AI summary by TwinMind

Judson Brewer | Unwinding Anxiety | Talks at Google

Talks at Google

1h 0m 44s

Introduction and Background

  • Google health and well-being team hosts Dr. Judd Brewer discussing "Unwinding Anxiety: New Science Shows How to Break the Cycles of Worry and Fear to Heal Your Mind"
  • Dr. Brewer: NY Times bestselling author, psychiatrist, internationally known mindfulness expert
  • Director of research and Innovation at Brown University's Mindfulness Center
  • Associate professor at Brown's School of Public Health and Psychiatry
  • Developed apps: Unwinding Anxiety, Eat Right Now, Craving to Quit
  • Background: MD/PhD program, started meditating to understand his mind, became psychiatrist
  • Specialized in addiction treatment due to lack of effective treatments and high stigmatization
  • Standard addiction treatment based on willpower - not effective
  • Anxiety medication success rate: 1 in 5 patients (number needed to treat = 5.2)
  • Discovered anxiety as habit (research from 1980s by Tom Borkovec)
  • Smoking program: 5x quit rates of gold standard treatment
  • Eating program: 40% reduction in craving-related eating

Fear vs Planning vs Anxiety

  • Fear: helpful survival mechanism for present danger
  • Planning: helpful for future preparation
  • Anxiety: unhelpful combination of fear + planning = fear of future
  • Brain seeks information when uncertain, but can't get future information
  • Creates endless worry loops that "seize up" mental processing
  • No evidence anxiety helps performance - inverse relationship exists
  • Yerkes-Dodson curve myth: based on 1907 Japanese dancing mice study about arousal, not anxiety
  • Flow state (optimal performance) = opposite of anxiety
  • Default mode network activated during worry and mind-wandering
  • Expert meditators show quieted default mode network

Three Gears Framework

First Gear: Mapping Habit Loops

  • Habit loop: evolutionarily conserved learning mechanism
  • Three components: trigger → behavior → reward/result
  • Sea slugs have same learning mechanism (Eric Kandel Nobel Prize research)
  • Example: food foraging creates context-dependent memory
  • Clinical mapping process: draw trigger-behavior-reward on paper
  • Patient "Dave": panic disorder mapped as thought of car wreck → avoid highway → no panic attack
  • Free resource: mapmyhabit.com for habit mapping
  • Perseverative thinking: single top anxiety issue
  • Forward-looking (anxiety) vs backward-looking (depression) perseverative thinking
  • Worry provides false sense of control as reward
  • Occasionally predicts outcomes, reinforcing the habit
  • Research shows worrying makes people feel in control but doesn't actually provide control

Second Gear: Updating Brain's Reward Value

  • Orbital frontal cortex: behind eyes, processes reward hierarchies
  • Brain creates algorithms for decision-making efficiency
  • Example: chocolate preference hierarchy (milk → dark → 72% → with cayenne/sea salt)
  • Only way to change behavior: change reward value
  • Willpower myth: prefrontal cortex is youngest, weakest brain part
  • Goes offline during stress (when most needed)
  • Solution: pay attention to direct experience during behavior
  • Smoking example: patient smoking 40 years (293,000 reinforcements) realized "cigarettes taste like crap"
  • Negative prediction error: brain updates when experience below expectations
  • Overeating study: 10-15 times to update reward value and shift behavior
  • Brain's tremendous plasticity for survival adaptation
  • Key ingredient: awareness, not intellectual knowledge

Third Gear: Bigger Better Offer

  • Substitution strategies often fail (e.g., cocaine → exercise)
  • Can lead to dual addictions if original loop not dismantled
  • Need intrinsically rewarding behaviors that don't habituate
  • Two main flavors: curiosity and kindness

Curiosity as Superpower

  • Always available, intrinsically rewarding
  • Can't get "too curious"
  • Quotes: "Curiosity will conquer fear even more than bravery will"
  • "Curiosity will conquer boredom, there is no cure for curiosity"
  • Twofer benefit: provides awareness AND feels better than old behaviors
  • Ancient Buddhist concepts align with awareness practices

Kindness as Superpower

  • Self-judgment habit loops very common
  • Western culture promotes judgment (social media amplifies)
  • Trigger: thought → behavior: self-judgment ("should" statements) → reward: familiar pattern
  • Brain prefers kindness to self-judgment (no-brainer comparison)
  • Can recall receiving kindness if can't remember giving it to self
  • Critical distinction: self-care vs self-indulgence
  • Self-care: asking "what do I need?" vs "what do I want?"
  • Example: loneliness needs connection, not ice cream

Anxiety-Specific Applications

  • Wife's anxiety description: "low-grade feeling with no object, attaches to any situation/thought, mind looking for something to be anxious about"
  • "Why" habit loops: patients seek root causes to "fix" anxiety forever
  • Problem: can't change past, only present moment
  • Solution: shift from "why" to "what" - present moment experience
  • Trigger is least important part of habit loop
  • Reward-based learning (not trigger-based learning) drives behavior
  • Focus on behavior and result for prediction errors

Practical Advice for Anxiety Sufferers

  • You're not alone - very common experience
  • Pandemic increased anxiety levels, still elevated
  • Start with mapping habit loops = "flipping light switch" in dark room
  • Provides orientation and empowerment
  • Ask "what am I getting from this?"
  • Find bigger better offer through curiosity and kindness

Audience Q&A Insights

Curiosity Challenges

  • Two types: deprivation curiosity (destination-focused) vs interest curiosity (journey-focused)
  • If can't find curiosity, ask "what's it feel like not to be curious?"
  • Stress tool: locate anxiety in body (right/left, front/back) to awaken curiosity
  • Tone shift: "oh no" vs "oh" (interest curiosity marker)
  • Not anxiety eraser - changes relationship to experience
  • Welcoming vs resisting present moment experience

Mindfulness Adverse Effects

  • Willoughby Britton's research on intensive practitioners
  • Trauma history may need extra support
  • Historical teacher support vs modern consumer approach
  • Expect some initial anxiety increase when starting to notice avoided feelings
  • "Muddy waters" analogy: stirring up settles downstream with emotional regulation skills

ADHD and Anxiety Correlation

  • Both have restless, driven quality
  • ADHD: "oh this, oh this, oh this"
  • Anxiety: "oh no, oh no, oh no"
  • Shared physiologic restlessness experience

Distress Tolerance

  • Critical for anxiety and everyday life
  • Phones as "weapons of mass distraction"
  • Mindfulness as emotion regulation/distress tolerance strategy
  • "Oh no" (resistance) vs "oh" (opening) response
  • Rumi's "Guest House" poem: welcome negative emotions as teachers
  • Anxiety as wisdom teacher for handling strong emotions

Trauma and Rumination

  • Honor past coping mechanisms that helped survival
  • Recognize when old "shoes" no longer fit
  • Distinguish between honoring past and being helped in present
  • Example: childhood worry as survival mechanism for 50 years
  • Present moment focus: "Is this helping me now?"
  • "What do I need?" vs staying stuck in past patterns
  • Importance of good support systems for trauma work

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome