AI summary by TwinMind
Lec 9: Supply and Demand & Consumer/Producer Surplus
MIT OpenCourseWare
47m 21s
Course Introduction and Framework Setup
- New course section introducing normative economics (how things should be) vs positive economics (how things are)
- Return to supply and demand framework but with normative analysis tools
- Students now understand demand curves from consumer theory, supply curves from producer theory
- Should be able to derive curves from primitives (utility functions, prices, production functions)
Standard Market Analysis - Gas Market Example
- Figure 9.1: General gas market setup
- X-axis: quantity (gallons of gas)
- Y-axis: price (dollars per gallon)
- Demand curve: marginal willingness to pay for each unit
- Supply curve: producer's marginal willingness to supply each unit
- Demand slopes down (higher price → less willing to buy)
- Supply slopes up (higher price → more willing to supply)
- Equilibrium at P1, Q1 where supply equals demand (point E1)
Demand Shocks Analysis
- Example: Taste change toward big cars (SUVs, minivans)
- Big cars complement gasoline → increased gas demand
- Demand curve shifts outward from D1 to D2
- At unchanged price P1: excess demand (Q1' - Q1)
- Market equilibration: slide up supply curve from E1 to E2
- New equilibrium: higher price P2, higher quantity Q2
- Suppliers raise prices due to excess demand, consumers accept higher prices for more gas
Supply Shocks Analysis
- Example: War in Middle East increases gas production costs
- Higher marginal costs → supply curve shifts upward/inward
- At price P1: producers only supply Q1', consumers want Q1
- Creates excess demand again
- Slide up demand curve to new equilibrium E2
- Result: higher price P2, lower quantity Q2
Key Insight on Price Changes
- Price increases alone don't indicate if demand or supply shifted
- Need to observe both price AND quantity changes
- Demand shift: price up, quantity up
- Supply shift: price up, quantity down
- Critical for empirical economics analysis
Factors Causing Curve Shifts
Demand Curve Shifts (4 reasons):
- Income changes
- Price changes of complement goods
- Price changes of substitute goods
- Preference changes
Supply Curve Shifts (2 reasons):
- Input price changes
- Technology changes
Real-World Example: Kim Kardashian Corset Effect
- Kim Kardashian (more Instagram followers than France + England population) posted about exercising in corsets
- No scientific evidence for weight loss claims
- Massive demand surge for medieval corsets
- One corset company initially made huge profits
- Market response: new firms entered due to profits
- Eventually drove prices back down
- Most corset companies presumably bankrupt now
Elasticity Effects on Market Outcomes
- Market responses depend on demand and supply curve shapes
- Perfectly inelastic demand example: insulin for diabetics
- Supply shock → price rises, quantity unchanged
- Vertical demand curve
- Perfectly elastic demand example: McDonald's vs Burger King
- Supply shock → quantity changes, price unchanged
- Horizontal demand curve
Introduction to Welfare Economics
- Shift from positive to normative economics
- Welfare economics = normative side measuring societal well-being
- Problem: can't measure utils (utility is ordinal, not cardinal)
- Solution: compensating variation using revealed preference
- Ask how much money people would pay/accept for changes
- Measure welfare through willingness to pay rather than direct utility
Consumer Surplus Concept
- Benefit consumer gets above price paid
- Example: Killers concert tickets
- Marginal willingness to pay: $300
- Ticket price: $100
- Consumer surplus: $200
- Demand curve represents willingness to pay
- Consumer surplus = area under demand curve above price line
Individual vs Market Consumer Surplus
- Individual example (Figure 9.6): Personal demand for concerts
- First concert: ~$500 willingness to pay
- Fifth concert: ~$100 willingness to pay
- Diminishing marginal utility
- Market example (Figure 9.7): Gas market
- Each person wants one gallon (simplified)
- People line up by willingness to pay
- 1,000th consumer indifferent at $3/gallon
- Everyone left of person A gains welfare
- Triangle area = total consumer surplus
Consumer Surplus and Price Changes
- Figure 9.8: Price rise from $3.00 to $3.50/gallon
- Two effects:
- Fewer people buy (1,000 → 900 buyers)
- Remaining buyers get less surplus
- Lost consumer surplus = gray trapezoid
- Rectangle: reduced surplus for continuing buyers
- Triangle: lost surplus from non-buyers
Consumer Surplus and Demand Elasticity
- Figure 9.9: Two demand curves with different elasticities
- More elastic demand → smaller consumer surplus
- More inelastic demand → larger consumer surplus
- Perfectly elastic demand → zero surplus (McDonald's vs Burger King)
- Perfectly inelastic demand → maximum surplus (insulin example)
- Consumer surplus inversely related to demand elasticity
Producer Surplus Concept
- Difference between price received and willingness to supply
- If price > marginal cost → producer surplus
- Figure 9.10: Individual producer example
- Price = $3, quantity = 100 gallons
- First 99 units: price above marginal cost
- Shaded triangle = producer surplus
- In perfect competition: producer surplus = profit
- Marginal cost = average cost
- Price - average cost = profit
Market Producer Surplus
- Figure 9.11: Market supply curve analysis
- Most efficient producer (left): marginal cost ≈ 0, gets $3 → nearly all profit
- Marginal producer (point A): marginal cost = average cost = price = $3 → zero profit
- Heterogeneous firms create upward sloping supply curve
- Producer surplus = profits for all inframarginal firms
First Fundamental Theorem of Welfare Economics
- Paul Samuelson's "modestly" named theorem
- Bold statement: "Competition maximizes welfare"
- Welfare = consumer surplus + producer surplus
- Figure 9.12: Competitive equilibrium analysis
- Consumer surplus = R + V
- Producer surplus = S + T + U
- Total welfare maximized at equilibrium E1
Price Ceiling Example
- Government sets price ceiling at P2 (below equilibrium P1)
- Producers only supply Q2 (on supply curve)
- Effects on welfare:
- Consumer surplus: gains S, loses V → net change = S - V
- Producer surplus: loses S + U
- Transfer: S moves from producers to consumers
- Deadweight loss: V + U permanently lost
- Key insight: transfers don't affect total welfare, but lost trades do
Deadweight Loss Concept
- Net reduction in welfare from trades not made
- Occurs when mutually beneficial trades don't happen
- V + U areas represent welfare permanently destroyed
- Society worse off when beneficial trades prevented
- Competitive equilibrium avoids deadweight loss by enabling all mutually beneficial trades
Economic Philosophy Implications
- Economics fundamentally "right-wing science"
- Starts with "market knows best" principle
- Perfect competition assumptions lead to laissez-faire conclusions
- Example: kidney sales on eBay would increase welfare under these assumptions
- Future lectures will examine when assumptions break down (equity concerns, market failures)
