AI summary by TwinMind
Lec 2: Preferences and Utility Function
MIT OpenCourseWare
40m 48s
Course Introduction and Roadmap
- Building demand curves from consumer behavior foundations
- Previous lecture: created supply/demand curves without derivation
- Today: start with demand curve origins through consumer preferences
- Forget budget constraints initially - assume unlimited resources (won lottery scenario)
Three-Step Framework for Consumer Demand
- Step 1: Write underlying assumptions about consumer preferences (axioms)
- Step 2: Translate axioms into mathematical utility function
- Step 3: Next lecture - introduce budget constraint for choice optimization
Three Key Assumptions of Consumer Preferences
Assumption 1: Completeness
- Consumers have opinions on all possible choices
- When faced with two options: prefer one, prefer other, or indifferent
- Never respond "I don't know"
- Complete set of preferences over all choices
Assumption 2: Transitivity
- Standard mathematical principle from kindergarten
- If prefer A to B and B to C, must prefer A to C
- Ensures logical consistency in preference ordering
Assumption 3: Non-Satiation
- "More is always better" - economics gets power from this assumption
- 10th item always better than not having it
- Doesn't mean 10th item makes you equally happy as 9th
- If offered something for free, always take it
- Operates in world of goods (not bads like needle in eye)
Indifference Curves - Preference Maps
Simple Example Setup
- Two goods: pizza slices and cookies
- Choice A: 2 pizza slices, 1 cookie
- Choice B: 1 pizza slice, 2 cookies
- Choice C: 2 pizza slices, 2 cookies
- Assume indifferent between A and B, prefer C to both
Four Properties of Indifference Curves
Property 1: Higher Curves Preferred
- Further from origin = more preferred
- Follows from non-satiation principle
Property 2: Downward Sloping
- Must slope downward due to non-satiation
- Upward slope would violate "more is better"
- Can't be indifferent between less and more
Property 3: Never Cross
- Crossing violates transitivity and non-satiation
- If A~B and A~C, then B~C by transitivity
- But if B dominates C, can't be indifferent
- Mathematical impossibility
Property 4: One Curve Per Point
- Only one indifference curve through any given point
- Follows from completeness assumption
- Must know how you feel about each allocation
Real-World Application Example
- Graduate student job choice between Princeton vs Santa Cruz
- Two dimensions: school quality vs weather/location
- Princeton: great quality, mediocre weather
- Santa Cruz: lower quality, great weather
- Chose IMF (Washington DC): middle ground on both dimensions
- Illustrates personal preference mapping
Utility Functions - Mathematical Representation
Log Utility Function Example
- U = √(S × C) where S = pizza slices, C = cookies
- Mathematical representation of graphical indifference curves
- Consistent with example: √(2×1) = √(1×2) = √2, √(2×2) = 2
Cardinal vs Ordinal Utility
- Utility numbers meaningless cardinally
- Only ordinal ranking matters
- Utility of 3 vs 2 doesn't mean "50% better"
- Only for ranking choices, not measuring happiness levels
- Could use S×C, S²×C², etc. - same rankings
Diminishing Marginal Utility
Core Principle
- Fundamental driver of all consumer decisions
- More is better, but next unit not as good as previous
- Each additional unit provides less happiness
- 10th pizza slice less satisfying than 9th
- 5th cookie less satisfying than 4th
Mathematical Example
- Hold pizza slices constant at 2
- 1 cookie: utility = 1.4
- 2 cookies: utility = 2.0
- 3 cookies: utility = 2.45
- Incremental utility from each additional cookie falls
Real-World Sensibility
- Enormously sensible assumption
- Most people's preferences satisfy this principle
- Will drive mathematics throughout semester
- Some exceptions exist (increasing/constant marginal utility)
Marginal Rate of Substitution (MRS)
Definition and Concept
- Rate willing to trade good on y-axis for good on x-axis
- Slope of indifference curve at any point
- ΔS/ΔC = slope of indifference curve
- Key concept for entire class
Mathematical Relationship
- MRS = -MUc/MUs (negative ratio of marginal utilities)
- Ties mathematical functions to graphical curves
- Negative sign because marginal utilities are negative functions of quantity
- Utility positive function of quantity, marginal utility negative due to diminishing returns
Example Calculations
- For U = √(S×C):
- MUc = 0.5×S/√(S×C)
- MUs = 0.5×C/√(S×C)
- MRS = -S/C
MRS Along Indifference Curve
- Point A (4 slices, 1 cookie): MRS = -4
- Point B (2 slices, 2 cookies): MRS = -1
- Point C (1 slice, 4 cookies): MRS = -0.25
- MRS changes due to diminishing marginal utility
- At A: really want cookies, willing to give up 4 pizza slices
- At C: have too many cookies, only give up 0.25 pizza slices
Curve Shape and Diminishing MRS
- Indifference curves convex to origin (not concave)
- Driven by diminishing marginal rate of substitution
- As get fewer slices/more cookies: marginal utility of pizza rises, cookies falls
- Results in downward sloping, convex curves
Counterexample: Concave Curves
- Utility function: S² + C² = 65
- Would imply: with 8 pizza slices, 1 cookie, give up 1/8 slice for cookie
- But with 4 pizza slices, 7 cookies, give up 2 slices for cookie
- Doesn't make intuitive sense
- Why give up more pizza when you have less pizza?
Real-World Application: Beverage Sizing
Starbucks Example
- Tall iced coffee: $4.55
- Large (double size): additional $0.90
- Pay much less per ounce for larger size
McDonald's Example
- Small Coke: $2.29
- Large Coke (more than double): $2.99
- Companies recognize diminishing marginal utility
Business Logic
- Small satisfies most of thirst/caffeine need
- Large is better but not proportionally better
- Consumers won't pay proportionally more for additional quantity
- Marginal cost of inputs very low (3-4 cents for soda)
- Pricing reflects consumer diminishing marginal utility
