AI summary by TwinMind

Lec 2: Preferences and Utility Function

MIT OpenCourseWare

40m 48s

Course Introduction and Roadmap

  • Building demand curves from consumer behavior foundations
  • Previous lecture: created supply/demand curves without derivation
  • Today: start with demand curve origins through consumer preferences
  • Forget budget constraints initially - assume unlimited resources (won lottery scenario)

Three-Step Framework for Consumer Demand

  • Step 1: Write underlying assumptions about consumer preferences (axioms)
  • Step 2: Translate axioms into mathematical utility function
  • Step 3: Next lecture - introduce budget constraint for choice optimization

Three Key Assumptions of Consumer Preferences

Assumption 1: Completeness

  • Consumers have opinions on all possible choices
  • When faced with two options: prefer one, prefer other, or indifferent
  • Never respond "I don't know"
  • Complete set of preferences over all choices

Assumption 2: Transitivity

  • Standard mathematical principle from kindergarten
  • If prefer A to B and B to C, must prefer A to C
  • Ensures logical consistency in preference ordering

Assumption 3: Non-Satiation

  • "More is always better" - economics gets power from this assumption
  • 10th item always better than not having it
  • Doesn't mean 10th item makes you equally happy as 9th
  • If offered something for free, always take it
  • Operates in world of goods (not bads like needle in eye)

Indifference Curves - Preference Maps

Simple Example Setup

  • Two goods: pizza slices and cookies
  • Choice A: 2 pizza slices, 1 cookie
  • Choice B: 1 pizza slice, 2 cookies
  • Choice C: 2 pizza slices, 2 cookies
  • Assume indifferent between A and B, prefer C to both

Four Properties of Indifference Curves

Property 1: Higher Curves Preferred

  • Further from origin = more preferred
  • Follows from non-satiation principle

Property 2: Downward Sloping

  • Must slope downward due to non-satiation
  • Upward slope would violate "more is better"
  • Can't be indifferent between less and more

Property 3: Never Cross

  • Crossing violates transitivity and non-satiation
  • If A~B and A~C, then B~C by transitivity
  • But if B dominates C, can't be indifferent
  • Mathematical impossibility

Property 4: One Curve Per Point

  • Only one indifference curve through any given point
  • Follows from completeness assumption
  • Must know how you feel about each allocation

Real-World Application Example

  • Graduate student job choice between Princeton vs Santa Cruz
  • Two dimensions: school quality vs weather/location
  • Princeton: great quality, mediocre weather
  • Santa Cruz: lower quality, great weather
  • Chose IMF (Washington DC): middle ground on both dimensions
  • Illustrates personal preference mapping

Utility Functions - Mathematical Representation

Log Utility Function Example

  • U = √(S × C) where S = pizza slices, C = cookies
  • Mathematical representation of graphical indifference curves
  • Consistent with example: √(2×1) = √(1×2) = √2, √(2×2) = 2

Cardinal vs Ordinal Utility

  • Utility numbers meaningless cardinally
  • Only ordinal ranking matters
  • Utility of 3 vs 2 doesn't mean "50% better"
  • Only for ranking choices, not measuring happiness levels
  • Could use S×C, S²×C², etc. - same rankings

Diminishing Marginal Utility

Core Principle

  • Fundamental driver of all consumer decisions
  • More is better, but next unit not as good as previous
  • Each additional unit provides less happiness
  • 10th pizza slice less satisfying than 9th
  • 5th cookie less satisfying than 4th

Mathematical Example

  • Hold pizza slices constant at 2
  • 1 cookie: utility = 1.4
  • 2 cookies: utility = 2.0
  • 3 cookies: utility = 2.45
  • Incremental utility from each additional cookie falls

Real-World Sensibility

  • Enormously sensible assumption
  • Most people's preferences satisfy this principle
  • Will drive mathematics throughout semester
  • Some exceptions exist (increasing/constant marginal utility)

Marginal Rate of Substitution (MRS)

Definition and Concept

  • Rate willing to trade good on y-axis for good on x-axis
  • Slope of indifference curve at any point
  • ΔS/ΔC = slope of indifference curve
  • Key concept for entire class

Mathematical Relationship

  • MRS = -MUc/MUs (negative ratio of marginal utilities)
  • Ties mathematical functions to graphical curves
  • Negative sign because marginal utilities are negative functions of quantity
  • Utility positive function of quantity, marginal utility negative due to diminishing returns

Example Calculations

  • For U = √(S×C):
    • MUc = 0.5×S/√(S×C)
    • MUs = 0.5×C/√(S×C)
    • MRS = -S/C

MRS Along Indifference Curve

  • Point A (4 slices, 1 cookie): MRS = -4
  • Point B (2 slices, 2 cookies): MRS = -1
  • Point C (1 slice, 4 cookies): MRS = -0.25
  • MRS changes due to diminishing marginal utility
  • At A: really want cookies, willing to give up 4 pizza slices
  • At C: have too many cookies, only give up 0.25 pizza slices

Curve Shape and Diminishing MRS

  • Indifference curves convex to origin (not concave)
  • Driven by diminishing marginal rate of substitution
  • As get fewer slices/more cookies: marginal utility of pizza rises, cookies falls
  • Results in downward sloping, convex curves

Counterexample: Concave Curves

  • Utility function: S² + C² = 65
  • Would imply: with 8 pizza slices, 1 cookie, give up 1/8 slice for cookie
  • But with 4 pizza slices, 7 cookies, give up 2 slices for cookie
  • Doesn't make intuitive sense
  • Why give up more pizza when you have less pizza?

Real-World Application: Beverage Sizing

Starbucks Example

  • Tall iced coffee: $4.55
  • Large (double size): additional $0.90
  • Pay much less per ounce for larger size

McDonald's Example

  • Small Coke: $2.29
  • Large Coke (more than double): $2.99
  • Companies recognize diminishing marginal utility

Business Logic

  • Small satisfies most of thirst/caffeine need
  • Large is better but not proportionally better
  • Consumers won't pay proportionally more for additional quantity
  • Marginal cost of inputs very low (3-4 cents for soda)
  • Pricing reflects consumer diminishing marginal utility

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome