AI summary by TwinMind
Japanese Fine Arts? Or Furniture?
Asianometry
12m 14s
Background and Context
- Speaker visited Tokyo National Museum during Japan trip, inspired by Japanese art/cultural artifacts
- Story focuses on post-Meiji Restoration Japan (second half 1800s) seeking Western engagement
- Japan discovered West viewed their treasured crafts as "just furniture"
- Three World Fairs became test of Japan's influence and internal development
Early European Exposure to Japanese Art (1862)
- Europe's first major exposure: 1862 London exhibition
- Showed woodworking, ivory, lacquerware in "Japanese Court" international exhibition
- Set up by British minister to Japan Rutherford Alcock (unofficial)
- Smashing success, started "Japonism" trend
- Japonism: phrase coined late 19th century describing European/American popularity for Japanese art/design
- Western artists captivated by ukiyo-e (pictures of floating world)
- Famous Great Wave of Kanagawa print by Hokusai influenced van Gogh to Apple ocean wave emoji
First Official World Fair Participation - Vienna 1873
- 1871: Meiji government agreed to participate in Vienna World Fair (Wiener Weltausstellung) 1873
- First exhibition held outside UK/France
- 35 countries participated; non-Western: China, Egypt, Persia
Japan's Strategic Goals
- Primary goal: avoid China's fate of being carved up by foreign interests
- China had coastal areas like Hong Kong turned into foreign concessions
- 1850s: Japan ceded 5 ports to foreign governments via unequal treaties
- Meiji modernization wave needed foreign currency funding
- Three exhibition objectives:
- Examine foreign goods for adoptable techniques
- Demonstrate Japan's fertile land/excellent goods capability - kick-start export market
- Keep historical heritage items within country (policy: shokusan kogyo - promotion of industry)
Exhibition Preparation and Execution
- Preparatory work: 2+ years, directed by Council of State (highest political body)
- Budget allocation: 500,000 yen from meager budget
- Key consultant: Dr. Godfrey Wagner
- Came to Japan 1868 to open soap factory
- Later taught Western ceramics at University of Tokyo
- Selected goods exhibiting high technical craftsmanship/precision handcrafted products
Items Exhibited
- Historical treasures to manufactured goods
- Lager from Osaka brewery
- Edo period armor/weapons
- Sword set belonging to Toyotomi Hiroshi
- First Japanese garden ever in Europe + Shinto shrine
- 15-meter Great Buddha statue from Todaiji Temple (burned during unpacking, only head exhibited)
Results
- World fair had flooding/cholera epidemic issues
- Japanese items sold well, including garden (sold to British Trading Company)
- Government founded export company: Kiritsu Kosho Kaisha
Language and Conceptual Challenges
- Translation issue: "Fine Arts" term didn't exist in Japanese
- West distinguished between:
- Fine Arts: made solely for aesthetic purpose
- Decorative Arts: beautiful and useful
- Japanese had generic term "gigay" focusing on materials/techniques/skills rather than aesthetics
- Created new terms:
- "Bijutsu" (1873): includes Chinese character for beautiful, indicates Fine Arts concept
- "Kogay" (1890): decorative arts, literally means crafts
Paris 1878 Exhibition and Growing Criticism
- Japanese goods classified as decorative arts
- Treasures (ceramics, lacquerware, folding screens) seen as inferior art/trinkets
- Lacquerware example: writing box with eight bridges (1700, National Treasure)
- Praised by furniture maker Albert Giacometti: "bright, brilliant, intense"
- Criticized by art critic Ernest Chesnow: "pastiche of manual objects with decorated motifs"
- Criticism brewing since 1862 exhibition
- 1883: Louis Gonse published "L'art Japonais" reinforcing negative framing
- Counter-criticism: Philippe Bertie (coined "japonism") called 1878 exhibition "great victory for objects combining art and functionality"
Market Saturation and Policy Shift (1880s-1890s)
- 1880s: japonism export trend reached full height
- 1882: flood of low-quality goods saturating market despite quality control attempts
- Meiji government wanted to show Japan as modern nation with sophisticated artistic culture
Educational and Artistic Reforms
- Changed artistic traditions to meet Western standards
- Opened Fine Art schools
- Sent Japanese artists to Europe for learning
- Encouraged participation in shows
- Notable emerging artists:
- Kuroda Seiki: father of modern western-style painting in Japan
- Takamura Koun: applied Western techniques to Japanese wooden statue making
Wagner's Advice
- Repeatedly urged Japanese officials to resist copying Western products outright
- Quote: "efforts should be made to give play to unique national ways and means"
- Essentially: don't lose what makes them special
Chicago 1893 World Exposition - Strategic Pivot
- Market tests 1885-1890: japonism export industry on downward turn
- Government shifted policy focus from decorative arts exports to industrialized manufacturing
- Tokyo National Museum reassigned goals: display/boost traditional Japanese Fine Arts
High-Stakes Cultural Diplomacy
- Committee vowed to "elevate decorative arts to same level as Fine Arts"
- Official policy: "recognition as works of art should be sought for art without distinction between painting and decorative Arts"
- Strategic timing: 1894 unequal treaties due for revision by US Congress (Treaty of November 22, 1894)
- Japan anxious to be seen as equal international community member
Results and Legacy
- Western art community largely continued hard delineation between fine/decorative arts
- Few Japanese items exhibited as Fine Arts were made by Western-trained Japanese artists
- Traditional categories (lacquerware, ceramics) remained in manufacturers section, not Fine Arts Palace
- Japanese government learned valuable lessons about building global influence
- Important step toward Japan's future rise on world stage
