AI summary by TwinMind
Lec10: Lorenz on fundamental ethology, part 2
MIT OpenCourseWare
48m 57s
Parasitic Birds and Mafia Hypothesis
- Parasitic birds (cuckoos) lay eggs in other birds' nests
- Host birds raise cuckoo chicks despite larger egg size, often at expense of own offspring
- Cuckoo chicks aggressive, push smaller chicks out of nest
- Mafia hypothesis: Study of spotted cuckoos and magpies in Spain
- When host birds destroy cuckoo eggs, "cuckoo mafia" destroys their entire nest
- Better to reproduce few offspring than none
- Verified in Spain through research
- Counter-strategies: Some songbirds build decoy nests above real nest
- Cuckoos typically lay in conspicuous upper nest
- Real nest below remains hidden
- Cuckoos exploit innate releasing mechanisms - host birds can't resist large gape of cuckoo chick
Human Parallels and Supernormal Stimuli
- Food industry exploits human preferences by adding extra saturated fat
- Fast food industry example: French fries designed to trigger taste preferences
- High fat content: digests slowly, raises blood sugar for hours, double calories of protein/carbohydrate
- Baby schema (Kindchenschema): Lorenz's work on infant features
- Larger head, larger eyes, short chubby limbs
- Elicits caregiving behavior across species
- Even aggressive males respond to baby stimuli
- Doll industry uses these features in design
- Risk of "uncanny valley" - line between cute and grotesque
Key Stimuli vs. Releasers
- Releaser definition: Stimulus property evolved specifically for communication
- Structure/movement evolved to send signals to same species
- Examples: showy color patterns, loud/regular sounds, rhythmic movements
- Human releasers:
- Smiling: Motor pattern evolved to elicit positive responses
- Baby features: Chubby cheeks with fat pads that disappear later
- Human breasts: Evolved larger than necessary for function
Mimicry Examples
- Monarch butterfly: Tastes terrible, other species mimic coloration
- Mouth breeder fish: Male has orange spots on anal fin mimicking female's eggs
- Female tries to collect "eggs" in mouth
- Male fertilizes real eggs directly in her mouth
- Baboon sexual mimicry: Males develop pink rump patches like females
- Female presentation inhibits male aggression
- Males use mimicry to turn off aggression from dominant males
- Hamster appeasement signals: White patches on chest, white underbelly
- Exposed to reduce aggression
- Covered when attacking
- Only fail in artificial cage situations where signals can't be properly displayed
Dummy Rule and Learning Effects
- Dummy rule: If simple model elicits fixed action pattern, indicates innate releasing mechanism
- Learning affects stimulus selectivity, not motor patterns
- Motor patterns can be linked in specific sequences
- Imprinting: Changes stimulus selectivity with experience
- Example: Turkey anti-predator response to overhead objects becomes more specific
Lorenz's Psycho-hydraulic Model
- Action specific potential: Motivation builds up like fluid in reservoir
- Original model: Simple reservoir with spring-loaded release mechanism
- Revised model: Added "readiness increasing stimuli"
- Don't trigger behavior alone but increase motivation
- Releasing stimuli act like adding fluid rapidly
- Endogenous input: Constantly building (like blinking reflex)
- Model resembled "flush toilet" - often mocked but functionally useful
Neural Basis of Fixed Action Patterns
- Low-level stimulation (spinal cord/hindbrain): Components only during stimulation
- High-level stimulation (hypothalamus/forebrain): Complete behavioral sequences persist after stimulation ends
- Transected animals: Only motor components, stop immediately when stimulation ends
- Intact animals: Full motivational states indistinguishable from natural behavior
- Examples: Cat predatory attack (quiet biting) vs. defensive attack (arching, vocalizing)
Inertia of Excitation
- Definition: Behavior continues after stimulus removal due to high motivation level
- Disney bear example: Bear stuck in log, emerges angry, continues aggressive behavior
- Human examples: Anger persists after TV stimulus removed, breaking objects
- Occurs with fear, aggression, sexual excitement
- Dog urination: Two separate motivations - bladder fullness vs. scent marking
- Males hold back urine for territorial marking
- Separate from elimination needs
Behavioral Chains - Kitten Nursing
- Sequence of innate behaviors:
- Search phase: Sideways head sweeping while creeping forward
- Contact phase: Snuggle against vertical surface, continue sweeping
- Fur contact: Stop forward motion, nose pressed to fur, continue sweeping
- Bare spot contact: Stop sweeping, initiate snapping to find nipple
- Suckling: Stop other movements, begin sucking and milk treading
- Each behavior provides stimulus for next component
- Components can be skipped if animal placed in appropriate situation
- Lorenz viewed as separate but linked fixed action patterns
Tinbergen's Hierarchical Model
- Information flow approach vs. Lorenz's hydraulic model
- Block mechanism: Prevents continuous discharge of motor patterns
- Innate releasing mechanism removes block rather than adding motivation
- Mutual inhibition: Different behaviors inhibit each other
- Stickleback example: Fighting, nesting, courtship, parental behavior
- Different stimuli activate different components
- Hierarchical organization from hormones to individual muscle fibers
- Broader scope than Lorenz model but less dynamic detail
Model Comparisons
- Tinbergen strengths: Information flow, hierarchical organization, popular with neurophysiologists
- Lorenz strengths: Focus on motivational dynamics, used in actual computer modeling
- Tinbergen weaknesses: Doesn't explain inertia effects, behavioral persistence
- Lorenz weaknesses: Mechanical analogy limitations, narrower scope
Digger Wasp Behavior Complexity
- Nesting behavior: Separate hole for each egg, multiple active nests
- Behavioral sequence:
- Inspect nest
- If empty: fly off to hunt food
- Return with prey
- Remember which nest needed provisioning
- Plasticity within innate structure: Learning integrated with fixed patterns
- Next behavior determined by nest inspection results
- Complex appearing behavior with innate foundation
Hierarchical Motivations - Upending Behavior
- Ducks/geese feeding: Upending (tail up, head underwater) separate motivation from hunger
- Well-fed birds deprived of upending opportunity will still perform behavior
- Action specific potential separate from hunger drive
- Similar to starling poking behavior, cactus finch spine use
- Multiple motivational systems can operate independently
Head Ganglion Evolution
- Lawrence's theory: Head evolved to limit behavior to one motor pattern at a time
- Functions:
- Embody innate releasing mechanisms
- Most stimuli enter through cranial nerves, not spinal
- Some tactile components (nursing) enter via spinal cord
- Higher vertebrate changes:
- Increased linkage between innate and learned behavior
- Learned motivations can initiate behavior patterns
- Cognitive level at top of hierarchy but not always dominant
- True intellectual definition: Cognitions actually affect behavior significantly
Taxes and Reflexes - Spatial Orientation
- Mantle of reflexes: Continuous adjustments make fixed patterns appear variable
- Walking example: Fixed motor pattern adjusted by visual, vestibular, tactile reflexes
- Egg-rolling behavior: Looks different each time due to terrain adjustments
- Reflexes never stop: Don't depend on motivation, always active
- Goldfish barrier problem:
- Positive telotaxis: Movement toward food
- Negative thigmotaxis: Avoidance of obstacles when touched
- Two reflexes create apparently intelligent problem-solving behavior
