AI summary by TwinMind
Lecture 11: The IS-LM-PC Model
MIT OpenCourseWare
49m 27s
Silicon Valley Bank Crisis Current Events Discussion
- Silicon Valley Bank (SVB): 16th largest bank by asset size in US ($209 billion assets)
- Shut down by FDIC last Friday due to bank run
- Comparable size to Washington Mutual (largest bank failure during 2008 financial crisis)
- Stock declined dramatically Thursday-Friday before trading suspension
Immediate Cause of Failure
- Bank run by depositors (classic mechanism that kills banks)
- SVB grew enormously over 2-3 years, doubled asset size
- Net deposit outflows during 2022 due to tech sector difficulties
- Bank primarily served tech startups/companies
- Tech sector struggling to raise capital in unfriendly environment
- Companies withdrawing deposits to fund operations
Asset-Liability Mismatch Problem
- SVB bought 10-year Treasury bonds (safest investments) at wrong time
- Purchased right before 2022 interest rate hikes began
- Rising interest rates caused bond prices to decline
- Banks don't need to recognize losses unless they sell bonds
- When deposit withdrawals required asset sales, had to recognize $2.5 billion loss
- CEO announced need for fundraising to cover losses
- Social media spread news rapidly, triggering massive withdrawal attempts
Deposit Insurance Issue
- US deposits insured up to $250,000 by FDIC
- ~95% of SVB deposits were above insurance limit (business deposits from startups)
- Uninsured depositors had strong incentive to withdraw funds
- Venture capital funds called portfolio companies advising withdrawal
- Coordination failure: rational individual behavior created collective problem
Government Response
- Weekend intervention to prevent contagion
- All deposits (including uninsured) guaranteed by FDIC
- Fed created new credit line for banks to avoid forced asset sales
- Banks can pledge assets to Fed for cash without marking to market
Market Impact
- VIX (volatility index) spiked Thursday-Friday, indicating investor fear
- Credit spreads widened, especially for financial sector
- First Republic Bank shares declined 60%
- Fed funds rate expectations dropped dramatically:
- Pre-crisis: ~40 basis points expected hike (50 bp likely)
- Post-crisis: 15 basis points expected (many expecting pause)
Regulatory and Policy Lessons
- Regulatory failure: SF Fed should have monitored rapid growth
- Dodd-Frank rollbacks in 2018 reduced oversight for mid-size banks
- SVB lobbied to raise stress-test threshold, avoided strict regulation
- Diversification failures: depositors, funding sources, geographic concentration
- Interest rate risk from rapid monetary tightening
IS-LM-PC Model Introduction
Model Components
- Combines IS-LM model with Phillips Curve
- Analyzes short-run vs medium-run dynamics
- Fed now assumed to set real interest rate directly (r̄)
- IS-LM equation: Y = C(Y-T) + I(Y,r̄) + G
Phillips Curve Transformation
- Original: π - πᵉ = -α(u - uₙ)
- Converted to output gap: π - πᵉ = α(Y - Yₙ)/L
- Output gap = Y - Yₙ (actual minus potential output)
- When Y > Yₙ: inflation exceeds expected inflation
- When Y < Yₙ: inflation below expected inflation
Natural Rate of Interest (r*)
- Real interest rate that makes potential output the IS-LM equilibrium
- Also called neutral rate, Wicksellian rate, "r-star"
- Determined by real factors, not monetary policy
- Economy must eventually converge to this rate
Short-Run vs Medium-Run Analysis
Short-Run Dynamics
- IS-LM determines output for given real interest rate
- If r̄ < r*: output above potential, rising inflation
- If r̄ > r*: output below potential, falling inflation
- Phillips curve shows inflationary pressure direction
Medium-Run Adjustment
- Fed responds to inflation by adjusting interest rates
- Must eventually set r̄ = r* for stable inflation
- Real variables determined by real sector in medium run
- Monetary policy affects nominal variables only
Expected Inflation Scenarios
Unanchored Expectations (πᵉ = π₋₁)
- Dangerous scenario for central banks
- If inflation rises to 9%, expected inflation also rises to 9%
- To return to 2% target, Fed must cause recession
- Need negative inflation gap to bring down expected inflation
- Requires output significantly below potential
Anchored Expectations (πᵉ = π̄ = 2%)
- Preferred scenario for central banks
- Even if inflation temporarily rises to 9%
- Fed only needs to return to r* to stabilize at target
- No recession required, just slower growth
- Maintains credibility crucial for this outcome
US Experience 2020-2022
- Real interest rates too low for extended period
- Combination of factors:
- Potential output declined due to COVID
- Massive fiscal support and pent-up demand
- Supply chain disruptions
- Fed "behind the curve" - should have raised rates sooner
- Resulted in inflation rising from 2% to 9%
Key Economic Principles
Neutrality of Money
- Short run: monetary policy affects real variables
- Medium/long run: monetary policy only affects nominal variables
- Real interest rate (r*) determined by real factors
- Fed chooses nominal rate consistent with desired real rate and inflation target
Policy Trade-offs
- Credibility essential for effective monetary policy
- Anchored expectations reduce costs of fighting inflation
- Rapid rate changes can break fragile institutions
- Balance between fighting inflation and financial stability
