AI summary by TwinMind

Lec 9: Supply and Demand & Consumer/Producer Surplus

MIT OpenCourseWare

47m 21s

Course Introduction and Framework Setup

  • New course section introducing normative economics (how things should be) vs positive economics (how things are)
  • Return to supply and demand framework but with normative analysis tools
  • Students now understand demand curves from consumer theory, supply curves from producer theory
  • Should be able to derive curves from primitives (utility functions, prices, production functions)

Standard Market Analysis - Gas Market Example

  • Figure 9.1: General gas market setup
    • X-axis: quantity (gallons of gas)
    • Y-axis: price (dollars per gallon)
  • Demand curve: marginal willingness to pay for each unit
  • Supply curve: producer's marginal willingness to supply each unit
  • Demand slopes down (higher price → less willing to buy)
  • Supply slopes up (higher price → more willing to supply)
  • Equilibrium at P1, Q1 where supply equals demand (point E1)

Demand Shocks Analysis

  • Example: Taste change toward big cars (SUVs, minivans)
  • Big cars complement gasoline → increased gas demand
  • Demand curve shifts outward from D1 to D2
  • At unchanged price P1: excess demand (Q1' - Q1)
  • Market equilibration: slide up supply curve from E1 to E2
  • New equilibrium: higher price P2, higher quantity Q2
  • Suppliers raise prices due to excess demand, consumers accept higher prices for more gas

Supply Shocks Analysis

  • Example: War in Middle East increases gas production costs
  • Higher marginal costs → supply curve shifts upward/inward
  • At price P1: producers only supply Q1', consumers want Q1
  • Creates excess demand again
  • Slide up demand curve to new equilibrium E2
  • Result: higher price P2, lower quantity Q2

Key Insight on Price Changes

  • Price increases alone don't indicate if demand or supply shifted
  • Need to observe both price AND quantity changes
  • Demand shift: price up, quantity up
  • Supply shift: price up, quantity down
  • Critical for empirical economics analysis

Factors Causing Curve Shifts

Demand Curve Shifts (4 reasons):

  • Income changes
  • Price changes of complement goods
  • Price changes of substitute goods
  • Preference changes

Supply Curve Shifts (2 reasons):

  • Input price changes
  • Technology changes

Real-World Example: Kim Kardashian Corset Effect

  • Kim Kardashian (more Instagram followers than France + England population) posted about exercising in corsets
  • No scientific evidence for weight loss claims
  • Massive demand surge for medieval corsets
  • One corset company initially made huge profits
  • Market response: new firms entered due to profits
  • Eventually drove prices back down
  • Most corset companies presumably bankrupt now

Elasticity Effects on Market Outcomes

  • Market responses depend on demand and supply curve shapes
  • Perfectly inelastic demand example: insulin for diabetics
    • Supply shock → price rises, quantity unchanged
    • Vertical demand curve
  • Perfectly elastic demand example: McDonald's vs Burger King
    • Supply shock → quantity changes, price unchanged
    • Horizontal demand curve

Introduction to Welfare Economics

  • Shift from positive to normative economics
  • Welfare economics = normative side measuring societal well-being
  • Problem: can't measure utils (utility is ordinal, not cardinal)
  • Solution: compensating variation using revealed preference
  • Ask how much money people would pay/accept for changes
  • Measure welfare through willingness to pay rather than direct utility

Consumer Surplus Concept

  • Benefit consumer gets above price paid
  • Example: Killers concert tickets
    • Marginal willingness to pay: $300
    • Ticket price: $100
    • Consumer surplus: $200
  • Demand curve represents willingness to pay
  • Consumer surplus = area under demand curve above price line

Individual vs Market Consumer Surplus

  • Individual example (Figure 9.6): Personal demand for concerts
    • First concert: ~$500 willingness to pay
    • Fifth concert: ~$100 willingness to pay
    • Diminishing marginal utility
  • Market example (Figure 9.7): Gas market
    • Each person wants one gallon (simplified)
    • People line up by willingness to pay
    • 1,000th consumer indifferent at $3/gallon
    • Everyone left of person A gains welfare
    • Triangle area = total consumer surplus

Consumer Surplus and Price Changes

  • Figure 9.8: Price rise from $3.00 to $3.50/gallon
  • Two effects:
    • Fewer people buy (1,000 → 900 buyers)
    • Remaining buyers get less surplus
  • Lost consumer surplus = gray trapezoid
    • Rectangle: reduced surplus for continuing buyers
    • Triangle: lost surplus from non-buyers

Consumer Surplus and Demand Elasticity

  • Figure 9.9: Two demand curves with different elasticities
  • More elastic demand → smaller consumer surplus
  • More inelastic demand → larger consumer surplus
  • Perfectly elastic demand → zero surplus (McDonald's vs Burger King)
  • Perfectly inelastic demand → maximum surplus (insulin example)
  • Consumer surplus inversely related to demand elasticity

Producer Surplus Concept

  • Difference between price received and willingness to supply
  • If price > marginal cost → producer surplus
  • Figure 9.10: Individual producer example
    • Price = $3, quantity = 100 gallons
    • First 99 units: price above marginal cost
    • Shaded triangle = producer surplus
  • In perfect competition: producer surplus = profit
    • Marginal cost = average cost
    • Price - average cost = profit

Market Producer Surplus

  • Figure 9.11: Market supply curve analysis
  • Most efficient producer (left): marginal cost ≈ 0, gets $3 → nearly all profit
  • Marginal producer (point A): marginal cost = average cost = price = $3 → zero profit
  • Heterogeneous firms create upward sloping supply curve
  • Producer surplus = profits for all inframarginal firms

First Fundamental Theorem of Welfare Economics

  • Paul Samuelson's "modestly" named theorem
  • Bold statement: "Competition maximizes welfare"
  • Welfare = consumer surplus + producer surplus
  • Figure 9.12: Competitive equilibrium analysis
    • Consumer surplus = R + V
    • Producer surplus = S + T + U
    • Total welfare maximized at equilibrium E1

Price Ceiling Example

  • Government sets price ceiling at P2 (below equilibrium P1)
  • Producers only supply Q2 (on supply curve)
  • Effects on welfare:
    • Consumer surplus: gains S, loses V → net change = S - V
    • Producer surplus: loses S + U
    • Transfer: S moves from producers to consumers
    • Deadweight loss: V + U permanently lost
  • Key insight: transfers don't affect total welfare, but lost trades do

Deadweight Loss Concept

  • Net reduction in welfare from trades not made
  • Occurs when mutually beneficial trades don't happen
  • V + U areas represent welfare permanently destroyed
  • Society worse off when beneficial trades prevented
  • Competitive equilibrium avoids deadweight loss by enabling all mutually beneficial trades

Economic Philosophy Implications

  • Economics fundamentally "right-wing science"
  • Starts with "market knows best" principle
  • Perfect competition assumptions lead to laissez-faire conclusions
  • Example: kidney sales on eBay would increase welfare under these assumptions
  • Future lectures will examine when assumptions break down (equity concerns, market failures)

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome