AI summary by TwinMind
JavaScript Framework Tier List
Theo - t3․gg
40m 57s
Framework Ranking Overview
- Ranking every JavaScript framework in tier list format (S, A, B, C, D, F)
- Using vanilla JavaScript as C-tier baseline reference point
- Evaluating frameworks based on developer experience, syntax, community, and impact
Individual Framework Rankings
S-Tier Frameworks
- jQuery: S-tier
- Foundation of modern internet
- Still present on majority of websites
- Fantastic developer experience
- Script tag setup approach
- Solid: S-tier (just behind jQuery)
- Best performance benchmarks, nearly vanilla JS speed
- Uses JSX but compiles to signals-based reactivity
- Create signal, create effect primitives
- HTM support for no-build-step development
- Solid Start making significant progress
- Two S's in name = bonus points
A-Tier Frameworks
- Angular: A-tier
- Massive historical impact on web development
- Enabled large codebases with hundreds of developers
- Kickstarted component-based web architecture
- Transition from AngularJS to Angular was significant
- Personal hatred for development experience but acknowledges importance
- Lit: A-tier (moved up from B)
- Built around web components standards
- Creates actual HTML elements usable in browser
- Good for reusable components across projects
- Vanilla JavaScript compatibility
- Pleasant abstraction over raw web components
- Nuxt: A-tier (highest-rated meta framework)
- Full-stack plugin system
- TypeScript-based RPC solution with automatic type inference
- Use fetch with network call deduplication
- Dollar sign fetch with type safety
- Only way presenter would use Vue
- Compelling meta framework evolution
B-Tier Frameworks
- Handlebars: B-tier (slightly above vanilla JS)
- Important templating language concept
- Standardized HTML generation from JavaScript
- Opposite approach to jQuery (generate vs manipulate)
- Historical significance in JS/HTML relationship
- Preact: B-tier
- Fast React alternative focused on bundle size
- Strict bundle size rules (add feature = delete equivalent code)
- HTM support for no-transpilation JSX
- Class components and hooks support
- First to implement signals in React-like framework
- Educational value for understanding React internals
- Recent performance benchmarks not as competitive
- Next.js: B-tier
- S-tier for extensibility and abuse potential
- Core primitives historically painful (getServerSideProps)
- API directory excellent for JSON endpoints
- Great with tRPC integration
- App router improvements but still issues with file-based routing
- Server components value comes from React, not Next
- Svelte: B-tier (front of B-tier)
- Historically important, challenged React dominance
- Rethinking Reactivity talk was influential
- Single file component architecture commitment
- Custom templating syntax reinvents JavaScript in HTML
- #each syntax:
#each array.from(Array(6).keys()) as row - @debug alternative to console.log
- Syntax preferences over React's JSX approach
C-Tier Frameworks
- Vanilla JavaScript: C-tier (baseline)
- Solid middle ground reference point
- Won't make things worse or better
- All other frameworks compared against this baseline
- Quick: C-tier (slightly better than vanilla JS)
- Created by Misko (original Angular creator)
- Focuses on resumability vs hydration
- Addresses JavaScript bundle size, time-to-interactive issues
- Component$() syntax for component definition
- Hybrid of Solid and Remix concepts
- Resumability benefits questionable for most use cases
- Other frameworks catching up with hybrid hydration
D-Tier Frameworks
- Alpine.js: D-tier
- Lightweight framework with script tag setup
- 15 attributes, 6 properties, 2 methods
- Vue-syntax for mid-version of HTMX
- JavaScript-in-string approach
- Would have ranked higher before HTMX relevance
- Vue: Low A-tier (but mentioned for comparison)
- Incredible international community
- Docs internationalized rapidly
- Single file component trend starter
- v-for syntax with specific runtime requirements
- Vue JSX exists but <33% adoption rate
- Less dynamic than pure JavaScript approaches
- Vue Vapor (Solid-like rewrite) anticipated
F-Tier Frameworks
- Astro: F-tier
- Not actually a JavaScript framework
- Ships no browser-running code
- HTML generation on server only
- Can mount React components but no native router/JS
- Imposter framework
- Ember: F-tier
- Caused presenter to initially dislike web development
- Heavy code generation approach
- Handlebars-based templating (HBS)
- @tracked decorator syntax
- Template/JavaScript separation with non-deterministic behavior
- Development mode required to catch binding errors
- GitHub highlighting doesn't work properly
- Remix: F-tier (same tier as Quick)
- Important for web evolution but wouldn't use personally
- Route-level loader/action separation problematic
- Non-deterministic component/data relationships
- Moving components breaks functionality silently
- Switch statements required for multiple actions per route
- Normalized important patterns (streaming, TTFB, server React)
- Influenced Next.js and React development
- Gatsby: F-tier
- React framework with HTML page generation
- Massive GraphQL layer for data management
- Plugin system for WordPress, Markdown integration
- Extremely painful development experience
- Acquired by Netlify, framework largely abandoned
- Worst possible approach to React website generation
- Flutter Web: F-tier
- Escapes web primitives entirely
- Canvas-based rendering
- No DOM, no button elements
- Accessibility issues (screen readers)
- Even Flutter advocates don't recommend web usage
- Elm: D-tier
- Functional programming language, not just framework
- Benchmarks against outdated frameworks (Angular 1/2, old React)
- Nested vertical syntax approach
- Manual text/element assignment with arrays
- Too far into FP territory for practical adoption
- Minimal recent development/adoption
Special Mentions
- HTMX: F-tier (not JavaScript framework)
- Allows backend developers to create interactive web apps
- Eliminates need for JavaScript frameworks
- HX-post, HX-swap-outer-html attributes
- Works with any backend language
- Solves different problem than JavaScript frameworks
- Flash: S-tier (joke ranking)
- All best games made in Flash
- Android support existed briefly
- Touchscreen friendly
- Historical significance
