AI summary by TwinMind
Jonathan Sacks | Morality: Restoring the Common Good in Divided Times | Talks at Google
Talks at Google
52m 29s
Introduction and Background
- Host: Tim Chatwin interviewing Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks
- Sacks served as Chief Rabbi of UK and United Hebrew Congregations of Commonwealth 1991-2013
- Author of over 30 books, held professorships at universities in Britain, US, and Israel
- Discussion focused on Sacks' book "Morality"
Genesis of the Book - Cultural Climate Change
- Sacks felt "things were coming apart" in Britain and America
- Observed loss of ability to "talk across differences" - essence of intellectual civilization
- Identified multiple symptoms: post-truth, fake news, identity politics, unequal economics, loneliness, isolation, teenage depression
- Central thesis: All symptoms of "cultural climate change" - loss of common moral core to society
- Society reduced to two competitions: market (wealth) and state (power)
- Competition fine only if counterbalanced by arena of cooperation
- Progressive wearing away of cooperative arena making society more conflictual
Optimism vs. Pessimism - Prophecy vs. Prediction
- Sacks referenced George Steiner's distinction: prediction succeeds if comes true, prophecy fails if comes true
- Prophetic books warn of dangers then offer hope through solutions
- Book follows pattern: three-quarters analysis of problems, final quarter offers hope
- Good things are contagious like bad things - every altruistic act creates "contagion of good"
- Examples: 750,000 people volunteered for NHS in Britain within two days
The I-We Construct
- Darwin and evolutionary psychologists understand need for both competition and cooperation
- Social animals need altruism - putting group interests above private interests
- "We consciousness" written into human brain, even in fruit bats (food sharing behavior)
- Contemporary culture discourages "we" thinking
- Lockdown provided extreme "I" experience - isolation and solitary confinement effects
- John McCain: solitary confinement worse than torture during Vietnam War imprisonment
Post-Lockdown Community Building
- Plan to identify isolated community members and weave them back into community fabric
- "Very big act of redemption we have to do over the next few years"
- National service opportunity: generation struggling for jobs + need for 300,000 testing/tracking workers
- Could avoid frustration/despair among young people while inducting them into working for common good
- Young people robbed of rites of passage (A-level results, graduation celebrations)
Contracts vs. Covenants
- Covenant was key word leading to free societies of the West
- Started with Calvinists: Geneva, Holland, Scotland, then 1620s England and America
- John Milton steeped in Hebrew Bible, Mayflower Compact 1620, John Winthrop's Arbela speech 1630
- Covenant spoke about moral basis of free society
- England became less covenantal after 1688 settlement
- America remained explicitly/implicitly covenantal - Exodus story with England as Egypt, George III as Pharaoh
- American covenant: "all men are created equal" with rights to "life, liberty, pursuit of happiness"
- Key American covenant words: "We the People" (vs. Britain's "Her Majesty's loyal subjects")
- America losing covenantal foundation, causing sadness
Democracy and Economic Inequality
- Ray Dalio (richest hedge fund owner) called US income inequality "existential threat" (January 2019)
- Ragaram Rajan (former World Bank economic adviser) and Sir Ronald Cohen (Britain's first venture capitalist) saying current capitalism won't work
- Many successful business people feel system very skewed
- Won't need to "force people to be free" - wise economists/business people recognizing unsustainability
Listening and Disagreement
- Prize goes to best listeners in non-listening age
- Technology creating opportunities for genuine searching conversations
- Sacks held public conversations with atheists: Richard Dawkins, Stephen Pinker, late Christopher Hitchens
- People have hunger for conversation - hasn't diminished
- Learn most from people most different from us
- Sacks' doctoral supervisor: atheist Bernard Williams, taught him more than almost anyone
- Quotes Nietzsche more than anyone else in "Morality" despite Nietzsche being hostile to everything Sacks stands for
Technology and Information Revolutions
- Most profound civilization changes occur with information technology revolutions
- First: writing invention in Mesopotamia 4,500 years ago - birth of civilization
- Second: alphabet invention (22 characters from thousands of symbols) - universal access to knowledge, raised human dignity
- Codex (book with pages) led to Christianity (four gospels wouldn't exist with scrolls)
- Printing led to Reformation
- National newspapers led to nationalism
- Radio gave power to prominent leaders (Roosevelt, Churchill, Hitler)
- Current revolution: Google democratizing access to information - culmination of 4,500 years of development
- Google Classroom allowed schools to function during pandemic
- Electronic communication taking place alongside face-to-face communication
- Spiritual transformation will follow (all previous revolutions had spiritual consequences)
Black Lives Matter Movement
- Sacks' ideals formed by Martin Luther King Jr. and Robert F. Kennedy friendship
- Both assassinated within three months of each other in 1968
- King challenged white America to live up to white America's ideals
- Current approach supplanted by anger - requires therapeutic response
- Must "lean into" anger, listen and show listening, otherwise violence results
- Violence won't help Black Lives Matter
- Admits not understanding depths of issue, would be "flip" to offer practical solutions
Anti-Semitism
- Anti-Semitism is dependent variable, not independent variable
- Has nothing to do with Jews - about political turbulence
- Follows political turbulence "as night follows day"
- When people feel loss (economic, jobs, uncertainty), groups ask either:
- "What did we do wrong?" OR
- "Who did this to us?"
- If second question asked, someone gets blamed - Jews have been candidate of choice for 1,000 years
- Masses into conspiracy theories means "we're in trouble"
Individual Action and Volunteering
- Advice: volunteer
- Health benefits of volunteering: psychological improvement, physical improvement, strengthened immune system
- Called "helper's high"
- Volunteering helps: people being helped, society as whole, volunteers themselves
Social Media and Division
- Social media are "disaster" for moral discourse
- Confirmation bias: believe views that agree with us
- Broadcasting (BBC) vs. narrowcasting (social media)
- Broadcasting reaches diverse audiences; narrowcasting reaches similar-minded people
- Cass Sunstein research: associating with same-view people makes everyone more extreme
- Social media increasing divisiveness through narrowcasting phenomenon
- Advice: "always read the opposition"
Education and Argument
- Jewish education model: all canonical texts are "anthologies of arguments"
- "In Judaism to think is to argue"
- Students replay great arguments from 2,000 years ago, taking different positions
- Develops intellectual flexibility needed in world full of sharply held, different beliefs
- Entering different positions doesn't compromise ability to reach independent conclusions
Political Leadership
- Politics in danger of becoming personality cult
- Democracy not about following charismatic leader but listening to will of people
- Need to bring back concept of political leadership as service
- Leader serves people, not vice versa
- Recent memory of leaders who knew they were servants of people, serving interests larger than their own
Community Creativity During Pandemic
- Flourishing creativity during lockdown: families recording YouTube videos, sketches
- Jewish communities created virtual engagements: synagogue magazines through Zoom, profiling members
- Creative use of Zoom for services and adult education
- Sacks teaching audiences worldwide non-stop since lockdown
- However, 10 people on Zoom don't constitute quorum for Jewish prayer - must be physically present
- Electronic communication never real substitute for personal psychology and "touch of two selves"
