AI summary by TwinMind

Lec 16: Input Markets II—Labor and Capital

MIT OpenCourseWare

49m 47s

Course Context & Factor Markets Introduction

  • Second half of course examining elements underlying supply/demand model from first half
  • Focus on where prices of firm inputs (W and R) originate
  • Factor markets have flipped roles: firms are demanders, people are suppliers

Labor Market Equilibrium

  • Demand curve comes from firms' marginal product of labor
  • Example: demand curve = 70 - W (higher wages → fewer workers demanded)
  • Supply curve shape indeterminate due to income effects offsetting substitution effects when leisure is normal good
  • Course assumption: upward sloping labor supply curves (substitution effects dominate)
  • Example: labor supply = W - 10
  • Equilibrium: setting demand = supply yields 30 units labor at wage = 40

Minimum Wage Analysis - Standard Model

  • Government sets wage floor below which employers cannot pay
  • Example: minimum wage set at 50 (above equilibrium wage of 40)
  • Results in new market outcome at point where firms demand fewer workers
  • Creates excess supply of labor = unemployment
  • Workers want more work at higher wage but no jobs available
  • Welfare effects:
    • Transfers area B from firms to workers
    • Creates deadweight loss of C + E
    • Standard trade-off: worker benefits vs. efficiency loss

Research Findings on Minimum Wage

  • Starting ~30 years ago: research found minimum wages didn't cause unemployment
  • Some studies suggest minimum wage increases employment
  • Little evidence of employment reduction
  • Striking contradiction to standard theory

Alternative Explanation: Non-Competitive Labor Markets

  • Just as goods markets can be non-competitive, so can labor markets
  • Competitive labor market requirements:
    • Perfect information
    • No transaction costs
    • All jobs identical
  • These conditions often not met in reality
  • Information problems: wages not always posted, unknown compensation at other firms
  • Transaction costs interfere with competitive outcomes

Monopsony Model

  • Extreme case: old mining towns with single employer
  • Monopsony = only one firm hires workers (vs. monopoly = only one firm sells)
  • Assumption: monopsonies can't wage discriminate (more reasonable than price discrimination)
  • Marginal cost of hiring ≠ wage due to "poisoning effect"
  • Marginal expenditure = W + (dW/dL) × L
  • Must raise wages for all workers to attract one more worker

Monopsony Firm Decision-Making

  • Marginal benefit = marginal revenue product of labor (70 - L)
  • Marginal cost = marginal expenditure curve (2L + 10)
  • Firm hires where marginal cost = marginal benefit
  • Results: 20 workers at wage of 30 (vs. competitive 30 workers at 40)
  • Hiring fewer workers at lower wage than competitive equilibrium

Real-World Monopsony Power Examples

  • Professor example: MIT has monopsony power due to:
    • Information limitations about other universities' wages
    • Transaction costs of moving (packing, family considerations)
    • Job-specific preferences (office view, student quality, established lectures)
  • Transaction costs create monopsony power in most job changes
  • Monopsony now considered better description of most labor markets than perfect competition

Minimum Wage in Monopsony Markets

  • Creates scope for welfare-improving regulation
  • Minimum wage set at competitive level can eliminate poisoning effect
  • Results in win-win: transfers surplus to workers AND raises employment
  • Minimum wage below monopsony wage has no effect
  • Optimal range: between monopsony wage and competitive wage
  • Above optimal range: causes unemployment like standard model

Current Minimum Wage Evidence

  • Consensus for US minimum wages ($8-12/hour): generally beneficial
  • Benefits workers without reducing employment
  • Evidence on $15/hour wages more mixed, needs more study
  • Some level definitionally high enough to cause unemployment
  • Standard model shows trade-off, not necessarily bad policy

Capital Markets Introduction

  • Capital less tangible than labor (machines, buildings vs. hours of work)
  • Capital defined as diversion of current consumption toward future consumption
  • Historical example: farmers saving seeds for next year's crop
  • Modern firms get capital through capital markets, not self-financing

Capital Market Structure

  • Demand for capital: firms' marginal revenue product of capital
  • Supply of capital: household savings
  • Interest rate (I) = rate firms pay savers to obtain their money
  • Three ways people transfer money to firms:
    1. Bank deposits (indirect through financial intermediary)
    2. Corporate bonds (direct loans to firms)
    3. Stocks (ownership shares, returns through appreciation/dividends)

Intertemporal Choice Model

  • Individual choice between consumption in period 1 vs. period 2
  • Trade-off driven by human impatience vs. need for money in both periods
  • Example: $80,000 income in period 1, zero in period 2, 10% interest rate
  • Budget constraint options: consume all in period 1 or save all for $88,000 in period 2
  • Price of period 1 consumption = -(1 + I) in terms of period 2 consumption
  • Opportunity cost: every dollar consumed in period 1 gives up (1 + I) dollars in period 2

Savings as Residual

  • Savings not modeled as good (like Scrooge McDuck swimming in money)
  • Savings = necessary tool to transfer consumption between periods
  • Model consumption directly, derive savings as residual
  • Similar to modeling leisure to get work as residual

Interest Rate Effects on Savings

  • Higher interest rates have conflicting effects:
    • Substitution effect: price of period 1 consumption increases → consume less in period 1
    • Income effect: effectively richer from higher returns → want more of everything including period 1 consumption
  • Net effect ambiguous (like labor supply)
  • Intuitive example: saving for $200 bike
    • 10% rate: save $180 this year
    • 20% rate: save $160 this year
    • Higher rate → less savings needed → downward sloping supply curve possible

Capital Supply Curve Uncertainty

  • Unlike labor supply (known to slope up/nearly vertical), capital supply curve shape unknown
  • Real empirical weakness in economics
  • Course assumption: substitution effects dominate → upward sloping capital supply curves
  • Evidence insufficient to determine actual shape

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome