AI summary by TwinMind

Lec 17: Making Choices over Time

MIT OpenCourseWare

49m 21s

Present Value Concepts

  • Core principle: dollar in future worth less than dollar today due to opportunity cost of earning interest
  • Cannot simply add money from different time periods - like adding pounds of gold, apples, butter
  • Present value formula: Future value / (1 + interest rate)^T where T = periods in future
  • Example: $100 next year at 10% interest rate requires $90.90 investment today
  • Perpetuity shortcut: Present value of payment F forever = F/I

Present Value Calculations and Examples

  • Loan example: $30 loan repaid as $10/year for 3 years at 10% interest
    • Present value = $10/1.1 + $10/1.1² + $10/1.1³ = $24.87
    • Not equivalent to $30 today due to time value of money
  • General formula for payment stream: F × [1/(1+I) + 1/(1+I)² + ... + 1/(1+I)^T]

Compound Interest and Retirement Savings

  • Beauty of compounding: earn interest on interest, becomes larger component over time
  • Retirement example comparing two savings plans (age 22-70, 7% interest):
    • Plan 1: Save $3,000/year ages 22-37, then nothing → $773,000 at retirement
    • Plan 2: Save nothing ages 22-37, then $3,000/year ages 37-70 → ~$386,000 at retirement
  • Early saving advantage due to compounding acceleration effect
  • 401(k) benefits: tax deferral + employer matching + compounding returns

Real-World Application: Bobby Bonilla Case

  • 1999: Mets offered $6 million buyout
  • Bonilla deferred payment at 8% interest from 1999, collected 2011-2035
  • $6 million became $30 million through deferral
  • Receives $1 million/year until age 72 ("Bobby Bonilla Day")

Inflation and Real Interest Rates

  • Consumer Price Index (CPI): measures cost of fixed basket of goods over time
  • Normalized to 100 in 1982, shows price changes relative to base year
  • Real interest rate = nominal interest rate - inflation rate (π)
  • What matters for purchasing power is real interest rate, not nominal
  • Innovation problem: CPI overstates inflation by missing quality improvements
    • Example: laptops cheaper today but vastly more powerful than 1990

Capital Markets and Federal Reserve Policy

  • Supply of capital: people's savings (increases with higher interest rates)
  • Demand for capital: firm investment (decreases with higher interest rates)
  • Higher interest rates cool economy by reducing both consumption and investment
  • Fed uses interest rate as primary tool to manage economic activity

Intertemporal Choice Applications

  • Professional athlete contracts: compare present values, not nominal totals
  • Contract A: $1 million today vs Contract B: $500k today + $1.5 million in 10 years
  • At 7% interest rate: choose B ($1.3 million present value)
  • At 14% interest rate: choose A ($900k present value for B)
  • Max Scherzer example: $210 million over 14 years ≈ $166 million present value
  • Lottery winnings: advertised amounts significantly overstate present value

Firm Investment Decisions

  • Net Present Value (NPV) rule: invest if NPV > 0
  • NPV formula: Σ(Rt - Ct)/(1+r)^t across all periods
  • Typical investment: negative cash flow early years, positive later
  • Higher interest rates reduce investment attractiveness due to opportunity cost
  • Example: $100 cost year 1, $150 revenue year 2 → NPV = $36.36 at 10% interest

Personal Investment Decisions

  • House insulation example: $4,000 cost, $500/year savings forever
  • NPV = -$4,000 + $500/r (using perpetuity formula)
  • Investment worthwhile if interest rate < 12.5%
  • All decisions with short-run costs/long-run benefits require NPV analysis
  • Includes smoking decisions: short-term benefits vs long-term health costs

Human Capital Investment: College Decision

  • College as investment in human capital/productivity
  • Costs: tuition payments + opportunity cost of foregone earnings (ages 18-22)
  • Benefits: higher lifetime earnings post-graduation (ages 22-70)
  • NPV analysis shows college worthwhile at interest rates up to ~8%
  • Above 8% interest rate: financially better to skip college
  • Government subsidized student loans lower effective interest rate to encourage college attendance

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome