AI summary by TwinMind

Lec 4: Demand Curves and Income/Substitution Effects

MIT OpenCourseWare

46m 58s

Deriving Demand Curves from Utility Maximization

  • Started with utility function U = √(S × C) where S = pizza slices, C = cookies
  • Budget constraint: Y = PS × S + PC × C, with Y = $24, PS = $4, PC = $2
  • Optimal consumption found by setting MRSS = MRRT (tangency condition)
    • MRSS = -S/C, MRRT = -PC/PS = -1/2
    • Solved system: C* = 6, S* = 3 (Point A on Figure 4-1)

Price Changes and Demand Curve Construction

  • Changed cookie price from $2 to $3: new slope = -1/3
    • New optimization: -S/C = -1/3, budget: 24 = 4S + 3C
    • Result: C* = 4, S* = 3 (Point B)
  • Changed cookie price from $2 to $4/3: new slope = -3/4
    • Result: C* = 9, S* = 3 (Point C)
  • Pizza demand remained constant due to specific utility function properties
    • Called "flat price consumption curve" - cross-price effect = 0
    • Not general property, specific to this utility function

Elasticity of Demand

  • Definition: ε = (ΔQ/Q)/(ΔP/P) = (dQ/dP) × (P/Q)
  • Measures responsiveness of quantity demanded to price changes
  • Perfectly inelastic demand (ε = 0): vertical demand curve
    • Examples: insulin for diabetics, essential medicines
    • Goods with no substitutes
  • Perfectly elastic demand (ε = -∞): horizontal demand curve
    • Examples: luxury goods, McDonald's vs Burger King
    • Goods with many substitutes
  • Key insight: substitutability determines elasticity
    • More substitutes → more elastic demand
    • Fewer substitutes → less elastic demand

Income Changes and Engel Curves

  • Income increase from $24 to $32: parallel outward shift of budget constraint
    • Same tangency condition (prices unchanged)
    • New solution: C* = 8, S* = 4 (Point B on Figure 4-4)
  • Income decrease to $16: C* = 4, S* = 2 (Point C)
  • Engel curve: relationship between income and quantity demanded
  • Income elasticity γ = (ΔQ/Q)/(ΔY/Y)

Classification of Goods by Income Elasticity

  • Normal goods: γ > 0 (demand increases with income)
    • Necessities: 0 < γ < 1 (budget share decreases as income rises)
      • Examples: rent, basic clothing, food at home
    • Luxury goods: γ > 1 (budget share increases as income rises)
      • Examples: restaurant dining, expensive watches
  • Inferior goods: γ < 0 (demand decreases with income)
    • Example: ramen noodles - consumed when poor, avoided when rich
    • People substitute to better alternatives as income rises

Income and Substitution Effects Decomposition

  • When price changes, two simultaneous effects occur:
    1. Substitution effect: response to relative price change at constant utility
    2. Income effect: response to effective income change

Substitution Effect Analysis

  • Definition: ΔQ holding utility constant (ΔQ|U̅)
  • Measured using imaginary budget constraint BC'
    • Parallel to new budget constraint (same price ratio)
    • Tangent to original indifference curve (constant utility)
  • Always negative (opposite sign of price change)
  • Mathematical proof: At tangency MUC/MUS = PC/PS
    • If PC/PS rises, MUC/MUS must rise
    • Achieved by consuming fewer cookies (raising MUC) and more slices (lowering MUS)

Income Effect Analysis

  • Measures effect of purchasing power change
  • Price increase → effectively poorer → income effect depends on good type
  • Normal goods: income effect reinforces substitution effect
    • Both effects work in same direction
  • Inferior goods: income effect opposes substitution effect
    • Net effect depends on relative magnitudes

Giffen Goods (Theoretical Extreme)

  • Occur when income effect dominates substitution effect for inferior goods
  • Result: upward-sloping demand curve (higher price → higher quantity)
  • Largely theoretical/imaginary - don't exist in practice
  • Classic example debunked: Irish potato famine
    • Apparent increase in potato consumption per capita
    • Actually due to emigration of non-potato consumers
    • Demonstrates importance of proper empirical analysis

Summary Table of Effects

Normal Goods:

  • Price ↑: Substitution effect (-), Income effect (-), Net effect (-)
  • Price ↓: Substitution effect (+), Income effect (+), Net effect (+)

Inferior Goods:

  • Price ↑: Substitution effect (-), Income effect (+), Net effect (unclear)
  • Price ↓: Substitution effect (+), Income effect (-), Net effect (unclear)

Mathematical Framework

  • Substitution effect always has opposite sign of price change
  • Income effect sign depends on whether good is normal (γ > 0) or inferior (γ < 0)
  • Understanding decomposition crucial for later analysis of labor supply and savings decisions

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome