AI summary by TwinMind

Jaron Lanier: Virtual Reality, Social Media & the Future of Humans and AI | Lex Fridman Podcast #218

Lex Fridman

1h 52m 29s

Virtual Reality Philosophy and Physical World Appreciation

  • VR's most valuable moment: taking off headset, senses refreshed, perceiving physicality afresh like newborn with experience
  • Magic remains in physical world, VR helps appreciate reality's strangeness/delicacy
  • Mixed/augmented reality: augmenting forest makes real tree "pop out" as astounding
  • First surgical simulator (1980s with Dr. Joe Rosen at Stanford): transition from fake anatomy to real person "wakes up" surgeons
  • Transition more valuable than simulation itself

Software vs Physical Reality Distinction

  • Software is "terrible stuff" - slave to legacy, infinitely arbitrary/messy, brings out nerdy personality
  • Universe as computer: must be some kind of computer (follows principles, intelligible, programmable)
  • Turing machines are "teases" - universal only with infinite programmer/time/memory/clock speed
  • Not universal in practice within conservation principles of reality
  • Universality of particular model probably deceptive way to think

Media Evolution and Human Adaptation

  • People constantly learning/evolving/self-programmable, not fixed perception ability
  • Early wire recorder opera singer indistinguishable from real (peer review paper)
  • Early video teleconferencing (1930s NYC-DC) viewed as absolutely realistic
  • Civil War era: people bought photos of strangers resembling loved ones (photography/painters too expensive/impractical)
  • Greatest gift of photography: seeing flaws, appreciating reality more
  • Greatest gift of audio recording: distinguishing recorded from live performance
  • Shouldn't limit ourselves by assumption of stasis

AI Skepticism and Computational Metaphors

  • Doesn't believe in AI - "just algorithms we make and control, tools not creatures"
  • Argued with mentor Marvin Minsky (principal author of computer-as-creature rhetoric) since 1970s
  • Consciousness attribution: matter of faith, nobody can claim absolute knowledge
  • Circle of empathy: faith-based decision about what deserves consideration
  • Can't be pure faith - pragmatic decision (too big = incompetence, too small = cruelty)
  • Including AI makes you incompetent engineer/designer immediately
  • Need to subordinate algorithms, be more skeptical

Social Media Manipulation Mechanisms

  • Algorithms work on crude feedback loops: present stimulus, measure response
  • Measurement mechanism very crude: clicks, screen staring time
  • Only catches dramatic responses: fight-or-flight, scared, pissed off, aggressive, horny
  • Ancient "lizard brain" circuits - helpful for survival occasionally but not us at our best
  • Makes people incrementally more paranoid, xenophobic, aggressive, stupid, jerky
  • Happens slowly/progressively for people who get hooked
  • Engagement part works, persuade part is "iffy"
  • Becomes "giant cognitive access blackmail scheme"

Social Media Solutions and Alternatives

  • People should be responsible for curation, not algorithms
  • Algorithms "are crap in this era" - don't understand enough to recommend
  • Example: YouTube 17-18 hop experiment with high school kids - majority end up in "weird paranoid bizarre territory"
  • GitHub as positive example: people have stake in it, real-world consequences, shared responsibility
  • Need systems respectful of people, subordinate to people, without perverse incentives

Data Dignity Economic Model

  • Alternative to current social media economics
  • Two futures comparison using Berkeley Hill groundskeepers example:
    • Future 1: Robots replace workers, people on basic income (centralized, seizeable, unstable)
    • Future 2: Workers form data unions, improve robots, become new creative class
  • Data unions: people selling data cooperatively, making systems better than raw data grabbing
  • Massive data unions for social media content
  • People pay for platforms like Netflix, with allowance for poor
  • Economy as measuring device: honest economy produces bell curve distribution
  • Expanding economy from creativity/expertise flowing through network
  • Individual might join thousands of data unions over lifetime

Cryptocurrency and Economic Philosophy

  • Disappointed by Bitcoin: "applying fancy distributed security to recreate gold standard"
  • Computational inefficiency at boundless scale as security = "crime against atmosphere"
  • Bitcoin ownership concentrated (60+ people own quarter of all bitcoin)
  • Hasn't seen Bitcoin create economic growth, productivity, creativity
  • Pro digital currencies generally, anti using economics to wipe out politics
  • Politics = people dealing with each other, can't be avoided through abstract systems
  • Freedom = "perpetual annoyance" (dealing with people is annoying but necessary)

Death, Mortality, and Meaning

  • Ernest Becker's "Denial of Death": fear of death drives thought/civilization formation
  • Both dualist soul-believers and hardcore computationalists motivated by death avoidance
  • Computationalists: "brain's computer, I'll figure it out, upload myself, live forever"
  • Personal experience: less afraid of death with age due to familiarity
  • Optimism about future requires making room for it - "can't believe in future and want to live forever"
  • Mother died in car accident after surviving concentration camps, was Vienna piano prodigy
  • Connected to her through music (Viennese school, Beethoven sonatas)

Music and Consciousness Philosophy

  • Music "towers above me" - doesn't fully understand it
  • Music has "substantiality" that's "philosophically impossible"
  • Amount of understanding from right song at right time incomparable to language/Wikipedia
  • Music connects to something beyond explanation
  • Makes him consider panpsychism possibility but remains "proudly dualist"
  • Treats people as special, pragmatic imperative
  • Experience is "something real and apart, something mystical"

Physics and Autodidactic Universe

  • Co-authored paper with Lee Smolin on universe as self-learning system
  • Triple correspondence: physics theories as matrix models as machine learning systems
  • Goal: new tools for theoretical physics (many programs feel "stalled")
  • Pushes storytelling about universe origins further back - simple things evolving through simple principles
  • Universe might use different kind of "time-like" dimension for evolution
  • All "super baby steps" - approaching old problems in fresh way informed by machine learning correspondences

Advice for Young People

  • Find way to pay attention to internal experience, escape constant social manipulation
  • Believe experience is real, magical (dualistic philosophy)
  • Kindness requires genius - facile kindness isn't kindness, takes skill/hard lessons
  • Social/interpersonal emotions overwhelming when young - remember how fragile that "crust" is
  • Defining moments often horrible rather than good ones
  • Hard lessons necessary - world avoiding hard lessons becomes "stupid world"
  • Young people deserve "grace period of naivete"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome