AI summary by TwinMind
Jessica Kerr: Who makes judges? | TED
TED
12m 55s
Public Confidence in Judicial System
- Australian judges not elected but wield immense power
- System relies on public trust that judges "generally get it right"
- Losing this belief risks unbalancing entire constitution
- Blind faith in elites eroding fast
- Judges increasingly vulnerable to "why" question about deserving power
Judicial Independence Framework
- Judges must be seen as independent, working without fear or favor
- Protection mechanisms:
- High salaries that can never be cut
- Cannot be fired for what they say/do (unless corrupt or mad)
- In exchange: judges agree to be ultrarestrained in/out of court
- "Veil comes down" when appointed - creates lonely lifestyle
- Feeds perception that judges are different from general public
Current Merit-Based Appointment System
- All judges theoretically appointed on merit
- Confidential process relying heavily on senior judge advice
- Chosen candidates are experienced lawyers, traditionally top barristers
- All personally shoulder-tapped for position
- Results "in general, pretty impressive"
- But barristers historically "maler, paler and staler than other lawyers"
- Argument: chosen judges remind existing judges of themselves
- Diversity on bench becoming impossible to ignore
Fundamental Flaws in Selection Logic
- Judges picked based on arguing cases in front of judges
- Analogy: like giving anesthetist scalpel because they've worked with surgeons for 10 years
- Underlying skill set may be same, but jobs fundamentally different
- System has "basically privatized" judge-making process
- Work done within private legal profession, if done at all
Absence of Judicial Training
- No judge school for wannabe judges
- Judicial appointment seen as badge of honor, not professional milestone
- Judges are "just lawyers until day they take judicial oath"
- From appointment day: "sink or swim" - can't be fired for incompetence
- Speaker's experience: never ran criminal trial as lawyer, handed down 12-year prison sentences in first month (Seychelles magistrate's court)
- Transition described as "baptism by fire" and "terrifying"
Evolving Judicial Expectations
- Society's expectations of judges changing
- Modern judges need nonlegal skills:
- Management and leadership
- Political and cultural savvy
- Ability to handle relentless scrutiny
- Handle social isolation
- These skills not necessarily expected/valued in barristers
- Diversity goals worsen the problem:
- Less male, less pale judges not found in barristers chambers
- People without court experience can't be expected to know judging intuitively
- Result: no new judge has every piece of "merit puzzle"
- Missing pieces vary hugely from judge to judge
Cultural Barriers to Reform
- Judiciary scholars reluctant to discuss behind-the-scenes issues
- Fear of being seen as interfering with judicial independence
- Speaker argues this has "gone too far"
- Independence depends on public confidence
- Can't trust what can't be explained and justified
- Legal elite have obvious interest in maintaining status quo
- Uncomfortable for lawyers to criticize process barrister friends see as "natural progression" or "right"
- Getting lawyers to talk openly about learning to judge is difficult
- Admitting judicial ambitions considered "out of order"
- Can aim to be barrister but can't be seen angling for appointment
- Contrast with medicine profession "couldn't be more stark"
- Incentives in law are "all backwards"
Proposed Solutions
Government Responsibility
- Government must take more responsibility for own processes
- Need to explain why one person picked over another
Ongoing Judicial Education
- Judges do attend "judge school" now but only after appointment
- Currently labeled as CPD (Continuing Professional Development)
- Voluntary system because no one supposed to tell judge what to do
- Speaker could theoretically "just say no"
- CPD label avoids elephant in room: every modern lawyer needs help learning to be good judge
- Amazing work starting in judicial education but "nowhere near enough"
- Pre-appointment years matter most - government has taken "no responsibility at all"
Professional Culture Change
- Need to get past stigma on wannabe judges
- Profession itself must change
- Need judicial career path thinking (formal or informal)
- Actively create judicial merit
- Support young lawyers (particularly diverse ones) to do things making them great judges, not just great lawyers
- Especially when these things won't get them promoted as lawyers
- Speaker's hindsight wishes: more experience in community justice, technology, management
- Wished could have gone to judge school
Ultimate Goal
- Better prepared lawyers = better inputs for judge choosers/managers
- Better evidence that judges deserve public trust
- Any person could find future in judge's hands any day
- Need to look each other in eye and trust the system
