AI summary by TwinMind

Jonathan Sacks | Morality: Restoring the Common Good in Divided Times | Talks at Google

Talks at Google

52m 29s

Introduction and Background

  • Host: Tim Chatwin interviewing Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks
  • Sacks served as Chief Rabbi of UK and United Hebrew Congregations of Commonwealth 1991-2013
  • Author of over 30 books, held professorships at universities in Britain, US, and Israel
  • Discussion focused on Sacks' book "Morality"

Genesis of the Book - Cultural Climate Change

  • Sacks felt "things were coming apart" in Britain and America
  • Observed loss of ability to "talk across differences" - essence of intellectual civilization
  • Identified multiple symptoms: post-truth, fake news, identity politics, unequal economics, loneliness, isolation, teenage depression
  • Central thesis: All symptoms of "cultural climate change" - loss of common moral core to society
  • Society reduced to two competitions: market (wealth) and state (power)
  • Competition fine only if counterbalanced by arena of cooperation
  • Progressive wearing away of cooperative arena making society more conflictual

Optimism vs. Pessimism - Prophecy vs. Prediction

  • Sacks referenced George Steiner's distinction: prediction succeeds if comes true, prophecy fails if comes true
  • Prophetic books warn of dangers then offer hope through solutions
  • Book follows pattern: three-quarters analysis of problems, final quarter offers hope
  • Good things are contagious like bad things - every altruistic act creates "contagion of good"
  • Examples: 750,000 people volunteered for NHS in Britain within two days

The I-We Construct

  • Darwin and evolutionary psychologists understand need for both competition and cooperation
  • Social animals need altruism - putting group interests above private interests
  • "We consciousness" written into human brain, even in fruit bats (food sharing behavior)
  • Contemporary culture discourages "we" thinking
  • Lockdown provided extreme "I" experience - isolation and solitary confinement effects
  • John McCain: solitary confinement worse than torture during Vietnam War imprisonment

Post-Lockdown Community Building

  • Plan to identify isolated community members and weave them back into community fabric
  • "Very big act of redemption we have to do over the next few years"
  • National service opportunity: generation struggling for jobs + need for 300,000 testing/tracking workers
  • Could avoid frustration/despair among young people while inducting them into working for common good
  • Young people robbed of rites of passage (A-level results, graduation celebrations)

Contracts vs. Covenants

  • Covenant was key word leading to free societies of the West
  • Started with Calvinists: Geneva, Holland, Scotland, then 1620s England and America
  • John Milton steeped in Hebrew Bible, Mayflower Compact 1620, John Winthrop's Arbela speech 1630
  • Covenant spoke about moral basis of free society
  • England became less covenantal after 1688 settlement
  • America remained explicitly/implicitly covenantal - Exodus story with England as Egypt, George III as Pharaoh
  • American covenant: "all men are created equal" with rights to "life, liberty, pursuit of happiness"
  • Key American covenant words: "We the People" (vs. Britain's "Her Majesty's loyal subjects")
  • America losing covenantal foundation, causing sadness

Democracy and Economic Inequality

  • Ray Dalio (richest hedge fund owner) called US income inequality "existential threat" (January 2019)
  • Ragaram Rajan (former World Bank economic adviser) and Sir Ronald Cohen (Britain's first venture capitalist) saying current capitalism won't work
  • Many successful business people feel system very skewed
  • Won't need to "force people to be free" - wise economists/business people recognizing unsustainability

Listening and Disagreement

  • Prize goes to best listeners in non-listening age
  • Technology creating opportunities for genuine searching conversations
  • Sacks held public conversations with atheists: Richard Dawkins, Stephen Pinker, late Christopher Hitchens
  • People have hunger for conversation - hasn't diminished
  • Learn most from people most different from us
  • Sacks' doctoral supervisor: atheist Bernard Williams, taught him more than almost anyone
  • Quotes Nietzsche more than anyone else in "Morality" despite Nietzsche being hostile to everything Sacks stands for

Technology and Information Revolutions

  • Most profound civilization changes occur with information technology revolutions
  • First: writing invention in Mesopotamia 4,500 years ago - birth of civilization
  • Second: alphabet invention (22 characters from thousands of symbols) - universal access to knowledge, raised human dignity
  • Codex (book with pages) led to Christianity (four gospels wouldn't exist with scrolls)
  • Printing led to Reformation
  • National newspapers led to nationalism
  • Radio gave power to prominent leaders (Roosevelt, Churchill, Hitler)
  • Current revolution: Google democratizing access to information - culmination of 4,500 years of development
  • Google Classroom allowed schools to function during pandemic
  • Electronic communication taking place alongside face-to-face communication
  • Spiritual transformation will follow (all previous revolutions had spiritual consequences)

Black Lives Matter Movement

  • Sacks' ideals formed by Martin Luther King Jr. and Robert F. Kennedy friendship
  • Both assassinated within three months of each other in 1968
  • King challenged white America to live up to white America's ideals
  • Current approach supplanted by anger - requires therapeutic response
  • Must "lean into" anger, listen and show listening, otherwise violence results
  • Violence won't help Black Lives Matter
  • Admits not understanding depths of issue, would be "flip" to offer practical solutions

Anti-Semitism

  • Anti-Semitism is dependent variable, not independent variable
  • Has nothing to do with Jews - about political turbulence
  • Follows political turbulence "as night follows day"
  • When people feel loss (economic, jobs, uncertainty), groups ask either:
    • "What did we do wrong?" OR
    • "Who did this to us?"
  • If second question asked, someone gets blamed - Jews have been candidate of choice for 1,000 years
  • Masses into conspiracy theories means "we're in trouble"

Individual Action and Volunteering

  • Advice: volunteer
  • Health benefits of volunteering: psychological improvement, physical improvement, strengthened immune system
  • Called "helper's high"
  • Volunteering helps: people being helped, society as whole, volunteers themselves

Social Media and Division

  • Social media are "disaster" for moral discourse
  • Confirmation bias: believe views that agree with us
  • Broadcasting (BBC) vs. narrowcasting (social media)
  • Broadcasting reaches diverse audiences; narrowcasting reaches similar-minded people
  • Cass Sunstein research: associating with same-view people makes everyone more extreme
  • Social media increasing divisiveness through narrowcasting phenomenon
  • Advice: "always read the opposition"

Education and Argument

  • Jewish education model: all canonical texts are "anthologies of arguments"
  • "In Judaism to think is to argue"
  • Students replay great arguments from 2,000 years ago, taking different positions
  • Develops intellectual flexibility needed in world full of sharply held, different beliefs
  • Entering different positions doesn't compromise ability to reach independent conclusions

Political Leadership

  • Politics in danger of becoming personality cult
  • Democracy not about following charismatic leader but listening to will of people
  • Need to bring back concept of political leadership as service
  • Leader serves people, not vice versa
  • Recent memory of leaders who knew they were servants of people, serving interests larger than their own

Community Creativity During Pandemic

  • Flourishing creativity during lockdown: families recording YouTube videos, sketches
  • Jewish communities created virtual engagements: synagogue magazines through Zoom, profiling members
  • Creative use of Zoom for services and adult education
  • Sacks teaching audiences worldwide non-stop since lockdown
  • However, 10 people on Zoom don't constitute quorum for Jewish prayer - must be physically present
  • Electronic communication never real substitute for personal psychology and "touch of two selves"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome