AI summary by TwinMind
Lec 4: Demand Curves and Income/Substitution Effects
MIT OpenCourseWare
46m 58s
Deriving Demand Curves from Utility Maximization
- Started with utility function U = √(S × C) where S = pizza slices, C = cookies
- Budget constraint: Y = PS × S + PC × C, with Y = $24, PS = $4, PC = $2
- Optimal consumption found by setting MRSS = MRRT (tangency condition)
- MRSS = -S/C, MRRT = -PC/PS = -1/2
- Solved system: C* = 6, S* = 3 (Point A on Figure 4-1)
Price Changes and Demand Curve Construction
- Changed cookie price from $2 to $3: new slope = -1/3
- New optimization: -S/C = -1/3, budget: 24 = 4S + 3C
- Result: C* = 4, S* = 3 (Point B)
- Changed cookie price from $2 to $4/3: new slope = -3/4
- Result: C* = 9, S* = 3 (Point C)
- Pizza demand remained constant due to specific utility function properties
- Called "flat price consumption curve" - cross-price effect = 0
- Not general property, specific to this utility function
Elasticity of Demand
- Definition: ε = (ΔQ/Q)/(ΔP/P) = (dQ/dP) × (P/Q)
- Measures responsiveness of quantity demanded to price changes
- Perfectly inelastic demand (ε = 0): vertical demand curve
- Examples: insulin for diabetics, essential medicines
- Goods with no substitutes
- Perfectly elastic demand (ε = -∞): horizontal demand curve
- Examples: luxury goods, McDonald's vs Burger King
- Goods with many substitutes
- Key insight: substitutability determines elasticity
- More substitutes → more elastic demand
- Fewer substitutes → less elastic demand
Income Changes and Engel Curves
- Income increase from $24 to $32: parallel outward shift of budget constraint
- Same tangency condition (prices unchanged)
- New solution: C* = 8, S* = 4 (Point B on Figure 4-4)
- Income decrease to $16: C* = 4, S* = 2 (Point C)
- Engel curve: relationship between income and quantity demanded
- Income elasticity γ = (ΔQ/Q)/(ΔY/Y)
Classification of Goods by Income Elasticity
- Normal goods: γ > 0 (demand increases with income)
- Necessities: 0 < γ < 1 (budget share decreases as income rises)
- Examples: rent, basic clothing, food at home
- Luxury goods: γ > 1 (budget share increases as income rises)
- Examples: restaurant dining, expensive watches
- Necessities: 0 < γ < 1 (budget share decreases as income rises)
- Inferior goods: γ < 0 (demand decreases with income)
- Example: ramen noodles - consumed when poor, avoided when rich
- People substitute to better alternatives as income rises
Income and Substitution Effects Decomposition
- When price changes, two simultaneous effects occur:
- Substitution effect: response to relative price change at constant utility
- Income effect: response to effective income change
Substitution Effect Analysis
- Definition: ΔQ holding utility constant (ΔQ|U̅)
- Measured using imaginary budget constraint BC'
- Parallel to new budget constraint (same price ratio)
- Tangent to original indifference curve (constant utility)
- Always negative (opposite sign of price change)
- Mathematical proof: At tangency MUC/MUS = PC/PS
- If PC/PS rises, MUC/MUS must rise
- Achieved by consuming fewer cookies (raising MUC) and more slices (lowering MUS)
Income Effect Analysis
- Measures effect of purchasing power change
- Price increase → effectively poorer → income effect depends on good type
- Normal goods: income effect reinforces substitution effect
- Both effects work in same direction
- Inferior goods: income effect opposes substitution effect
- Net effect depends on relative magnitudes
Giffen Goods (Theoretical Extreme)
- Occur when income effect dominates substitution effect for inferior goods
- Result: upward-sloping demand curve (higher price → higher quantity)
- Largely theoretical/imaginary - don't exist in practice
- Classic example debunked: Irish potato famine
- Apparent increase in potato consumption per capita
- Actually due to emigration of non-potato consumers
- Demonstrates importance of proper empirical analysis
Summary Table of Effects
Normal Goods:
- Price ↑: Substitution effect (-), Income effect (-), Net effect (-)
- Price ↓: Substitution effect (+), Income effect (+), Net effect (+)
Inferior Goods:
- Price ↑: Substitution effect (-), Income effect (+), Net effect (unclear)
- Price ↓: Substitution effect (+), Income effect (-), Net effect (unclear)
Mathematical Framework
- Substitution effect always has opposite sign of price change
- Income effect sign depends on whether good is normal (γ > 0) or inferior (γ < 0)
- Understanding decomposition crucial for later analysis of labor supply and savings decisions
