AI summary by TwinMind
iPhone XS / XS Max vs iPhone X vs Samsung Note 9 Camera TEST
Mrwhosetheboss
7m 59s
Video Recording Comparison
- Front Camera Video
- iPhone XS: softer, more even feel; software brings down highlights, brings up shadows for flatter image; advanced but subtle skin smoothing works effectively
- Note 9: looks sharper, which some people might prefer
- Rear Camera Video
- iPhone XS: HDR capabilities present; manages to keep both light and dark parts visible; looks like moving HDR image unlike any camera seen before (mobile or not)
- Note 9: does good job retaining detail in sky but makes rest of image darker to compensate
- 4K Video Stabilization
- All three phones have optical image stabilization
- At 4K resolution: still rarely feel impact of feet hitting ground
- Note 9 slightly better for 4K stabilization (close comparison)
- iPhone XS: brighter looking image
- 1080p Video Stabilization
- All three phones more stable at 1080p
- iPhone XS: slightly better at eliminating judder than iPhone X
- Note 9: even better than XS at judder elimination
- Samsung produces weird spin-off from stabilization - image moves sharply right/left (OIS too aggressive)
- Slow Motion
- iPhone XS: tops out at unspecified fps at 1080p; less noisy than iPhone X
- Note 9: remains on top; has option for bursts of super slow-motion video at 960 fps
- Samsung takes the cake in slow motion category
- Low-Light Video
- iPhone X: struggles most, has most noise, softer than other two phones
- Between Samsung and XS: personal preference; Note 9 just slightly darker
Photo Comparison - Front Camera
- General Performance
- iPhone XS: massive improvement in selfies; manages to light face better with no compromise in background detail
- Note 9: completely washed out background, not even close
- iPhone XS vs iPhone X: more even face tones on XS, other two phones little harsh
- Detail Quality
- iPhone XS: can see filament inside bulbs as separate object from glass
- iPhone X and Note 9: just seeing glowing ball
- This represents huge improvement
- Low-Light Performance
- iPhone X: worst performer; bright background completely destroyed; high grain levels on shirt when zoomed in
- iPhone XS: polar opposite; background evenly lit unlike any selfie camera ever used; trade-off is longer shutter time resulting in softer, less sharp result than both other devices
- Portrait Mode Front Camera
- iPhone X: serious problems in broad daylight; kept getting error message saying image too bright
- When working: all three decent but none would be mistaken for dual camera photos
- Hair detection: slightly better on XS and Note 9; no phone could separate hair from background
Photo Comparison - Rear Camera
- General Image Characteristics
- iPhone XS: instantly recognizable for even lighting and high saturation
- iPhone X and Note 9: noticeably darker shadows, darker looking images generally; lose much more detail in lighter parts of image
- Samsung: applies artificial sharpness to photos for crispy look
- Apple: opted for slightly less enhanced images
- HDR Capability
- All three phones have awesome HDR capability
- Even with sun directly in shot: foreground doesn't become silhouettes, remains well lit
- Portrait Mode Rear Camera
- Samsung Live Focus: always generally blown out skies and brighter areas
- iPhone X: little better especially on face where Note 9 has lost detail
- iPhone XS: different ballgame; pretty much zero spots of overexposure
- Synthetic Blur Adjustment: cool feature with great software implementation; doesn't work as well as desired; background can become super blurred giving massive depth of field but so can shirt; variable depth effect tends to isolate face from rest of image rather than isolating face and body from background
- Optical Zoom
- All three phones support 2x optical zoom using secondary cameras
- Low-Light Performance
- Note 9: obvious area of strength with variable aperture opening to f/1.5; long way ahead of iPhone X in super low light
- iPhone X: trouble focusing in super low light
- iPhone XS: leagues ahead of iPhone X; room so dim could barely see but photo dark but still sharp
- When zoomed in: Note 9's super wide aperture lends well to conditions; details much clearer and cleaner than both iPhones
- Detail and Noise
- All three phones: 12 megapixel primary sensors; similar general detail level when zoomed in
- iPhone X: darker shadows make some details harder to discern; noise levels little higher
- Edge goes to Note 9 and XS for detail/noise performance
Overall Assessment
- iPhone XS vs iPhone X: massive upgrade in terms of audio, dynamic range, selfies, and more; software and hardware difference quite possibly largest jump in iPhone history
- iPhone XS Limitations: hard time keeping body in focus when changing blur; selfies can look soft in low-light; 4K video stabilization leaves room for improvement
- Final Verdict: on balance, easily one of most powerful, reliable camera systems ever used
