AI summary by TwinMind

Lecture 11: The IS-LM-PC Model

MIT OpenCourseWare

49m 27s

Silicon Valley Bank Crisis Current Events Discussion

  • Silicon Valley Bank (SVB): 16th largest bank by asset size in US ($209 billion assets)
  • Shut down by FDIC last Friday due to bank run
  • Comparable size to Washington Mutual (largest bank failure during 2008 financial crisis)
  • Stock declined dramatically Thursday-Friday before trading suspension

Immediate Cause of Failure

  • Bank run by depositors (classic mechanism that kills banks)
  • SVB grew enormously over 2-3 years, doubled asset size
  • Net deposit outflows during 2022 due to tech sector difficulties
    • Bank primarily served tech startups/companies
    • Tech sector struggling to raise capital in unfriendly environment
    • Companies withdrawing deposits to fund operations

Asset-Liability Mismatch Problem

  • SVB bought 10-year Treasury bonds (safest investments) at wrong time
  • Purchased right before 2022 interest rate hikes began
  • Rising interest rates caused bond prices to decline
  • Banks don't need to recognize losses unless they sell bonds
  • When deposit withdrawals required asset sales, had to recognize $2.5 billion loss
  • CEO announced need for fundraising to cover losses
  • Social media spread news rapidly, triggering massive withdrawal attempts

Deposit Insurance Issue

  • US deposits insured up to $250,000 by FDIC
  • ~95% of SVB deposits were above insurance limit (business deposits from startups)
  • Uninsured depositors had strong incentive to withdraw funds
  • Venture capital funds called portfolio companies advising withdrawal
  • Coordination failure: rational individual behavior created collective problem

Government Response

  • Weekend intervention to prevent contagion
  • All deposits (including uninsured) guaranteed by FDIC
  • Fed created new credit line for banks to avoid forced asset sales
  • Banks can pledge assets to Fed for cash without marking to market

Market Impact

  • VIX (volatility index) spiked Thursday-Friday, indicating investor fear
  • Credit spreads widened, especially for financial sector
  • First Republic Bank shares declined 60%
  • Fed funds rate expectations dropped dramatically:
    • Pre-crisis: ~40 basis points expected hike (50 bp likely)
    • Post-crisis: 15 basis points expected (many expecting pause)

Regulatory and Policy Lessons

  • Regulatory failure: SF Fed should have monitored rapid growth
  • Dodd-Frank rollbacks in 2018 reduced oversight for mid-size banks
  • SVB lobbied to raise stress-test threshold, avoided strict regulation
  • Diversification failures: depositors, funding sources, geographic concentration
  • Interest rate risk from rapid monetary tightening

IS-LM-PC Model Introduction

Model Components

  • Combines IS-LM model with Phillips Curve
  • Analyzes short-run vs medium-run dynamics
  • Fed now assumed to set real interest rate directly (r̄)
  • IS-LM equation: Y = C(Y-T) + I(Y,r̄) + G

Phillips Curve Transformation

  • Original: π - πᵉ = -α(u - uₙ)
  • Converted to output gap: π - πᵉ = α(Y - Yₙ)/L
  • Output gap = Y - Yₙ (actual minus potential output)
  • When Y > Yₙ: inflation exceeds expected inflation
  • When Y < Yₙ: inflation below expected inflation

Natural Rate of Interest (r*)

  • Real interest rate that makes potential output the IS-LM equilibrium
  • Also called neutral rate, Wicksellian rate, "r-star"
  • Determined by real factors, not monetary policy
  • Economy must eventually converge to this rate

Short-Run vs Medium-Run Analysis

Short-Run Dynamics

  • IS-LM determines output for given real interest rate
  • If r̄ < r*: output above potential, rising inflation
  • If r̄ > r*: output below potential, falling inflation
  • Phillips curve shows inflationary pressure direction

Medium-Run Adjustment

  • Fed responds to inflation by adjusting interest rates
  • Must eventually set r̄ = r* for stable inflation
  • Real variables determined by real sector in medium run
  • Monetary policy affects nominal variables only

Expected Inflation Scenarios

Unanchored Expectations (πᵉ = π₋₁)

  • Dangerous scenario for central banks
  • If inflation rises to 9%, expected inflation also rises to 9%
  • To return to 2% target, Fed must cause recession
  • Need negative inflation gap to bring down expected inflation
  • Requires output significantly below potential

Anchored Expectations (πᵉ = π̄ = 2%)

  • Preferred scenario for central banks
  • Even if inflation temporarily rises to 9%
  • Fed only needs to return to r* to stabilize at target
  • No recession required, just slower growth
  • Maintains credibility crucial for this outcome

US Experience 2020-2022

  • Real interest rates too low for extended period
  • Combination of factors:
    • Potential output declined due to COVID
    • Massive fiscal support and pent-up demand
    • Supply chain disruptions
  • Fed "behind the curve" - should have raised rates sooner
  • Resulted in inflation rising from 2% to 9%

Key Economic Principles

Neutrality of Money

  • Short run: monetary policy affects real variables
  • Medium/long run: monetary policy only affects nominal variables
  • Real interest rate (r*) determined by real factors
  • Fed chooses nominal rate consistent with desired real rate and inflation target

Policy Trade-offs

  • Credibility essential for effective monetary policy
  • Anchored expectations reduce costs of fighting inflation
  • Rapid rate changes can break fragile institutions
  • Balance between fighting inflation and financial stability

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome