AI summary by TwinMind

Jessica Kerr: Who makes judges? | TED

TED

12m 55s

Public Confidence in Judicial System

  • Australian judges not elected but wield immense power
  • System relies on public trust that judges "generally get it right"
  • Losing this belief risks unbalancing entire constitution
  • Blind faith in elites eroding fast
  • Judges increasingly vulnerable to "why" question about deserving power

Judicial Independence Framework

  • Judges must be seen as independent, working without fear or favor
  • Protection mechanisms:
    • High salaries that can never be cut
    • Cannot be fired for what they say/do (unless corrupt or mad)
  • In exchange: judges agree to be ultrarestrained in/out of court
  • "Veil comes down" when appointed - creates lonely lifestyle
  • Feeds perception that judges are different from general public

Current Merit-Based Appointment System

  • All judges theoretically appointed on merit
  • Confidential process relying heavily on senior judge advice
  • Chosen candidates are experienced lawyers, traditionally top barristers
  • All personally shoulder-tapped for position
  • Results "in general, pretty impressive"
  • But barristers historically "maler, paler and staler than other lawyers"
  • Argument: chosen judges remind existing judges of themselves
  • Diversity on bench becoming impossible to ignore

Fundamental Flaws in Selection Logic

  • Judges picked based on arguing cases in front of judges
  • Analogy: like giving anesthetist scalpel because they've worked with surgeons for 10 years
  • Underlying skill set may be same, but jobs fundamentally different
  • System has "basically privatized" judge-making process
  • Work done within private legal profession, if done at all

Absence of Judicial Training

  • No judge school for wannabe judges
  • Judicial appointment seen as badge of honor, not professional milestone
  • Judges are "just lawyers until day they take judicial oath"
  • From appointment day: "sink or swim" - can't be fired for incompetence
  • Speaker's experience: never ran criminal trial as lawyer, handed down 12-year prison sentences in first month (Seychelles magistrate's court)
  • Transition described as "baptism by fire" and "terrifying"

Evolving Judicial Expectations

  • Society's expectations of judges changing
  • Modern judges need nonlegal skills:
    • Management and leadership
    • Political and cultural savvy
    • Ability to handle relentless scrutiny
    • Handle social isolation
  • These skills not necessarily expected/valued in barristers
  • Diversity goals worsen the problem:
    • Less male, less pale judges not found in barristers chambers
    • People without court experience can't be expected to know judging intuitively
  • Result: no new judge has every piece of "merit puzzle"
  • Missing pieces vary hugely from judge to judge

Cultural Barriers to Reform

  • Judiciary scholars reluctant to discuss behind-the-scenes issues
  • Fear of being seen as interfering with judicial independence
  • Speaker argues this has "gone too far"
  • Independence depends on public confidence
  • Can't trust what can't be explained and justified
  • Legal elite have obvious interest in maintaining status quo
  • Uncomfortable for lawyers to criticize process barrister friends see as "natural progression" or "right"
  • Getting lawyers to talk openly about learning to judge is difficult
  • Admitting judicial ambitions considered "out of order"
  • Can aim to be barrister but can't be seen angling for appointment
  • Contrast with medicine profession "couldn't be more stark"
  • Incentives in law are "all backwards"

Proposed Solutions

Government Responsibility

  • Government must take more responsibility for own processes
  • Need to explain why one person picked over another

Ongoing Judicial Education

  • Judges do attend "judge school" now but only after appointment
  • Currently labeled as CPD (Continuing Professional Development)
  • Voluntary system because no one supposed to tell judge what to do
  • Speaker could theoretically "just say no"
  • CPD label avoids elephant in room: every modern lawyer needs help learning to be good judge
  • Amazing work starting in judicial education but "nowhere near enough"
  • Pre-appointment years matter most - government has taken "no responsibility at all"

Professional Culture Change

  • Need to get past stigma on wannabe judges
  • Profession itself must change
  • Need judicial career path thinking (formal or informal)
  • Actively create judicial merit
  • Support young lawyers (particularly diverse ones) to do things making them great judges, not just great lawyers
  • Especially when these things won't get them promoted as lawyers
  • Speaker's hindsight wishes: more experience in community justice, technology, management
  • Wished could have gone to judge school

Ultimate Goal

  • Better prepared lawyers = better inputs for judge choosers/managers
  • Better evidence that judges deserve public trust
  • Any person could find future in judge's hands any day
  • Need to look each other in eye and trust the system

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome