AI summary by TwinMind
Is San Francisco a Failed State? (And Other Questions You Shouldn’t Ask the Mayor) |...
Freakonomics Radio Network
59m 1s
Show Introduction and Context
- Steven Dubner hosting live Freakonomics Radio show at Sydney Goldstein Theater, San Francisco
- Recording during American Economics Association (AEA) annual meeting week (January 3rd)
- AEA held during cheapest week for hotels/conferences (immediately after New Year's)
- Upcoming LA show February 13th with Ari Emanuel, portion of ticket sales going to wildfire relief
- Live format different from usual heavily-produced podcast episodes
Interview with Mayor London Breed
- Final days in office before leaving mayoralty
- Addressed "failed state" perception vs. reality of San Francisco
- Helped 20,000+ people exit homelessness
- Significant crime rate decline, lowest homicide rate since 1960s
- Car break-ins under 10,000 (lowest since 2015)
- Created entertainment zones, night markets, "First Thursdays" events
- COVID response praised for early shutdown, emergency authority bypassed bureaucracy
- Lost re-election despite $20+ million spent against her campaign
- Cited Board of Supervisors bureaucracy as major obstacle to quick action
- Personal background: raised by grandmother in public housing, overcame significant barriers
- Experienced different treatment than previous mayors from traditional backgrounds
- Philosophy: "I may not like you, I don't have to like you, but I will work with you"
- Post-mayoral plans: exploring opportunities including potential DNC chair candidacy
- Democratic Party recommendations:
- Cultivate young new talent
- Invest resources in growing talent pipeline
- Listen to voters who may have different perspectives
- Unite behind candidates regardless of personal preferences
Interview with Coleman Strump (Wake Forest Economist)
- Childhood entrepreneurship: sold candy at school markup, appeared in Tang commercial
- Research focus: illicit/taboo activities (sports betting, cannabis, file sharing)
- Data collection methods for illegal markets through law enforcement connections
- Cannabis market analysis using Weedmaps app data
- Scraped data from app for several years using multiple computers
- Cross-referenced with California's legal dispensary list
- Found ~70% of LA cannabis shops illegal vs ~20% in San Francisco
- Illegal shops use fake license numbers or copy legitimate ones
- Sophisticated counterfeiting including branded packaging
- Sports betting and prediction markets
- Historically more accurate than polling
- French citizen made $80 million betting on Trump using neighbor polling methodology
- Polling difficulties: no landlines, caller ID, location independence
- Historical San Francisco election betting markets in cigar stores (1900s)
- "Freak bets" for non-monetary wagers
- 1916 example: loser dressed as woman, arrested (crossdressing illegal until ~40 years ago)
Interview with Eric Brynjolfsson (Stanford AI Economist)
- Senior Fellow at Stanford Institute for Human-Centered AI
- Director of Stanford Digital Economy Lab
- Moved from MIT to Stanford 4 years ago
- "Mindful optimist" about AI (vs blind optimist or pessimist)
- Advocates moving beyond Turing Test toward human-AI complementarity
- AI risks: misinformation, AI relationships, pathogens, catastrophic scenarios
- AI benefits: 44% more materials discovery, medical solutions, productivity gains
GDP-B (GDP for Benefits) Proposal
- Traditional GDP measures production costs, not consumer value
- GDP-B measures consumer surplus (value received minus price paid)
- Example: Wikipedia worth $15/month to user but costs $0 = $15 consumer surplus
- Americans spend 8+ hours daily on screens (half waking hours)
- Digital goods often free but provide significant unmeasured value
- Methodology: surveys asking compensation needed to give up services
- Currently measuring ~250 goods, goal of several thousand
- Funded by National Science Foundation, Sloan Foundation
Antitrust and Regulation Implications
- Consumer welfare standard should guide antitrust decisions
- European regulators concerned about money flow to US tech companies
- Student showed French citizens receive more value than they pay
- European attitudes shifting as they develop own tech companies (Mistral)
Silicon Valley Innovation Culture
- Moved to Bay Area 2020, underestimated innovation culture
- Concentration of AI innovation increased since ChatGPT
- Attracts global talent with world-changing mindset
- Wealth creation allows governmental slack/mismanagement
- Advocates congestion pricing, pollution taxes over work/investment taxes
- Housing costs due to supply/demand imbalance, not inherent necessity
