smoothing works effectively
    • Note 9: looks sharper, which some people might prefer
  • Rear Camera Video
    • iPhone XS: HDR capabilities present; manages to keep both light and dark parts visible; looks like moving HDR image unlike any camera seen before (mobile or not)
    • Note 9: does good job retaining detail in sky but makes rest of image darker to compensate
  • 4K Video Stabilization
    • All three phones have optical image stabilization
    • At 4K resolution: still rarely feel impact of feet hitting ground
    • Note 9 slightly better for 4K stabilization (close comparison)
    • iPhone XS: brighter looking image
  • 1080p Video Stabilization
    • All three phones more stable at 1080p
    • iPhone XS: slightly better at eliminating judder than iPhone X
    • Note 9: even better than XS at judder elimination
    • Samsung produces weird spin-off from stabilization - image moves sharply right/left (OIS too aggressive)
  • Slow Motion
    • iPhone XS: tops out at unspecified fps at 1080p; less noisy than iPhone X
    • Note 9: remains on top; has option for bursts of super slow-motion video at 960 fps
    • Samsung takes the cake in slow motion category
  • Low-Light Video
    • iPhone X: struggles most, has most noise, softer than other two phones
    • Between Samsung and XS: personal preference; Note 9 just slightly darker

Photo Comparison - Front Camera

  • General Performance
    • iPhone XS: massive improvement in selfies; manages to light face better with no compromise in background detail
    • Note 9: completely washed out background, not even close
    • iPhone XS vs iPhone X: more even face tones on XS, other two phones little harsh
  • Detail Quality
    • iPhone XS: can see filament inside bulbs as separate object from glass
    • iPhone X and Note 9: just seeing glowing ball
    • This represents huge improvement
  • Low-Light Performance
    • iPhone X: worst performer; bright background completely destroyed; high grain levels on shirt when zoomed in
    • iPhone XS: polar opposite; background evenly lit unlike any selfie camera ever used; trade-off is longer shutter time resulting in softer, less sharp result than both other devices
  • Portrait Mode Front Camera
    • iPhone X: serious problems in broad daylight; kept getting error message saying image too bright
    • When working: all three decent but none would be mistaken for dual camera photos
    • Hair detection: slightly better on XS and Note 9; no phone could separate hair from background

Photo Comparison - Rear Camera

  • General Image Characteristics
    • iPhone XS: instantly recognizable for even lighting and high saturation
    • iPhone X and Note 9: noticeably darker shadows, darker looking images generally; lose much more detail in lighter parts of image
    • Samsung: applies artificial sharpness to photos for crispy look
    • Apple: opted for slightly less enhanced images
  • HDR Capability
    • All three phones have awesome HDR capability
    • Even with sun directly in shot: foreground doesn't become silhouettes, remains well lit
  • Portrait Mode Rear Camera
    • Samsung Live Focus: always generally blown out skies and brighter areas
    • iPhone X: little better especially on face where Note 9 has lost detail
    • iPhone XS: different ballgame; pretty much zero spots of overexposure
    • Synthetic Blur Adjustment: cool feature with great software implementation; doesn't work as well as desired; background can become super blurred giving massive depth of field but so can shirt; variable depth effect tends to isolate face from rest of image rather than isolating face and body from background
  • Optical Zoom
    • All three phones support 2x optical zoom using secondary cameras
  • Low-Light Performance
    • Note 9: obvious area of strength with variable aperture opening to f/1.5; long way ahead of iPhone X in super low light
    • iPhone X: trouble focusing in super low light
    • iPhone XS: leagues ahead of iPhone X; room so dim could barely see but photo dark but still sharp
    • When zoomed in: Note 9's super wide aperture lends well to conditions; details much clearer and cleaner than both iPhones
  • Detail and Noise
    • All three phones: 12 megapixel primary sensors; similar general detail level when zoomed in
    • iPhone X: darker shadows make some details harder to discern; noise levels little higher
    • Edge goes to Note 9 and XS for detail/noise performance

Overall Assessment

  • iPhone XS vs iPhone X: massive upgrade in terms of audio, dynamic range, selfies, and more; software and hardware difference quite possibly largest jump in iPhone history
  • iPhone XS Limitations: hard time keeping body in focus when changing blur; selfies can look soft in low-light; 4K video stabilization leaves room for improvement
  • Final Verdict: on balance, easily one of most powerful, reliable camera systems ever used

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome