AI summary by TwinMind
Itamar Mann: An app that empowers people to solve their legal problems | TED Fellows
TED
6m 6s
Danielle's Story - Illustrating the Access to Justice Crisis
- Senior in college when father passed away, leaving mother without support
- Dropped out of college, took 3 jobs: barista, bartender, car washer
- Total annual income: $23,000
- Car accident with deer, crashed into barn
- Injuries: damaged brain stem and C1 vertebrae
- Medical bills: $55,000
- Spent 2 years unable to pay debt on $23,000 salary
- Bankruptcy lawyer cost: $1,500 (unaffordable)
The Access to Justice Problem
- Cruel irony: costs $1,500 to tell court you have no money
- Courts direct everyone to find lawyers regardless of financial ability
- Civil rights injustice: equal rights only if you can afford lawyer
- No right to free lawyer in most civil cases (unlike criminal cases)
- Insufficient pro bono/legal aid lawyers available
- 4 out of 5 low-income Americans cannot get needed legal help for civil rights
Upsolve Solution
- Nonprofit organization started 4 years ago
- Mission: fight for new civil right to solve own legal problems without lawyer
- Built app for free bankruptcy filing
- App features:
- Questions about finances in understandable language
- Generates required forms automatically
- Danielle used Upsolve to file bankruptcy for free
- Received debt relief letter after Christmas Day
- Now has highest paying job ever, on track to finish degree
Broader Applications and Opportunities
- Applicable to nonadversarial legal areas:
- No-asset bankruptcies
- Uncontested divorces
- Social Security disability claims
- Potential to create more just legal system through self-service tools
Two Main Barriers to Reform
Legal Complexity
- Forms and courts designed around lawyers, not regular people
- Legal forms function as "modern day literacy tests"
- Poorly designed forms/processes deny millions their rights annually
- Impact on "life, liberty and property"
- Solutions needed:
- Require basic user testing in courts
- Revise assumption that everyone can afford lawyers in poverty law
Closed Culture
- Pushback from those believing lawyer always necessary
- Analogy: requiring doctor visit for headache instead of buying Advil
- Telling poor people to find unaffordable lawyers is:
- Out of touch
- Intimidating
- Unfair
- Wrong
Racial and Economic Justice Issues
- Black and brown communities disproportionately cannot afford legal fees
- Legal fees function as "modern day poll taxes"
- Cannot access rights without ability to pay fees
- Decision point: how open and equal should justice system be
Call to Action
- Need new civil right: right to solve own legal problems when can't afford lawyer
- Must eliminate modern day literacy tests and poll taxes in courts
- Rights should be inalienable, protections equal
- Everyone deserves life, liberty, pursuit of happiness regardless of legal fee affordability
