AI summary by TwinMind
Lecture 12: IS-LM-PC Model continued
MIT OpenCourseWare
46m 5s
IS-LM-PC Model Introduction
- Integration of IS-LM analysis with Phillips curve
- Central bank controls real interest rate (assumption for simplicity)
- Output gap concept: difference between actual output and potential output
- Potential output = output when employment at natural rate
- Output gap related to employment gap through production function
- Phillips curve in inflation-output gap space integrates easily with IS-LM model
IS-LM-PC Model Components
- Combines IS-LM equilibrium equation with Phillips curve equation
- Includes model of expected inflation
- Example: unanchored inflation expectations model
- Change in inflation = function of output gap
- Upward sloping relationship: higher output → more employment → wage pressure → price pressure → inflation
Short-Run vs Medium-Run Dynamics
- Short run: equilibrium output determined by IS-LM intersection
- May not equal potential output
- Creates inflation/disinflation pressures
- Medium run: output converges back to natural rate/potential output
- Central bank reacts to inflation changes
- Natural rate of interest (R*): rate that gives equilibrium output equal to potential output
Anchored vs Unanchored Expectations
- Unanchored expectations scenario:
- Inflation rises from 2% to 9% due to above-potential output
- Fed raises rates to natural rate → inflation stops rising but stays at 9%
- To return to 2% target, Fed must cause recession (output below potential)
- Anchored expectations allow "soft landing" without severe recession
- Central bank credibility crucial for maintaining anchored expectations
Monetary Policy Implementation Challenges
- Milton Friedman: "monetary policy acts with long and variable lags"
- Difficult to know potential output/natural unemployment rate in real time
- Inflation signals whether economy above/below potential
- Policy transmission takes time, creating timing challenges
- Recent Fed concern: aggressive rate hikes may hit economy too hard with lag
Deflationary Trap Risk
- Occurs when natural interest rate is negative but nominal rate constrained by zero lower bound
- Real interest rate = nominal rate - expected inflation
- Negative inflation → positive real rate → further economic contraction
- Creates self-reinforcing deflationary spiral
- Great Depression example: 1929-1933
- Unemployment low initially, nominal rates ~5%, inflation ~0%
- Fed lowered nominal rates slowly as deflation deepened
- Real rates rose despite nominal rate cuts
- Reached -10% deflation, making real rates very high
Aggregate Demand Shocks Analysis
- Fiscal consolidation example:
- IS curve shifts left (reduced government spending/higher taxes)
- Output falls below potential → deflationary forces
- Central bank responds by cutting rates
- Medium run: output returns to potential with lower real interest rate
- Speed of adjustment varies, can cause prolonged recessions
Supply-Side Shocks Analysis
- Oil/energy shocks modeled as markup increases
- Increases natural rate of unemployment → reduces potential output
- Phillips curve shifts left (higher inflation for same output level)
- Short run: inflation rises before output falls
- Central bank response: raise rates to new higher natural rate
- COVID recovery: supply chain disruptions initially thought temporary
- Fed delayed response expecting self-correction
- Some disruptions persisted longer than expected
- Europe: massive energy shock from geopolitical events
Silicon Valley Bank Crisis Application
- Modeled as credit shock (X parameter increase)
- IS curve shifts left: higher borrowing costs for given safe rate
- Creates deflationary forces
- Market anticipation of Fed response despite ongoing inflation concerns
Market Response to Banking Crisis
- One-year inflation expectations collapsed from rising trend
- Expected Fed hikes dropped from 45 basis points to 13 basis points
- Markets shifted from expecting 50bp hike to pricing no hike/possible cut
- Demonstrates market understanding of IS-LM-PC mechanics
Credit Suisse Crisis Development
- 35% equity decline in single day
- Credit default swaps spiked dramatically
- European bank stocks declined significantly
- VIX (fear index) spiked sharply
- Flight to quality: deposits moving from small/regional banks to major banks
Banking System Implications
- Small/regional banks provide >50% of commercial/industrial loans
- 80% of mortgages from small banks
- Potential prolonged credit tightening (sustained high X)
- Systemic risk from deposit flight to large banks
Market Expectations Shift
- Previous path: Fed funds rate peak at 5.3% in June, gradual cuts
- New path: small hikes, peak in May, aggressive cuts by year-end
- One-year rates dropped 60 basis points (major change)
- Market pricing aggressive Fed response to financial stability concerns
Policy Dilemma
- Dual challenges: financial panic + high inflation (5.5%)
- Without high inflation, Fed would cut rates immediately
- High inflation provides policy space (can cut real rates to -5%)
- Delayed reaction due to inflation concerns but more space for aggressive cuts if needed
