AI summary by TwinMind
Jaron Lanier: Virtual Reality, Social Media & the Future of Humans and AI | Lex Fridman Podcast #218
Lex Fridman
1h 52m 29s
Virtual Reality Philosophy and Physical World Appreciation
- VR's most valuable moment: taking off headset, senses refreshed, perceiving physicality afresh like newborn with experience
- Magic remains in physical world, VR helps appreciate reality's strangeness/delicacy
- Mixed/augmented reality: augmenting forest makes real tree "pop out" as astounding
- First surgical simulator (1980s with Dr. Joe Rosen at Stanford): transition from fake anatomy to real person "wakes up" surgeons
- Transition more valuable than simulation itself
Software vs Physical Reality Distinction
- Software is "terrible stuff" - slave to legacy, infinitely arbitrary/messy, brings out nerdy personality
- Universe as computer: must be some kind of computer (follows principles, intelligible, programmable)
- Turing machines are "teases" - universal only with infinite programmer/time/memory/clock speed
- Not universal in practice within conservation principles of reality
- Universality of particular model probably deceptive way to think
Media Evolution and Human Adaptation
- People constantly learning/evolving/self-programmable, not fixed perception ability
- Early wire recorder opera singer indistinguishable from real (peer review paper)
- Early video teleconferencing (1930s NYC-DC) viewed as absolutely realistic
- Civil War era: people bought photos of strangers resembling loved ones (photography/painters too expensive/impractical)
- Greatest gift of photography: seeing flaws, appreciating reality more
- Greatest gift of audio recording: distinguishing recorded from live performance
- Shouldn't limit ourselves by assumption of stasis
AI Skepticism and Computational Metaphors
- Doesn't believe in AI - "just algorithms we make and control, tools not creatures"
- Argued with mentor Marvin Minsky (principal author of computer-as-creature rhetoric) since 1970s
- Consciousness attribution: matter of faith, nobody can claim absolute knowledge
- Circle of empathy: faith-based decision about what deserves consideration
- Can't be pure faith - pragmatic decision (too big = incompetence, too small = cruelty)
- Including AI makes you incompetent engineer/designer immediately
- Need to subordinate algorithms, be more skeptical
Social Media Manipulation Mechanisms
- Algorithms work on crude feedback loops: present stimulus, measure response
- Measurement mechanism very crude: clicks, screen staring time
- Only catches dramatic responses: fight-or-flight, scared, pissed off, aggressive, horny
- Ancient "lizard brain" circuits - helpful for survival occasionally but not us at our best
- Makes people incrementally more paranoid, xenophobic, aggressive, stupid, jerky
- Happens slowly/progressively for people who get hooked
- Engagement part works, persuade part is "iffy"
- Becomes "giant cognitive access blackmail scheme"
Social Media Solutions and Alternatives
- People should be responsible for curation, not algorithms
- Algorithms "are crap in this era" - don't understand enough to recommend
- Example: YouTube 17-18 hop experiment with high school kids - majority end up in "weird paranoid bizarre territory"
- GitHub as positive example: people have stake in it, real-world consequences, shared responsibility
- Need systems respectful of people, subordinate to people, without perverse incentives
Data Dignity Economic Model
- Alternative to current social media economics
- Two futures comparison using Berkeley Hill groundskeepers example:
- Future 1: Robots replace workers, people on basic income (centralized, seizeable, unstable)
- Future 2: Workers form data unions, improve robots, become new creative class
- Data unions: people selling data cooperatively, making systems better than raw data grabbing
- Massive data unions for social media content
- People pay for platforms like Netflix, with allowance for poor
- Economy as measuring device: honest economy produces bell curve distribution
- Expanding economy from creativity/expertise flowing through network
- Individual might join thousands of data unions over lifetime
Cryptocurrency and Economic Philosophy
- Disappointed by Bitcoin: "applying fancy distributed security to recreate gold standard"
- Computational inefficiency at boundless scale as security = "crime against atmosphere"
- Bitcoin ownership concentrated (60+ people own quarter of all bitcoin)
- Hasn't seen Bitcoin create economic growth, productivity, creativity
- Pro digital currencies generally, anti using economics to wipe out politics
- Politics = people dealing with each other, can't be avoided through abstract systems
- Freedom = "perpetual annoyance" (dealing with people is annoying but necessary)
Death, Mortality, and Meaning
- Ernest Becker's "Denial of Death": fear of death drives thought/civilization formation
- Both dualist soul-believers and hardcore computationalists motivated by death avoidance
- Computationalists: "brain's computer, I'll figure it out, upload myself, live forever"
- Personal experience: less afraid of death with age due to familiarity
- Optimism about future requires making room for it - "can't believe in future and want to live forever"
- Mother died in car accident after surviving concentration camps, was Vienna piano prodigy
- Connected to her through music (Viennese school, Beethoven sonatas)
Music and Consciousness Philosophy
- Music "towers above me" - doesn't fully understand it
- Music has "substantiality" that's "philosophically impossible"
- Amount of understanding from right song at right time incomparable to language/Wikipedia
- Music connects to something beyond explanation
- Makes him consider panpsychism possibility but remains "proudly dualist"
- Treats people as special, pragmatic imperative
- Experience is "something real and apart, something mystical"
Physics and Autodidactic Universe
- Co-authored paper with Lee Smolin on universe as self-learning system
- Triple correspondence: physics theories as matrix models as machine learning systems
- Goal: new tools for theoretical physics (many programs feel "stalled")
- Pushes storytelling about universe origins further back - simple things evolving through simple principles
- Universe might use different kind of "time-like" dimension for evolution
- All "super baby steps" - approaching old problems in fresh way informed by machine learning correspondences
Advice for Young People
- Find way to pay attention to internal experience, escape constant social manipulation
- Believe experience is real, magical (dualistic philosophy)
- Kindness requires genius - facile kindness isn't kindness, takes skill/hard lessons
- Social/interpersonal emotions overwhelming when young - remember how fragile that "crust" is
- Defining moments often horrible rather than good ones
- Hard lessons necessary - world avoiding hard lessons becomes "stupid world"
- Young people deserve "grace period of naivete"
