AI summary by TwinMind
Lec21: Genetic influences on social behavior
MIT OpenCourseWare
39m 12s
Path Analysis Review
- Path analysis method for calculating probability that two related individuals share identical alleles at one locus
- Also called inbreeding coefficient or coefficient of kinship
- Used when family tree can be drawn to determine genetic relationships
Wilson's Population Genetics Concepts
- Effective population number: Number of individuals in ideal randomly breeding population (1:1 sex ratio) with same heterozygosity decrease rate as actual population
- Usually smallest number possible without significant inbreeding
- Ranges from as low as 10 in some species to closer to 100
- Wright's Island Model: Population divided into smaller isolated groups
- Genetic differences appear and maintained in different groups
- Advantage: if environmental change/new predators affect all groups, some will survive better due to genetic differences
- Opposed selection tendencies in small groups:
- Greater inbreeding chance → lowers individual fitness, genetic adaptability
- Greater altruistic behavior and cooperation among related individuals
- Assortative mating (homogamy): Tendency to choose mates similar to oneself
- Found in all animal groups including humans
- Increases gene sharing in limited number of genes affecting appearance
Genetic Determinism vs. Sociobiology
- Nature vs. nurture: Both always involved, never purely genetic determination
- Sociobiology focuses on population genetics (frequency changes) not developmental genetics (biochemical pathways)
- Critics incorrectly claim sociobiologists advocate "hereditary, fixed, inevitable, unchangeable" traits
- Ethology connection: Fixed action patterns are genetically influenced but depend on:
- Motivational levels
- Environmental variables
- Learning components (especially stimulus side)
Single Gene Effects on Behavior
- Multiplier effect model: One allele difference can create large behavioral differences through development
- Genetic difference interacts with environment throughout development
- Environmental effects on neural development amplify initial genetic differences
- Example: Big B vs. little b alleles leading to different adult behaviors
Selection Mechanisms for Allele Frequency Changes
- Death before reproductive age (differential survival)
- Behavioral differences reducing reproduction probability in specific environments
- Reduced parental care affecting offspring survival
- All require only probability differences, not absolute effects
Breeding for Behavioral Traits
- Laboratory examples:
- Cricket singing volume (loud vs. quiet strains)
- Fruit fly learning mutants by Chip Quinn: "dunce," "rutabaga," "turnip" strains
- Mouse spatial learning differences, nest building activity
- Rat maze learning: Hebb-Williams maze → "maze bright" vs. "maze dull" strains
- Agricultural breeding:
- Dogs: herding ability (sheep dogs), retrieving, pointing, hunting behaviors
- Farm animals: reduced aggression in cattle, enhanced egg-laying in chickens
- Horses: speed (thoroughbreds), quarter-mile racing, work capacity
- Bulls: breeding vs. fighting (Spain breeds for ferocity)
Problems with Single-Trait Breeding
- Behavioral problems appear when breeding only for physical traits
- Collie example: Breeding for narrow skulls/"needle nose" appearance resulted in "brainless ice picks" unlike original Lassie
- Cocker spaniels: increased epilepsy rates from appearance-focused breeding
- Importance of considering behavior during breeding programs
Human Behavioral Genetics
- Twin studies: Best evidence for genetic influences
- Concordance rates for identical twins
- Schizophrenia: ~67% concordance (not 100% = environmental factors involved)
- Type 1 diabetes: ~67% concordance
- Allows estimation of genetic vs. environmental contributions
- Criticism of "no genes found" argument:
- Quote from "Not in Our Genes" by Harvard Professor Lewontin, Rose claiming no genes related to human social behavior
- Absence of evidence ≠ evidence of absence
- Recent evidence for specific genes correlated with social behaviors
- Genes code for proteins, not behaviors directly
- Multiple genes always involved, environmental effects remain strong
Maladaptive Gene Persistence
- Why genes with negative effects persist in populations:
- Recent mutations (may be lost over time)
- Effects occur after reproductive age
- Effects only in certain environments
- Genetic swamping effects
- Personal example: Type 1 diabetes at age 24 (autoimmune, virus-triggered)
