AI summary by TwinMind

Is the United States a Country?

RealLifeLore

8m 32s

Definition of a Country

  • Traditional definition: state with sovereignty over geographic area, permanent population, defined territory, one government, capacity for international relations
  • Question: Does US perfectly match this description?

US Territory Outside America

  • Only 99.5% of US actually located in North/South America
  • 1.6% of Americans live outside America
  • Non-American US land: islands in Caribbean and Pacific

Hawaii and Pacific Territories

  • Hawaii: only state outside America (1 of 50 states)
  • US Territories: governed directly by Congress
  • Divided between incorporated and unincorporated territories
  • No representation in Congress, cannot vote for president

Guam

  • 3,633 miles from nearest state (Hawaii)
  • 7,912 miles from US Capitol building
  • Population: 160,000 people

Other Populated Territories

  • Northern Mariana Islands
  • American Samoa
  • US Virgin Islands
  • Puerto Rico
  • 8 other uninhabited islands

Constitutional Application

  • US Constitution only partially applies in territories
  • Puerto Rico: higher population than 21 actual states
  • May become 51st state in future

Palmyra Atoll

  • Only incorporated territory
  • Uninhabited
  • Full US Constitution applies
  • Anyone born there automatically becomes US citizen
  • Administered by US President

Contested Territories

  • Two uninhabited islands claimed by Colombia (covered in bird poop)
  • Islands off Maine coast claimed by both US and Canada
    • Birth on these islands grants both American and Canadian citizenship
  • Guantanamo Bay, Cuba
    • Larger than 5 unrecognized sovereign states
    • Same size as Jersey (between England and France)
    • Cuba has claimed territory since 1959
    • US continues to maintain control

The 50 States System

  • 49 states plus Hawaii make up 99.5% of country
  • States elect representatives to Congress
  • Congress creates laws for entire Union
  • States granted considerable power by Congress
  • Power shared between state and federal government

Federal vs State Law

  • Both levels can pass separate laws
  • Has caused historical conflicts
  • Civil War settled: federal law always wins over state law
  • States cannot leave union once joined
  • States cannot declare federal law invalid
  • States can legalize things federally illegal

Marijuana Legalization Example

  • Federally illegal everywhere in US
  • Fully legalized in: Nevada, Maine, Colorado, Washington, California, Massachusetts, Alaska, Oregon
  • Federal government could theoretically arrest hundreds of thousands participating in legal state but illegal federal activities
  • Haven't done so because "not worth their time"

State Identity and Separatist Movements

  • Question: How many people identify more with state than country?
  • Active separatist movements despite illegality of secession:
    • Alaska, Hawaii, California, Oregon, Washington, Vermont, New Hampshire
    • Former Confederate States
    • Texas (most famous)
  • Most significant movements:
    • Texas, Hawaii, Alaska
    • Alaska Independence Party: polling at 6% of population
    • Got candidate elected governor in 1990

American Indian Reservations

  • 326 reservations within US
  • 12 reservations larger than Rhode Island
  • Navajo Nation: same size as West Virginia or Latvia
    • Population: nearly 200,000
  • Total reservation population: over 1 million
  • Total reservation area: size of Idaho or larger than Belarus

Tribal Sovereignty

  • Granted "tribal sovereignty" rights
  • Can govern themselves within US territory
  • Federal government recognizes as "domestic dependent nations"
  • Have jurisdiction over own land
  • Can pass laws separate from or violating state and federal laws
  • Example: largest casino in world located on Oklahoma reservation despite gambling being illegal in Oklahoma
  • Some have own courts, police forces, elect own presidents
  • Lead foreign delegations as representatives of reservation, not US

Federal Government Control

  • Only 100% federally governed territory:
    • Washington DC (not part of any state)
    • US territories (islands)
  • All other areas have varying degrees of independence

Comparison to European Union

  • Both composed of different states
  • Both have open borders
  • Both have common currency
  • Both have central government with state representatives
  • Key difference: US is considered a country, EU is made up of countries

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome