AI summary by TwinMind
Is CERN's $40 Billion Mega-Collider Already Doomed?
Sabine Hossenfelder
7m 32s
Future Circular Collider (FCC) Overview
- CERN proposes building even bigger collider than Large Hadron Collider (LHC)
- 91 kilometers circumference ring tunnel
- Two-phase project:
- Phase 1: FCC-EE (electron collider) - measure Higgs boson properties
- Phase 2: FCC-HH (proton collider) - energies up to 85 TeV (6x more than LHC)
- Total costs exceed $40 billion
- Operation wouldn't start until mid-2070s
- CERN feasibility study confirms it's technically feasible
- Speaker gives 80% probability it won't come into existence
Scientific Value and Limitations
- Would measure Higgs properties more precisely
- Make more precise measurements of other known particles
- No open problems in standard model requiring solution in this energy range
- Likely won't find anything new
- Risk: tie up thousands of intelligent people in potential waste of time/money
- Could stall progress in physics foundations for another 50 years
Growing Opposition from Physicists
- Halina Abramovich (particle physicist, Guardian interview):
- Worried about stopping development of other technologies
- FCC could "soak up funds for years and years"
- Olivier Path (physicist, AFP interview):
- "Financial, ecological, and operating costs are astronomical"
- Better to fund smaller scientific projects
- Ruben Sakon (particle physicist, Nature interview):
- FCC is current CERN director's vision being pushed forward
- Researchers feel pressured to back FCC for unified front
- 400 French scientists signed petition against FCC citing environmental concerns
Funding and Economic Challenges
- CERN's annual funding insufficient for FCC
- Plan to increase member state contributions
- Still need additional 5 billion euros on top
- Unclear where money will come from
- EU economic situation makes funding difficult
- German Ministry for Science and Education already stated Germany won't pick up bill
- Germany struggling with own collider project:
- 10 years behind schedule
- 3 billion euros over budget
Alternative Collider Options
- Linear Muon Collider preferred by most particle physicists:
- Smaller and cheaper than FCC
- Comes online faster
- New engineering territory (never had muon collider before)
- Survey of early career particle physicists shows most excitement for Muon Collider
Chinese Competition
- China plans similar collider to FCC:
- Ring collider of same size
- Same collision energy capability
- Two-stage project: electron-positron collider first, then "super proton-proton collider"
- Claims 125 TeV capability (higher than FCC's 85 TeV)
- Less than half the cost of FCC
- 20 years faster timeline
- Chinese government decision due with next 5-year plan in 2026
- January conference: Chinese researcher reported collider plans rank top among 15 proposals in high energy category
- If China proceeds, would make FCC obsolete before completion
Conclusion and Prediction
- Speaker believes Chinese will proceed with their collider
- CERN will abandon FCC plans
- Muon collider will be built instead
- Satirical description: FCC as "most expensive way to get slightly better measurement of particle discovered in 2012"
