AI summary by TwinMind
It’s not you - movies are getting darker.
Vox
6m 43s
Introduction to Movie Darkness Trend
- Batman franchise example: 13 on-screen appearances across 60 years showing evolution from bright 1960s films to dark 2022's "The Batman"
- Pattern visible across multiple franchises: Harry Potter, Game of Thrones, Spider-Man
- Movies and TV shows definitively getting darker over time
Film vs Digital Technology Shift
- Stephen Follows data: Top 100 grossing US films 2000-2015 showed flip point from film to digital cameras
- Major technological shift driving darkness trend
Film Shooting Limitations
- Brett Jukowitz (cinematographer): Ready or Not, Black Phone, Stranger Things Season 4
- Film shooting constraints:
- No accurate preview monitors (only video taps for framing reference)
- Must use light meters and trust measurements
- Dark scene information lost in darkest image parts
- Overall image becomes grainier
- No room for error in Hollywood productions
- Cannot reshoot scenes easily due to cost/scheduling
- Example comparison: 2002 Spider-Man (film) vs 2012 Amazing Spider-Man (digital) - faces much brighter in film version
- Film shooting strategy: shoot with plenty of light even for intended dark scenes
Digital Camera Advantages
- High quality digital monitors show final image appearance
- Enables taking more risks with darkness
- More sensitive to light than film
- Capture more highlight and shadow information
- Log format shooting:
- Captures flat, grayish image
- Preserves highlight and shadow information
- Extensive post-production flexibility in color grading
- Can push footage brighter without losing detail
- Doesn't become super grainy
Artistic Balance and Intentions
- Dark scenes possible on film (The Godfather, Dark Knight, Euphoria) but harder/riskier
- Balance between information preservation and artistic vision
- Severance example: using darkness to focus attention on specific frame elements
- Darkness as tool for guiding viewer's eye
- Problem only when audience feels they're missing important visual information
- Challenge: creating mood without hindering audience enjoyment
Production and Distribution Challenges
- Filmmakers use best available screens in perfectly dark rooms for brightness calibration
- Content optimized for highest quality displays
- Vision expected to "trickle down" to consumer screens
- Impossible to predict final viewing conditions
- Optimization dilemma: low-quality TV vs theater experience
Future Technology Developments
- Ad Astra and Nope used regular + infrared cameras
- Infrared capabilities:
- "Steal light" from invisible light spectrum sections
- Create black sky useful for compositing
- Blend images for deeper dark expanse visibility
- Technology evolution offering better solutions for darkness challenges
