AI summary by TwinMind
Is the United States a Country?
RealLifeLore
8m 32s
Definition of a Country
- Traditional definition: state with sovereignty over geographic area, permanent population, defined territory, one government, capacity for international relations
- Question: Does US perfectly match this description?
US Territory Outside America
- Only 99.5% of US actually located in North/South America
- 1.6% of Americans live outside America
- Non-American US land: islands in Caribbean and Pacific
Hawaii and Pacific Territories
- Hawaii: only state outside America (1 of 50 states)
- US Territories: governed directly by Congress
- Divided between incorporated and unincorporated territories
- No representation in Congress, cannot vote for president
Guam
- 3,633 miles from nearest state (Hawaii)
- 7,912 miles from US Capitol building
- Population: 160,000 people
Other Populated Territories
- Northern Mariana Islands
- American Samoa
- US Virgin Islands
- Puerto Rico
- 8 other uninhabited islands
Constitutional Application
- US Constitution only partially applies in territories
- Puerto Rico: higher population than 21 actual states
- May become 51st state in future
Palmyra Atoll
- Only incorporated territory
- Uninhabited
- Full US Constitution applies
- Anyone born there automatically becomes US citizen
- Administered by US President
Contested Territories
- Two uninhabited islands claimed by Colombia (covered in bird poop)
- Islands off Maine coast claimed by both US and Canada
- Birth on these islands grants both American and Canadian citizenship
- Guantanamo Bay, Cuba
- Larger than 5 unrecognized sovereign states
- Same size as Jersey (between England and France)
- Cuba has claimed territory since 1959
- US continues to maintain control
The 50 States System
- 49 states plus Hawaii make up 99.5% of country
- States elect representatives to Congress
- Congress creates laws for entire Union
- States granted considerable power by Congress
- Power shared between state and federal government
Federal vs State Law
- Both levels can pass separate laws
- Has caused historical conflicts
- Civil War settled: federal law always wins over state law
- States cannot leave union once joined
- States cannot declare federal law invalid
- States can legalize things federally illegal
Marijuana Legalization Example
- Federally illegal everywhere in US
- Fully legalized in: Nevada, Maine, Colorado, Washington, California, Massachusetts, Alaska, Oregon
- Federal government could theoretically arrest hundreds of thousands participating in legal state but illegal federal activities
- Haven't done so because "not worth their time"
State Identity and Separatist Movements
- Question: How many people identify more with state than country?
- Active separatist movements despite illegality of secession:
- Alaska, Hawaii, California, Oregon, Washington, Vermont, New Hampshire
- Former Confederate States
- Texas (most famous)
- Most significant movements:
- Texas, Hawaii, Alaska
- Alaska Independence Party: polling at 6% of population
- Got candidate elected governor in 1990
American Indian Reservations
- 326 reservations within US
- 12 reservations larger than Rhode Island
- Navajo Nation: same size as West Virginia or Latvia
- Population: nearly 200,000
- Total reservation population: over 1 million
- Total reservation area: size of Idaho or larger than Belarus
Tribal Sovereignty
- Granted "tribal sovereignty" rights
- Can govern themselves within US territory
- Federal government recognizes as "domestic dependent nations"
- Have jurisdiction over own land
- Can pass laws separate from or violating state and federal laws
- Example: largest casino in world located on Oklahoma reservation despite gambling being illegal in Oklahoma
- Some have own courts, police forces, elect own presidents
- Lead foreign delegations as representatives of reservation, not US
Federal Government Control
- Only 100% federally governed territory:
- Washington DC (not part of any state)
- US territories (islands)
- All other areas have varying degrees of independence
Comparison to European Union
- Both composed of different states
- Both have open borders
- Both have common currency
- Both have central government with state representatives
- Key difference: US is considered a country, EU is made up of countries
