AI summary by TwinMind
Lec 17: Making Choices over Time
MIT OpenCourseWare
49m 21s
Present Value Concepts
- Core principle: dollar in future worth less than dollar today due to opportunity cost of earning interest
- Cannot simply add money from different time periods - like adding pounds of gold, apples, butter
- Present value formula: Future value / (1 + interest rate)^T where T = periods in future
- Example: $100 next year at 10% interest rate requires $90.90 investment today
- Perpetuity shortcut: Present value of payment F forever = F/I
Present Value Calculations and Examples
- Loan example: $30 loan repaid as $10/year for 3 years at 10% interest
- Present value = $10/1.1 + $10/1.1² + $10/1.1³ = $24.87
- Not equivalent to $30 today due to time value of money
- General formula for payment stream: F × [1/(1+I) + 1/(1+I)² + ... + 1/(1+I)^T]
Compound Interest and Retirement Savings
- Beauty of compounding: earn interest on interest, becomes larger component over time
- Retirement example comparing two savings plans (age 22-70, 7% interest):
- Plan 1: Save $3,000/year ages 22-37, then nothing → $773,000 at retirement
- Plan 2: Save nothing ages 22-37, then $3,000/year ages 37-70 → ~$386,000 at retirement
- Early saving advantage due to compounding acceleration effect
- 401(k) benefits: tax deferral + employer matching + compounding returns
Real-World Application: Bobby Bonilla Case
- 1999: Mets offered $6 million buyout
- Bonilla deferred payment at 8% interest from 1999, collected 2011-2035
- $6 million became $30 million through deferral
- Receives $1 million/year until age 72 ("Bobby Bonilla Day")
Inflation and Real Interest Rates
- Consumer Price Index (CPI): measures cost of fixed basket of goods over time
- Normalized to 100 in 1982, shows price changes relative to base year
- Real interest rate = nominal interest rate - inflation rate (π)
- What matters for purchasing power is real interest rate, not nominal
- Innovation problem: CPI overstates inflation by missing quality improvements
- Example: laptops cheaper today but vastly more powerful than 1990
Capital Markets and Federal Reserve Policy
- Supply of capital: people's savings (increases with higher interest rates)
- Demand for capital: firm investment (decreases with higher interest rates)
- Higher interest rates cool economy by reducing both consumption and investment
- Fed uses interest rate as primary tool to manage economic activity
Intertemporal Choice Applications
- Professional athlete contracts: compare present values, not nominal totals
- Contract A: $1 million today vs Contract B: $500k today + $1.5 million in 10 years
- At 7% interest rate: choose B ($1.3 million present value)
- At 14% interest rate: choose A ($900k present value for B)
- Max Scherzer example: $210 million over 14 years ≈ $166 million present value
- Lottery winnings: advertised amounts significantly overstate present value
Firm Investment Decisions
- Net Present Value (NPV) rule: invest if NPV > 0
- NPV formula: Σ(Rt - Ct)/(1+r)^t across all periods
- Typical investment: negative cash flow early years, positive later
- Higher interest rates reduce investment attractiveness due to opportunity cost
- Example: $100 cost year 1, $150 revenue year 2 → NPV = $36.36 at 10% interest
Personal Investment Decisions
- House insulation example: $4,000 cost, $500/year savings forever
- NPV = -$4,000 + $500/r (using perpetuity formula)
- Investment worthwhile if interest rate < 12.5%
- All decisions with short-run costs/long-run benefits require NPV analysis
- Includes smoking decisions: short-term benefits vs long-term health costs
Human Capital Investment: College Decision
- College as investment in human capital/productivity
- Costs: tuition payments + opportunity cost of foregone earnings (ages 18-22)
- Benefits: higher lifetime earnings post-graduation (ages 22-70)
- NPV analysis shows college worthwhile at interest rates up to ~8%
- Above 8% interest rate: financially better to skip college
- Government subsidized student loans lower effective interest rate to encourage college attendance
