AI summary by TwinMind
Kissing Cousins: A History of Marrying Family | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
49m 37s
Introduction and Definitions
- Josh and Chuck discuss topic inspired by frantic email with misspellings
- Lydia helped with research, did outstanding job
- Consanguineous marriage: second cousin or closer relationships
- Incest specifically defined as abusive/dominant sexual relations within nuclear family (siblings, parents, children)
- General taboo exists almost universally against nuclear family sexual relations
Animal Behavior and Evolutionary Theories
- Animals avoid interbreeding based on inbreeding depression concerns
- Two main theories for human taboos:
- Biological imperative theory: cultural taboos are human version of innate sexual aversion
- Observational theory (William Durham): humans observed problems with inbreeding, created laws accordingly
Westermarck Effect
- Late 19th century Finnish sociologist Edvard Westermarck's hypothesis
- Children raised together won't be sexually attracted as adults
- Applies to blood relatives and non-relatives raised together
- Only effective if cohabitation occurred before age 6
- Studies generally support this effect
- Genetic Sexual Attraction: opposite phenomenon when blood relatives meet as adults
- Cumbria City Council issues pamphlets warning adoptees about this
- Powerful connection mistranslated as sexual attraction
Historical and Religious Context
- Religious texts show deity incest (Zeus/Hera siblings)
- Adam and Eve population explanation: twin daughters born to populate Earth
- Historians agree incest mainly among elites, not common people
- Elite families used incest to consolidate power, stay above taboos
- Roman Egyptian period (1st-3rd century CE): census shows common people in sibling marriages
- Zoroastrian Persia (5th century BCE - 11th century CE): "ex-widota" ritual sex for spiritual power
Cousin Marriage Through History
- 2021 DNA study: only 3% of ancient humans (45,000 years back) had cousin marriages
- Increased after agriculture/settled societies due to genetic diversity
- Robin Fox (Rutgers): estimated 80% of historical marriages were second cousin or closer
- Pre-transportation era: courting within 5-mile radius increased cousin encounters
Cultural Variations
China
- First cousin marriage generally acceptable except male sibling children (same family name)
- 1980s PRC marriage law banned first cousin marriage for "population quality"
- Coincided with one-child policy
Catholic Church Impact (506 CE)
- Banned marriage closer than third cousin
- Joseph Heinrich's hypothesis: led to modern Western world
- Weakened family bonds, encouraged individualism and trust beyond kin networks
- Enabled larger societies, free market competition
- Wedding objection tradition possibly evolved from "are these two related?" question
Royal and Elite Examples
Habsburg Dynasty
- Extensive inbreeding caused "Habsburg jaw" (severe underbite)
- Charles II of Spain couldn't chew food properly
- 18% infant mortality rate (high even for the time)
- Power consolidation motivation
Economic Dynasties
- DuPont family: Pierre Samuel DuPont (1810) preferred cousin marriages for "honesty of soul and purity of blood"
- Rothschild banking family: similar practices
- Money/power consolidation rather than genetic concerns
American Legal Development
- 1858: Kansas first state to ban cousin marriage
- 1875: cultural shift began
- Mid-1920s: most states had laws
- Western states led due to writing new laws from scratch
- Health and safety approach rather than moral regulation
- America has outlier preoccupation with cousin marriage compared to world
Current American Laws
- 25 states ban first cousin marriage
- 7 states have restrictions
- Arizona allows if both 65+ or can't reproduce
- Consanguineous defined as second cousins or closer
Global Perspective
- 10% of global population practices second cousin or closer marriage
- Middle Eastern provinces: up to 80%
- 1995 Pakistan study reasons for cousin marriage:
- More compatible with family than strangers
- Kinder in-laws
- Less focus on physical appearance
- Suspicion of outsiders wanting to marry (family rejection implications)
Health Risks Reality
- Genetic disorders rare even with cousin marriage
- Risk comes from shared recessive genes, not automatic punishment
- Doubling small risk still results in small absolute risk
- Can happen to unrelated people too
- University of Natural Sciences Lahore study:
- Population level: cousin marriage beneficial long-term (genetic fitness)
- Individual level: not preferable
- Recommendation: continue outlawing until gene therapy available
Famous Examples
- Edgar Allan Poe (1835): married 13-year-old first cousin Virginia Eliza Clem at age 27
- Jesse James (1874): married first cousin
- H.G. Wells (1891): cousin marriage
- Einstein (1919): married cousin Elsa (second marriage for both)
Cultural Taboos and Practices
Muslim Milk Kinship
- Breastfeeding unrelated child 3-5 times creates "mahram" status
- Cannot marry that person
- Workaround for hijab requirements
Levirate Marriage
- Widow must marry deceased husband's brother
- Found in multiple cultures
- Old Testament: refusal results in sandal removal, spitting, "family of the unsandled" designation
- Chukchi (Eastern Siberia): includes wife swapping backup system for women whose husbands lack brothers
Listener Mail
- Frank's correction about adoption language
- "Gave up for adoption" has negative connotation
- Preferred: "made an adoption plan for the baby"
- Chicago adoption agency campaign: "Give Up Giving Up"
