AI summary by TwinMind

Lecture 07: Estimation of Demand, Supply, and Market Power, Part 1

MIT OpenCourseWare

1h 6m 36s

Instructor Introduction and Course Overview

  • Instructor: Toia ZZ, office E52 fourth floor, office hours Thursdays 1-2pm
  • Background: PhD from NYU, worked at Columbia before MIT, was on sabbatical last year
  • Research interests: decentralized markets with frictions, digital markets/antitrust, consumer financial markets
  • Course goal: teach essentials of static demand models, focus on models currently used rather than historical evolution

Why Model Demand

  • Consumer welfare analysis for normative questions
  • Back out supply parameters (marginal cost, fixed cost) - cost data often unavailable
  • Firms consider opportunity costs (e.g., cannibalization) not captured in accounting data
  • Recent literature on rising markups in US economy (Yan Dela and Yan Eout paper)
  • Counterfactual analysis
  • Predict demand for new goods

Model Objectives and Constraints

  • Handle many products without restriction on number
  • Estimate with aggregate data (cannot see individual consumer purchases or link demographics)
  • Allow realistic substitution patterns (conflicts with aggregate data limitation)
  • Allow unobserved product characteristics (demand shocks) - things consumers/firms observe but researchers don't
  • Maintain computational tractability (conflicts with many products and realistic substitution)
  • These objectives often conflict with each other

Endogeneity Problem

  • Prices and quantities jointly determined in equilibrium
  • Price reflects unobserved information in error term
  • Price correlated with error term in demand equation
  • Solution: instrumental variables (supply/demand shifters)
  • Problem persists and becomes more complex in sophisticated models
  • Need more rather than fewer instruments for advanced models

Product Space vs Characteristic Space Approaches

Product Space Approach

  • Treat each product as unique entity
  • Demand system: quantities = f(all prices, all demand shocks)
  • Issue: curse of dimensionality - parameters grow at squared rate with new products
  • Each new product requires new row and column in coefficient matrix
  • Very demanding in terms of instruments (all prices potentially endogenous)
  • Cannot predict demand for new goods

Characteristic Space Approach

  • Products described by characteristics (horsepower, storage, features, etc.)
  • Combined with discrete choice framework
  • Consumers buy one product or none
  • Build from utility functions - consumers choose product maximizing utility
  • Adding products doesn't necessarily increase parameters if characteristics observed

Discrete Choice Framework

  • Utility function: U = observed attributes + unobserved attributes + demographics + random shifters
  • Consumers choose product with highest utility
  • Random part (epsilon) helps explain different consumer choices
  • Market shares determined by choice regions in epsilon space

Logit Model Solution

  • Assume type 1 extreme value distribution for epsilon terms
  • Provides closed-form solution for choice probabilities
  • Market share = exp(utility_j) / sum(exp(utility_k) for all k)
  • Normalization: outside good utility = 0
  • Outside good = everything else consumers could do instead

Data Requirements

  • Aggregate market shares, prices, product attributes for each market
  • Distributions of consumer characteristics (not linked to specific purchases)
  • From census data or similar sources
  • Instruments needed for endogenous prices
  • Assume no sampling uncertainty in market shares
  • Requires judgment on market size definition

Simple Logit Model Limitations

  • Unrealistic substitution patterns
  • Cross-price elasticity only function of price coefficient and market shares
  • Diversion ratios only depend on market shares
  • Example: Yugo (10% share) and Lexus (10% share) would have identical substitution patterns
  • Problem: only epsilon terms (IID) drive different choices
  • Doesn't capture that Lexus buyers systematically different from Yugo buyers

Random Coefficient Model (BLP)

  • Utility: U_ijt = X_jt * beta_i + alpha_i * p_jt + xi_jt + epsilon_ijt
  • Coefficients vary across consumers (beta_i, alpha_i)
  • Allows different consumers to value attributes and prices differently
  • Coefficients = intercept + demographics + random component
  • Don't observe individual consumer characteristics, only market distributions

Model Components

  • Delta_jt = average product quality (X_jt * beta_bar + xi_jt)
  • mu_ijt = consumer-specific deviations from average
  • Market shares require integration over consumer distribution
  • Much more complex than simple logit

Why Random Coefficients Needed

  • Unobserved product characteristics (xi) needed to explain market patterns
  • Example: Apple higher prices/shares despite inferior observable attributes
  • Creates endogeneity: firms know xi and price accordingly
  • Random coefficients allow realistic substitution patterns
  • People with higher income less price sensitive, prefer luxury features
  • Elasticity formulas become complex integrals over consumer distributions

Consumer Welfare

  • Inclusive value formula for expected welfare before epsilon draws
  • Convert to dollars by dividing by price coefficient
  • Integrate over consumer distribution in random coefficient model
  • Issue: welfare implications from adding/removing products due to "epsilon harvesting"
  • Random coefficients may ameliorate this problem through local substitution

Instrumental Variables for BLP

Simple Logit vs BLP

  • Simple logit: one instrument sufficient (linear after transformation)
  • BLP: need multiple instruments due to nonlinear parameters
  • Supply shifter alone insufficient to identify substitution patterns

Types of Instruments

  • Different markets: Presence/absence of competitors (concern: endogenous entry)
  • Cost shifters: Material costs, distribution costs, tariffs, taxes (often unavailable)
  • Hausman instruments: Firm's prices in other markets (concern: demand correlation across markets)
  • BLP instruments: Attributes of other products in market (concern: endogenous product attributes)
  • Waldfogel instruments: Zone pricing with demographic variation (concern: correlated demographics)

Estimation Procedure

  • Estimate via GMM: minimize weighted sum of moment conditions
  • Moments: instruments interacted with error term (xi)
  • Two-loop algorithm:
    • Outer loop: Search over nonlinear parameters (Theta2)
    • Inner loop: Solve for deltas using contraction mapping
  • Contraction mapping: iteratively update delta using difference between observed and predicted shares
  • Converges to unique solution for any guess of nonlinear parameters
  • Linear parameters (beta, alpha) estimated via regression once deltas known
  • Many implementation details and potential failure modes

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome