AI summary by TwinMind

Lec21: Genetic influences on social behavior

MIT OpenCourseWare

39m 12s

Path Analysis Review

  • Path analysis method for calculating probability that two related individuals share identical alleles at one locus
  • Also called inbreeding coefficient or coefficient of kinship
  • Used when family tree can be drawn to determine genetic relationships

Wilson's Population Genetics Concepts

  • Effective population number: Number of individuals in ideal randomly breeding population (1:1 sex ratio) with same heterozygosity decrease rate as actual population
  • Usually smallest number possible without significant inbreeding
  • Ranges from as low as 10 in some species to closer to 100
  • Wright's Island Model: Population divided into smaller isolated groups
    • Genetic differences appear and maintained in different groups
    • Advantage: if environmental change/new predators affect all groups, some will survive better due to genetic differences
  • Opposed selection tendencies in small groups:
    • Greater inbreeding chance → lowers individual fitness, genetic adaptability
    • Greater altruistic behavior and cooperation among related individuals
  • Assortative mating (homogamy): Tendency to choose mates similar to oneself
    • Found in all animal groups including humans
    • Increases gene sharing in limited number of genes affecting appearance

Genetic Determinism vs. Sociobiology

  • Nature vs. nurture: Both always involved, never purely genetic determination
  • Sociobiology focuses on population genetics (frequency changes) not developmental genetics (biochemical pathways)
  • Critics incorrectly claim sociobiologists advocate "hereditary, fixed, inevitable, unchangeable" traits
  • Ethology connection: Fixed action patterns are genetically influenced but depend on:
    • Motivational levels
    • Environmental variables
    • Learning components (especially stimulus side)

Single Gene Effects on Behavior

  • Multiplier effect model: One allele difference can create large behavioral differences through development
  • Genetic difference interacts with environment throughout development
  • Environmental effects on neural development amplify initial genetic differences
  • Example: Big B vs. little b alleles leading to different adult behaviors

Selection Mechanisms for Allele Frequency Changes

  • Death before reproductive age (differential survival)
  • Behavioral differences reducing reproduction probability in specific environments
  • Reduced parental care affecting offspring survival
  • All require only probability differences, not absolute effects

Breeding for Behavioral Traits

  • Laboratory examples:
    • Cricket singing volume (loud vs. quiet strains)
    • Fruit fly learning mutants by Chip Quinn: "dunce," "rutabaga," "turnip" strains
    • Mouse spatial learning differences, nest building activity
    • Rat maze learning: Hebb-Williams maze → "maze bright" vs. "maze dull" strains
  • Agricultural breeding:
    • Dogs: herding ability (sheep dogs), retrieving, pointing, hunting behaviors
    • Farm animals: reduced aggression in cattle, enhanced egg-laying in chickens
    • Horses: speed (thoroughbreds), quarter-mile racing, work capacity
    • Bulls: breeding vs. fighting (Spain breeds for ferocity)

Problems with Single-Trait Breeding

  • Behavioral problems appear when breeding only for physical traits
  • Collie example: Breeding for narrow skulls/"needle nose" appearance resulted in "brainless ice picks" unlike original Lassie
  • Cocker spaniels: increased epilepsy rates from appearance-focused breeding
  • Importance of considering behavior during breeding programs

Human Behavioral Genetics

  • Twin studies: Best evidence for genetic influences
    • Concordance rates for identical twins
    • Schizophrenia: ~67% concordance (not 100% = environmental factors involved)
    • Type 1 diabetes: ~67% concordance
    • Allows estimation of genetic vs. environmental contributions
  • Criticism of "no genes found" argument:
    • Quote from "Not in Our Genes" by Harvard Professor Lewontin, Rose claiming no genes related to human social behavior
    • Absence of evidence ≠ evidence of absence
    • Recent evidence for specific genes correlated with social behaviors
    • Genes code for proteins, not behaviors directly
    • Multiple genes always involved, environmental effects remain strong

Maladaptive Gene Persistence

  • Why genes with negative effects persist in populations:
    • Recent mutations (may be lost over time)
    • Effects occur after reproductive age
    • Effects only in certain environments
    • Genetic swamping effects
  • Personal example: Type 1 diabetes at age 24 (autoimmune, virus-triggered)

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome